Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
1052 lines (784 loc) · 63.5 KB

README.md

File metadata and controls

1052 lines (784 loc) · 63.5 KB
Raw

What is hoardy-mail?

hoardy-mail is a tool that can help you to very quickly fetch your email from a remote IMAP server to a file system on your local disk drive, programmatically change flags on messages on the IMAP server (e.g. mark all messages newer than a day old in some folder as unread), delete or expire old messages from the IMAP server, and do other similar things.

Or, more formally, hoardy-mail is a utility that can fetch and/or perform various batch operations on messages residing on specified IMAP servers. That is, for each given server: login, fetch or perform specified actions (count, flag/mark, delete, etc) on all messages matching specified criteria in all specified folders, logout.

Or, in comparison to other things, hoardy-mail is an advanced but fairly KISS (Keep It Stupid Simple) replacement for a combination of fetchmail/getmail and IMAPExpire, with additional features, and written in pure Python.

Highlights of hoardy-mail:

  • By default, it fetches mail more than 150 times faster and (when using --maildir option) generates ~150 times less disk writes than fetchmail and getmail while keeping to all the usual "only mark/delete messages on the server after they are fsynced to disk" guarantees. It does this by batching IMAP fetches and disk writes. You can make it as fast as you like, if your IMAP server supports longer command lines, thus allowing for larger batches.

  • It can do its supported actions as one operation per invocation of hoardy-mail, but it can also do a bunch of those actions sequentially from under a single connection to an IMAP server. This is much cleaner and faster when you want to do complex things like "fetch all new mail and then, if everything was okay, delete previously fetched mail older than 3 days".

  • It will not lose any of your mail regardless of network connections failing unexpectedly, your IMAP server generating errors at unexpected times, other simultaneous IMAP clients making incompatible changes that could lead to future data loss, your disk failing while hoardy-mail tries to fsync your data, you calling hoardy-mail with wrong command line arguments, ... In short, hoardy-mail is very careful about things.

  • It has a nice CLI UI and it can also generate desktop notifications (via notify-send) about things breaking or just happening.

hoardy-mail was previously knows as imaparms.

Screenshot

Click the above image to see the full terminal recording video of hoardy-mail invocation that also runs new-mail-hook indexing new mail with notmuch (see workflow example below), followed by a full-text search in Emacs UI of notmuch. (hoardy-mail was named imaparms at the point the recording was made. The account data was edited out and replaced by fake GMail accounts in post-processing.)

It was recorded on a 2013-era laptop (Thinkpad X230 with Intel Core i5-3230M CPU @ 2.60GHz upgraded with 16GB RAM and Samsung 870 EVO SSD), my notmuch database contains ~4 millions messages, and the whole search takes only 0.25 seconds in person (but about 2 seconds in the video because rendering an asciinema file to gif and then compressing it into webm adds extra time between frames, so it looks much more laggy than it actually is at the end there).

Why does hoardy-mail exist?

If all your email experience can be summarized as "I do all my mail in GMail or similar" or if you don't know what a Maildir is, you should start with this section below to learn why you might want to do the following.

If you

... effectively, you are using IMAP as a mail delivery protocol, not like a mail access protocol it was designed to be.

In which case you might ask yourself, wouldn't it be nice if there was a tool that could help you automate fetching of new messages and deletion of already backed up old messages from IMAP servers in such a way that any of your own systems crashing or losing hard drives at any point in time would not lose any of your mail?

hoardy-mail is a replacement for fetchmail/getmail that does this (and more, but mainly this).

Why would you make a replacement for fetchmail/getmail?

hoardy-mail was inspired by fetchmail and IMAPExpire and is basically a safe generalized combination of the two.

I used to use and (usually privately, but sometimes not) patch both fetchmail and IMAPExpire for years before getting tired of it and deciding it would be simpler to just write my own thingy instead of trying to make fetchmail fetch mail at decent speeds and fix all the issues making it unsafe and inconvenient to run IMAPExpire immediately after fetchmail finishes fetching mail. The main problem is that fetchmail fetches yet-unfetched mail, while IMAPExpire expires old mail. When fetchmail gets stuck or crashes it is entirely possible for IMAPExpire to delete some old yet-unfetched messages. (And getmail suffers from exactly the same problems.)

In short, hoardy-mail is designed to be used as a IMAP-server-to-local-Maildir Mail Delivery Agent (MDA) that makes the IMAP server in question store as little mail as possible while preventing data loss.

