use_cases.adoc

1. Use cases

The use of ClaimReview and MediaReview applies to the following use cases:

1. A declaration published on a single link.

2. A statement published in several places.

3. Several statements.

4. A statement with a media review.

All examples are accessible on the GitHub project: https://github.com/AFP-Medialab/defacto-rss/tree/main/examples

1.1. Case 1: A single statement published on a single link

ClaimReview	appearance
Video shows Russian soldiers landing in Ukraine in 2022	https://www.facebook.com/kashmirnews1658/videos/728945791437637/

Example 1 - ClaimReview from a URL

link:../examples/claimReview/simple-en.json[role=include]

Example 2 - ClaimReview from a VideoObject

link:../examples/claimReview/videoobject-en.json[role=include]

1.2. Case 2: Fact-check on a declaration published in several places

Several links to documents for the same claim: the same declaration was taken up in several places.

ClaimReview	appearance
EU riot police on the Champs-Elysées	https://twitter.com/LoupnoirAlpha/status/1493483404276420612/photo/1
	https://www.facebook.com/151335048220780/posts/2139858189368446/

Example 1 - Claim Review simple multi appearances

link:../examples/claimReview/multi-appearance-url-en.json[role=include]

Example 2 - ClaimReview with CreativeWork multi appearance and archived pages

link:../examples/claimReview/multi-appearance-archive-en.json[role=include]

1.3. Case 3: Multiple claim reviews for one thematic Fact-Checking wrap-up

A thematic wrap-up may include multiple claims.
Multiple claimReviews for a same thematic FactCheck wrap-up article are possible but be aware that the whole article will not be eligible for the single fact check rich result on Google search. Nevertheless, it may be useful to keep those multiple ClaimReviews into your CMS and to build databases.

Theme	Source
Manipulated videos, recycled photos: renewed disinformation about the Russian-Ukrainian conflict	https://factuel.afp.com/doc.afp.com.323Q7N9

ClaimReview	appearance
a girl on a bus in Ukraine (…​) waiting for Russian soldiers	https://twitter.com/terror_alarm/status/1492596807544750082/photo/1
Ukrainian troops preparing for potential combat	https://weibo.com/1650926392/LbMiODUqI?refer_flag=1001030103_
BBC warning of imminent nuclear war in Eastern Europe	https://www.facebook.com/104681915311714/videos/686860666025235/?_rdc=1&_rdr
	https://www.facebook.com/toscoentertianment/videos/1307046023053075/?_rdc=1&_rdr

Example - Multiple claim reviews

link:../examples/claimReview/multi-claimreview-en.json[role=include]

1.4. Case 4: A ClaimReview with media review

The example below shows the use of a MediaReview item in a ClaimReview.
The associatedMediaReview property replaces the itemReview property in the ClaimReview.

ClaimReview	MediaReview: EditedOrCroppedContent
Vladimir Putin ignored Emmanuel Macron’s handshake.	https://www.facebook.com/100063486369524/videos/2008381422654312
	https://twitter.com/baa3465dd891455/status/1486057108307066880
	https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=985014695406486

Example - AssociateMediaReview

link:../examples/claimReview/claimreview-with-mediareview-en.json[role=include]

1.5. Case 5: A ClaimReview from social media with interaction statistics

ClaimReview	appearance: SocialPostMedia
Le GIEC écrit que la mer va monter de 15 mères. Elle monte de combien la mer ? Le GIEC le dit : de deux millimères par an. [ …​] Au bout de cinquante ans, vous aurez 10 centimères.	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkuCBxIbZ_g

Example below show a claim from a Youtube video. It shows claim social interactions (like, comments, shares, etc ) on different platforms. .Example - InteractionStatistics

link:../examples/claimReview/mutli-interactionStatistic.json[role=include]