Which is to say, the main use case I made this for is as follows:

  • you periodically fetch your mail to a local Maildir with this tool's hoardy-mail fetch subcommand (which does what fetchmail --softbounce --invisible --norewrite --mda MDA does but much faster), then
  • you backup your Maildir with syncthing/bup/rsync/git/etc to make at least one other copy somewhere, and then, after your backup succeeds,
  • you run this tool's hoardy-mail delete subcommand to expire old already-fetched messages from the server (I prefer to expire messages --older-than some number of intervals between backups, just to be safe, but if you do backups directly after the fetch, or you like to live dangerously, you could delete old messages immediately), so that
  • when/if your account get cracked/hacked the attacker only gets your unfetched mail (+ configurable amount of yet to be removed messages), which is much better than them getting the whole last 20 years or whatever of your correspondence. (If your personal computer gets compromised enough, attackers will eventually get everything anyway, so deleting old mail from servers does not make things worse. But see some more thoughts on this below.)

Also, hoardy-mail seems to be one of the fastest, if not the fastest, IMAP fetchers there is. By default, it fetches mail more than 150 times faster than fetchmail (and getmail), but if your IMAP server supports long enough command lines, your system can do SSL and your hard drive can flush data fast enough, then you can saturate a gigabit Ethernet link with hoardy-mail.

Since bootstrapping into a setup similar to the one described above requires querying into actual IMAP folder names and mass changes to flags on IMAP server-side, hoardy-mail provides subcommands for that too.

See the "subcommands" subsection of the usage section for the list available of subcommands and explanations of what they do.

Quickstart

Install Python 3

Install hoardy-mail

  • On a POSIX system or on a Windows system with configured PATH environment variable, install with:

    pip install hoardy-mail

    and run as

    hoardy-mail --help

  • Alternatively, on a Windows system with unconfigured PATH, install with:

    pip install hoardy-mail

    and run as

    python3 -m hoardy_mail --help

  • Alternatively, on a POSIX system with Nix package manager, install and run with:

    nix-env -i -f ./default.nix
hoardy-mail --help

  • Alternatively, on a POSIX system, run without installing:

    alias hoardy-mail="python3 -m hoardy_mail"
hoardy-mail --help

How to: backup all your mail from GMail, Yahoo, Hotmail, Yandex, etc

hoardy-mail is not intended as an IMAP mirroring tool, it is intended to be used as a Mail Delivery Agent with automatic expiration of old server-side mail, i.e. a better replacement for fetchmail+IMAPExpire combination. If you want to keep a synchronized copy of your mail locally and on your mail server without sacrificing any flags, you should use offlineimap, imapsync, or something similar instead.

However, hoardy-mail can be used for efficient incremental backups of IMAP server data if you are willing to sacrifice either of SEEN or FLAGGED ("starred") IMAP flags for it. Also, making email backups with hoardy-mail is pretty simple, useful, and illustrative, so a couple of examples follow.

How to: fetch all your emails from GMail, Yahoo, Hotmail, Yandex, etc

The following will fetch all messages from all the folders on the server (without changing message flags on the server side) and just put them all into ~/Mail/backup Maildir (creating it if it does not exists).

# backup all your mail from GMail
hoardy-mail fetch --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --maildir ~/Mail/backup --all-folders --any-seen

For GMail you will have to create and use application-specific password, which requires enabling 2FA, see below for more info.

Also, if you have a lot of mail, this will be very inefficient, as it will try to re-download everything again if it ever gets interrupted.

How to: efficiently incrementally backup all your mail from GMail, Yahoo, Hotmail, Yandex, etc

To make the above efficient you have to sacrifice either SEEN or FLAGGED IMAP flags to allow hoardy-mail to track which messages are yet to be fetched, i.e. either:

# mark all messages as UNSEEN
hoardy-mail mark --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" unseen

# fetch UNSEEN and mark as SEEN as you go
# this can be interrrupted and restarted and it will continue from where it left off
hoardy-mail fetch --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --maildir ~/Mail/backup --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --unseen

or

# mark all messages as UNFLAGGED
hoardy-mail mark --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" unflagged

# similarly
hoardy-mail fetch --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --maildir ~/Mail/backup --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --any-seen --unflagged

This, of course, means that if you open or "mark as read" a message in GMail's web-mail UI while using --unseen, or mark it as flagged ("star") it there while using --unflagged, hoardy-mail will ignore the message on the next fetch.

How to: efficiently incrementally backup millions and/or decades of messages from GMail, Yahoo, Hotmail, Yandex, etc

In cases where you want to fetch millions of messages spanning decades, you'll probably want invoke hoardy-mail fetch multiple times with progressively smaller --older-than arguments so that IMAP SEARCH command responses will be smaller to re-fetch if the process gets interrupted, i.e.:

# mark all messages as UNSEEN
hoardy-mail mark --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" unseen

for n in 10 5 3 2 1; do
    echo "fetching mail older than $n years..."
    hoardy-mail fetch --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
      --maildir ~/Mail/backup --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --unseen \
      --older-than $((365*n))
done

What do I do with the resulting Maildir?

You feed it into sup, notmuch, or similar, as discussed this section, and it gives you a GMail-like UI with full-text search and tagging, but with faster search, with no cloud storage involvement, and it works while you are offline.

Or you just repeat this mirroring on a schedule so that when/if GMail decides to take your mail hostage you will be prepared to switch.

Can I use an MDA/LDA to deliver messages?

Yes, just replace --maildir DIRECTORY with --mda MDA. For instance, for maildrop Mail Delivery Agent (also knows as Local Delivery Agent, LDA, as it is an MDA that gets used to deliver messages to same machine) from Courier Mail Server project --- which is a commodity MDA/LDA with the simplest setup, that I know of --- the simplest hoardy-mail fetch invocation looks like this:

### setup: do once
mkdir -p ~/Mail/backup/{new,cur,tmp}

cat > ~/.mailfilter << EOF
DEFAULT="\$HOME/Mail/backup"
EOF

# backup all your mail from GMail
hoardy-mail fetch --host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --pass-pinentry \
  --mda maildrop --all-folders --any-seen

Of course, you can use any other MDA/LDA you want, e.g.:

  • fdm can function as an LDA and it is also pretty simple to setup;

  • deliveries to an SMTP server can be done by using msmtp.

How to: implement "fetch + backup + expire" workflow

The intended workflow described above looks like this:

### setup: do once
echo 0 > ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp

cat > ~/bin/new-mail-hook << EOF
#!/bin/sh -e
# index new mail
notmuch new

# auto-tagging rules go here

# backup
backup_start=\$(date +%s)
if rsync -aHAX ~/Mail /disk/backup ; then
    echo "\$backup_start" > ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp
fi
EOF
chmod +x ~/bin/new-mail-hook

### repeatable part

# optionally, if needed
# hoardy-mail mark ... --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" unseen

# every hour, fetch new and expire old mail from two GMail accounts,
# generate new desktop notifications with `notify-send` if some of the commands fail
hoardy-mail for-each --every 3600 --notify-failure \
    --host imap.gmail.com \
      --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]" \
      --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]" \
  -- \
    fetch --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --maildir ~/Mail/INBOX --new-mail-cmd new-mail-hook \; \
    fetch --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" --maildir ~/Mail/spam  \; \
    delete --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" \
      --older-than-timestamp-in ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp \
      --older-than 7

# note how new spam does not invoke `new-mail-hook`

You can check your command lines by running with --very-dry-run option, for the command above it prints:

# every 3600 seconds, for each of
... user [email protected] on host imap.gmail.com port 993 (SSL)
... user [email protected] on host imap.gmail.com port 993 (SSL)
# do
... in '[Gmail]/All Mail': search (UNSEEN), perform fetch, mark them as SEEN
... in '[Gmail]/Spam': search (UNSEEN), perform fetch, mark them as SEEN
... in '[Gmail]/All Mail', '[Gmail]/Spam', '[Gmail]/Trash': search (SEEN BEFORE 1-Jan-1970) {dynamic}, perform delete

Personally, I have a separate script exec-invoking hoardy-mail (see the terminal recording above) for each mail service I use, my window manager spawns a terminal window with tmux attach -t subs on startup while I have the following at the end of my ~/.tmux.conf:

# create new session named "subs" with the first window named "shell"
new-session -s subs -n shell
# set remain-on-exit for all windows in this session by default
set-option  -t subs -g remain-on-exit on
# add new windows running hoardy-mail instances
new-window -t :2 -n mail mail-mine
new-window -t :3 -n gmail mail-gmail
# ... and so on

This way, if I need to fetch mail from one of the services immediately (e.g. for 2FA tokens sent via email) I just navigate to the respective tmux window and hit Ctrl+C there.

How to: run hoardy-mail in parallel with fetchmail or similar

You can run hoardy-mail fetch with --any-seen --unflagged command line options instead of the implied --unseen --any-flagged options, which will make it use the FLAGGED IMAP flag instead of the SEEN IMAP flag to track state, allowing you to run it simultaneously with tools that use the SEEN flag, like fetchmail, getmail, or just another instance of hoardy-mail (using the other flag).

I.e. you can use it to run two instances of hoardy-mail on two separate machines and only expire old mail from the server after it was successfully backed up onto both machines. Or, if you are really paranoid, you can this feature to check files produced by fetchmail and hoardy-mail fetch against each other and then simply delete duplicated files.

Running in parallel with fetchmail using maildrop MDA for both fetchmail and hoardy-mail can be implemented like this:

### setup: do once
echo 0 > ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp

mkdir -p ~/Mail/INBOX/{new,cur,tmp}
mkdir -p ~/Mail/spam/{new,cur,tmp}
mkdir -p ~/Mail/INBOX.secondary/{new,cur,tmp}

cat > ~/.mailfilter << EOF
DEFAULT="\$HOME/Mail/INBOX"
EOF

cat > ~/.mailfilter-spam << EOF
DEFAULT="\$HOME/Mail/spam"
EOF

cat > ~/.mailfilter-secondary << EOF
DEFAULT="\$HOME/Mail/INBOX.secondary"
EOF

cat > ~/bin/new-mail-hook-dedup << EOF
#!/bin/sh -e
# deduplicate
jdupes -o time -O -rdN ~/Mail/INBOX ~/Mail/INBOX.secondary

# continue as usual
exec ~/bin/new-mail-hook
EOF
chmod +x ~/bin/new-mail-hook-dedup

secondary_common=(--host imap.gmail.com \
  --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]" \
  --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]")

# prepare by unflagging all messages
hoardy-mail mark "${secondary_common[@]}" --folder "INBOX" unflagged

### repeatable part
# run fetchmail daemon as usual, fetching new mail into the secondary maildir every hour
fetchmail --mda "maildrop ~/.mailfilter-secondary" -d 3600

# every 15 minutes
# - fetch new mail using FLAGGED flag for tracking state from "[Gmail]/All Mail",
# - fetch new mail using SEEN flag for tracking state from "[Gmail]/Spam",
# - expire old backed up messages marked both SEEN (by fetchmail) and FLAGGED (by hoardy-mail) from "[Gmail]/All Mail",
# - expire old backed up messages marked as SEEN (by hoardy-mail) from "[Gmail]/Spam",
# - clean any messages older than 7 days (regardless of their flags) from "[Gmail]/Trash".
# - generate new desktop notifications with `notify-send` if some of the commands fail
hoardy-mail for-each --every 900 --notify-failure \
    "${secondary_common[@]}" \
  -- \
    fetch --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --mda maildrop --new-mail-cmd new-mail-hook --any-seen --unflagged \; \
    fetch --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" --mda "maildrop ~/.mailfilter-spam" \; \
    delete --seen --flagged --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" \
      --older-than-timestamp-in ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp \
      --older-than 7 \; \
    delete "[Gmail]/Spam" \
      --older-than-timestamp-in ~/.rsync-last-mail-backup-timestamp \
      --older-than 7 \; \
    delete --any-seen --any-flagged --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" \
      --older-than 7

# note how new spam does not invoke `new-mail-hook`

See also

See the usage section for explanation of used command line options.

See the examples section for more examples.

Why would you even want to use any of this, isn't GMail good enough?

Remember the time when YouTube and Facebook showed you only the posts of people you were subscribed to? After they locked your in by becoming a monopoly by providing fairly good social networking services for free for years (selling under cost is textbook monopolistic behaviour) they started showing "promoted" posts (i.e. advertisements) in your feed so that they could provide cheap and very effective advertisement services for companies at your expense. Then, when advertisers were locked in, they started fleecing them too.

Now your subscriptions are just one of the inputs to their algorithms that are designed to make you waste as much time as possible on their platforms (while keeping you satisfied or addicted just enough so that you wouldn't just leave), and advertisers' ad postings are just inputs to their algorithms that are designed to waste as much of the advertiser's money as possible (being just effective enough to make them spend more).

(The process which Cory Doctorow calls "Enshittification".)

Remember the time when most people run their own mail servers or had their employers run them and you yourself got to decide which messages should go to INBOX and which should be marked as spam? Today, Google provides email services for free, and so >70% of all e-mails originate from or get delivered to Google servers (GMail, GMail on custom domains, corporate GMail). Now it's Google who decides which messages you get to see and which vanish into the void without a trace.

Which, as a recipient, is highly annoying if you frequently get useful mail that GMail marks as spam or just drops (happens all the time to me). And, as a sender, is highly annoying when you need to send lots of mail. Just go look up "Gmail Email Limits" (on a search engine other than Google). It's a rabbit hole with lots of ad-hoc rules on just how much mail you can send before GMail decides to just drop your messages, yes, drop, not mark as spam, not reject, they will drop your mail and tell neither the sender nor the recipient anything at all.

Moreover, they are now working towards making their INBOX into an algorithmically generated feed with "important" messages being shown first. It's easy to see where this is going.

Luckily, while Google is working hard to discourage you from using and/or make open mail protocols unusable, IMAP is still #1 protocol for accessing and managing mail, and setting up your own mail server gets easier every year, so they can't just stop supporting it just yet (but they are doing their best).

But, objectively, GMail --- when it works --- is a very nice Mail User Agent (aka MUA, aka email client, aka mail app) with an integrated full-text search engine and a labeling system.

Meanwhile, other modern MUAs like Thunderbird, Sylpheed, or K-9 Mail are designed to be IMAP and SMTP clients first, full-text search and tagging/labeling systems second (if at all). Which is to say, they suck at searching and tagging mail. Especially, since doing those things over IMAP is annoyingly slow, especially when your IMAP server is GMail which very much does not want you to use IMAP (after all, with a MUA working over IMAP, it's the MUA that decides how to sort and display your INBOX, not Google, and they hate they can't turn the order of messages in your INBOX into something they can sell).

However, there exists a bunch of MUAs that can do full-text mail search and tagging so well and so blazingly fast that they leave GMail in the dust (from a technical standpoint, given an index, full-text search >10x faster than GMail on a single-core of 2012-era laptop with an SSD is pretty easy to archive, simply because your SSD is much closer to you than GMail's servers).

Examples of such awesome MUAs that I'm aware of, in the order from simplest to hardest to setup:

However, to use these awesome MUAs you need to download your mail and save it in Maildir format on your hard disk first.

Which is where hoardy-mail and similar tools like fetchmail, getmail, offlineimap, imapsync, and etc come in.

Also, if GMail suddenly decides to take your mail hostage by locking you into their web-mail and disabling IMAP access, which seems more and more plausible every year, having a local copy of most of your mail will make it much easier to switch away. (Seems unrealistic to you? This actually happened to me with one of the email providers I used before (not GMail, not yet). They basically tried to force me to go through a KYC procedure to allow me to continue using IMAP, but because I had local backups, I just switched all the services that referenced that email address to something else and simply stopped using their service. Are you sure Google wouldn't do this?)

See "The Homely Mutt" by Steve Losh for a long in-detail explanation on how this setup in general is supposed to work. It describes a setup specifically tailored for mutt + notmuch + offlineimap + msmtp and the actual configs there are somewhat outdated (it was written in 2012) and much more complex than what you would need with, e.g. sup + hoardy-mail + msmtp, but it gives a good overview of the idea in general. Functionally, hoardy-mail takes place offlineimap in that article.

Personally, I use notmuch with Emacs, which requires almost no setup if you have a well-configured Emacs already (and effectively infinite amounts of setup otherwise).

Also, see "Sup" article on ArchWiki for how to setup sup.

(Also, in theory, Thunderbird also supports operation over Maildir, but that feature is so buggy it's apparently disabled by default at the moment.)

Google's security theater

GMail docs say that IMAP and SMTP are "legacy protocols" and are "insecure". Which, sure, they could be, if you reuse passwords. But them implying that everything except their own web-mail UI is "insecure" is kinda funny given that they do use SMTP to transfer mail between servers and signing in with Google prompts exists. I.e. you can borrow someone's phone, unlock it (passcode? peek over their shoulder or just get some video surveillance footage of them typing it in public; fingerprint? they leave their fingerprints all over the device itself, dust with some flour, take a photo, apply some simple filters, 3D-print the result, this actually takes ~3 minutes to do if you know what you are doing), ask Google to authenticate via prompt. Done, you can login into everything with no password needed. And Google appears to give no way to disable Google prompts if your account has an attached Android device. Though, you can make Google prompts ask for a password too, but that feature needs special setup. Meanwhile, "legacy" passwords are not secure, apparently?

So to use hoardy-mail with GMail you will have to enable 2FA in your account settings and then add an application-specific password for IMAP access. I.e., instead of generating a random password and giving it to Google (while storing it in a password manager that feeds it to hoardy-mail), you ask Google to generate a random password for you and use that with hoardy-mail.

To enable 2FA, even for very old accounts that never used anything phone or Android-related, for no rational reasons, GMail requires specifying a working phone number that can receive SMS. Which you can then simply remove after you copied your OTP secret into an authenticator of your choice. Sorry, why did you need the phone number, again?

Ah, well, Google now knows it and will be able track your movements by buying location data from your network operator. Thank you very much.

In theory, as an alternative to application-specific passwords, you can setup OAuth2 and update tokens automatically with mailctl, but Google will still ask for your phone number to set it up, and OAuth2 renewal adds another point of failure without really adding any security if you store your passwords in a password manager and use --passcmd option described below to feed them into hoardy-mail.

That is to say, I don't use OAuth2, which is why hoardy-mail does not support OAuth2.

Your emails will eventually get stolen anyway

Note that Snowden revelations mean that Google and US Government store copies of all of your correspondence since 2007-2009 (it depends on your mail provider) even if you delete everything from all the servers.

And they wiretap basically all the traffic going though international Internet exchanges because they wiretap all underwater cables. Simply because they can, apparently? (If you think about it, there is absolutely no point to doing this if you are trying to achieve their stated signal-intelligence goals. Governments and organized crime use one-time-pads since 1950s. AES256 + 32 bytes of shared secret (+ 8 bytes of plain-text session key + 4 bytes of plain-text IV) + some simple steganography and even if the signal gets discovered, no quantum-computer will ever be able to break it, no research into quantum-safe cryptography needed. So, clearly, this data collection only works against private citizens and civil society which have no ways to distribute symmetric keys and thus have to use public-key cryptography.)

Globally, >70% of all e-mails originate from or get delivered to Google servers (GMail, GMail on custom domains, corporate GMail).

Most e-mails never gets E2E-encrypted at all, (100 - epsilon)% (so, basically, 100%) of all e-mails sent over the Internet never get encrypted with quantum-safe cryptography in-transit.

So, eventually, US Government will get plain-text for almost everything you ever sent (unless you are a government official, work for well-organized crime syndicate, or you and all your friends are really paranoid).

Which means that, eventually, all that mail will get stolen.

So, in the best case scenario, a simple relatively benign blackmail-everyone-you-can-to-get-as-much-money-as-possible AI will be able organize a personal WikiLeaks-style breach, for every single person on planet Earth. No input from nefarious humans interested in exploiting personally you required. After all, you are not that interesting, so you have nothing to fear, nothing to hide, and you certainly did not write any still-embarrassing e-mails when you were 16 years old and did not send any nudes of yourself or anyone else to anyone (including any doctors, during the pandemic) ever.

It would be glorious, wouldn't it?

(Seriously, abstractly speaking, I'm kinda interested in civilization-wide legal and cultural effects of every embarrassing, even slightly illegal and/or hypocritical thing every person ever did relentlessly programmatically exploited as blackmail or worse. Non-abstractly speaking, why exactly do governments spend public money to make this possible? After all, hoarding of exploitable material that made a disaster after being stolen worked so well with EternalBlue, and that thing was a fixable bug, which leaked blackmail is not.)

That is to say, as a long-term defense measure, this tool is probably useless. All your mail will get leaked eventually, regardless. Against random exploitations of your mail servers hoardy-mail is perfect.

Also, hoardy-mail is a very nice fast mail fetcher, regardless of all of this.

Comparison to

fetchmail and getmail

hoardy-mail fetch

  • fetches your mail more than 150 times faster by default (both fetchmail and getmail fetch and mark messages one-by-one, incurring huge network latency overheads, hoardy-mail fetch does it in (configurable) batches);
  • generates ~150 times less disk writes (hoardy-mail fetch --maildir fsyncs messages to disk in (configurable) batches) improving performance and longevity of your SSD;
  • fetches messages out-of-order to try and maximize messages/second metric when it makes sense (i.e. it temporarily delays fetching of larger messages if many smaller ones can be fetched instead) so that you could efficiently index your mail in parallel with fetching;
  • only does deliveries to a local Maildir (with hoardy-mail fetch --maildir option) or MDA/LDA (with hoardy-mail fetch --mda option, which does the same thing as fetchmail --mda and getmail's MDA_external options), deliveries over SMTP are not and will never be supported (if you want this you can just use msmtp with hoardy-mail fetch --mda); thus, hoardy-mail
  • is much simpler to use when fetching to a local Maildir as it needs no configuration to fetch messages as-is without modifying any headers, thus fetching the same messages twice will produce identical files (which is not true for fetchmail, hoardy-mail fetch --mda MDA is roughly equivalent to fetchmail --softbounce --invisible --norewrite --mda MDA);
  • probably will not work with most broken IMAP servers (fetchmail has lots of workarounds for server bugs, hoardy-mail fetch does not);
  • is written in Python (like getmail) instead of C (like fetchmail);
  • has other subcommands, not just hoardy-mail fetch.

fdm

A better explanation of what fdm does.

hoardy-mail fetch

  • uses server-side message flags to track state instead of keeping a local database of fetched UIDs;
  • fetches messages out-of-order to try and maximize messages/second metric;
  • generates ~150 times less disk writes;
  • does not do any filtering, offloads that to MDA/LDA;
  • is written in Python instead of C;
  • has other subcommands, not just hoardy-mail fetch.

IMAPExpire

hoardy-mail delete

  • allows all UNICODE characters except \n in passwords/passphrases (yes, including spaces, quotes, etc);
  • provides a bunch of options controlling message selection and uses --seen option by default for destructive actions, so you won't accidentally delete any messages you have not yet fetched even if your fetcher got stuck/crashed;
  • provides GMail-specific options;
  • is written in Python instead of Perl and requires nothing but the basic Python install, no third-party libraries needed;
  • has other subcommands, not just hoardy-mail delete.

offlineimap, imapsync, and similar

  • hoardy-mail fetch does deliveries from an IMAP server to your Maildir/MDA/LDA instead of trying to synchronize state between some combinations of IMAP servers and local Maildirs (i.e. for hoardy-mail fetch your IMAP server is always the source, never the destination), which might seem like a lack of a feature at first, but
    • hoardy-mail lacking two-way sync also prevents you from screwing up your hoardy-mail invocation options or restarting the program at an inopportune time and losing all your mail on the server on the next sync as a result (like you can with offlineimap),
    • i.e., with hoardy-mail you won't ever lose any messages on the server if you never run hoardy-mail delete, and if you do run hoardy-mail delete, hoardy-mail's defaults try their best to prevent you from deleting any mail you probably did not mean to delete;
  • consequently, hoardy-mail is much simpler to use as the complexity of its configuration is proportional to the complexity of your usage;
  • hoardy-mail fetch generates ~150 times less disk writes;
  • hoardy-mail has other subcommands, not just hoardy-mail fetch.

License

GPLv3+.

Usage

hoardy-mail

A handy Swiss-army-knife-like utility for fetching and performing batch operations on messages residing on IMAP servers. I.e., for each specified IMAP server: login, perform specified actions on all messages matching specified criteria in all specified folders, log out.

  • options:

    • --version : show program's version number and exit
    • -h, --help : show this help message and exit
    • --markdown : show help messages formatted in Markdown
    • -q, --quieter : be less verbose

  • debugging:

    • --very-dry-run : verbosely describe what the given command line would do and exit
    • --dry-run : perform a trial run without actually performing any changes
    • --debug : dump IMAP conversation to stderr

  • hooks:

    • --notify-success : generate notifications (via notify-send) describing server-side changes, if any, at the end of each program cycle; most useful if you run hoardy-mail in background with --every argument in a graphical environment
    • --success-cmd CMD : shell command to run at the end of each program cycle that performed some changes on the server, i.e. a generalized version of --notify-success; the spawned process will receive the description of the performed changes via stdin; can be specified multiple times
    • --notify-failure : generate notifications (via notify-send) describing recent failures, if any, at the end of each program cycle; most useful if you run hoardy-mail in background with --every argument in a graphical environment
    • --failure-cmd CMD : shell command to run at the end of each program cycle that had some of its command fail, i.e. a generalized version of --notify-failure; the spawned process will receive the description of the failured via stdin; can be specified multiple times

  • authentication settings:

    • --auth-allow-login : allow the use of IMAP LOGIN command (default)
    • --auth-forbid-login : forbid the use of IMAP LOGIN command, fail if challenge-response authentication is not available
    • --auth-allow-plain : allow passwords to be transmitted over the network in plain-text
    • --auth-forbid-plain : forbid passwords from being transmitted over the network in plain-text, plain-text authentication would still be possible over SSL if --auth-allow-login is set (default)

  • server connection: can be specified multiple times

    • --plain : connect via plain-text socket
    • --ssl : connect over SSL socket (default)
    • --starttls : connect via plain-text socket, but then use STARTTLS command
    • --host HOST : IMAP server to connect to (required)
    • --port PORT : port to use (default: 143 for --plain and --starttls, 993 for --ssl)
    • --timeout TIMEOUT : socket timeout, in seconds (default: 60)

  • authentication to the server: either of --pass-pinentry, --passfile, or --passcmd are required; can be specified multiple times

    • --user USER : username on the server (required)
    • --pass-pinentry : read the password via pinentry
    • --passfile PASSFILE, --pass-file PASSFILE : file containing the password on its first line
    • --passcmd PASSCMD, --pass-cmd PASSCMD : shell command that returns the password as the first line of its stdout

  • batching settings: larger values improve performance but produce longer IMAP command lines (which some servers reject) and cause more stuff to be re-downloaded when networking issues happen

    • --store-number INT : batch at most this many message UIDs in IMAP STORE requests (default: 150)
    • --fetch-number INT : batch at most this many message UIDs in IMAP FETCH metadata requests (default: 150)
    • --batch-number INT : batch at most this many message UIDs in IMAP FETCH data requests; essentially, this controls the largest possible number of messages you will have to re-download if connection to the server gets interrupted (default: 150)
    • --batch-size INT : batch FETCH at most this many bytes of RFC822 messages at once; RFC822 messages larger than this will be fetched one by one (i.e. without batching); essentially, this controls the largest possible number of bytes you will have to re-download if connection to the server gets interrupted while hoardy-mail is batching (default: 4194304)

  • polling/daemon options:

    • --every INTERVAL : repeat the command every INTERVAL seconds; hoardy-mail will do its best to repeat the command precisely every INTERVAL seconds even if the command involes fetching of new messages and --new-mail-cmd invocations take different time each cycle; if program cycle takes more than INTERVAL seconds or INTERVAL < 60 then hoardy-mail would sleep for 60 seconds either way, this prevents the servers accessed earlier in the cycle from learning about the amount of new data fetched from the servers accessed later in the cycle
    • --every-add-random ADD : sleep a random number of seconds in [0, ADD] range (uniform distribution) before each --every cycle, including the very first one (default: 60); if you set it large enough to cover the longest single-server fetch, it will prevent any of the servers learning anything about the data on other servers; if you run hoardy-mail on a machine that disconnects from the Internet when you go to sleep and you set it large enough, it will help in preventing the servers from collecting data about your sleep cycle

  • message search filters:

    • --older-than DAYS : operate on messages older than this many days, the date will be rounded down to the start of the day; actual matching happens on the server, so all times are server time; e.g. --older-than 0 means older than the start of today by server time, --older-than 1 means older than the start of yesterday, etc; can be specified multiple times, in which case the earliest (the most old) date on the list will be chosen
    • --newer-than DAYS : operate on messages newer than this many days, a negation of--older-than, so everything from --older-than applies; e.g., --newer-than -1 will match files dated into the future, --newer-than 0 will match files delivered from the beginning of today, etc; can be specified multiple times, in which case the latest (the least old) date on the list will be chosen
    • --older-than-timestamp-in PATH : operate on messages older than the timestamp (in seconds since UNIX Epoch) recorded on the first line of this PATH, rounded as described above; can be specified multiple times, in which case it will processed as described above
    • --newer-than-timestamp-in PATH : operate on messages newer than the timestamp (in seconds since UNIX Epoch) recorded on the first line of this PATH, rounded as described above; can be specified multiple times, in which case it will processed as described above
    • --older-than-mtime-of PATH : operate on messages older than mtime of this PATH, rounded as described above; can be specified multiple times, in which case it will processed as described above
    • --newer-than-mtime-of PATH : operate on messages newer than mtime of this PATH, rounded as described above; can be specified multiple times, in which case it will processed as described above
    • --from ADDRESS : operate on messages that have this string as substring of their header's FROM field; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-from ADDRESS : operate on messages that don't have this string as substring of their header's FROM field; can be specified multiple times

  • subcommands:

    • {list,count,mark,fetch,delete,for-each}
      • list : list all available folders on the server, one per line
      • count : count how many matching messages each specified folder has
      • mark : mark matching messages in specified folders in a specified way
      • fetch : fetch matching messages from specified folders, put them into a Maildir or feed them to a MDA/LDA, and then mark them in a specified way if it succeeds
      • delete : delete matching messages from specified folders
      • for-each : perform multiple other subcommands, sequentially, on a single server connection

hoardy-mail list

Login, perform IMAP LIST command to get all folders, print them one per line.

  • options:
    • --porcelain : print in a machine-readable format (the default at the moment)

hoardy-mail count

Login, (optionally) perform IMAP LIST command to get all folders, perform IMAP SEARCH command with specified filters in each folder, print message counts for each folder one per line.

  • options:

    • --porcelain : print in a machine-readable format

  • folder search filters:

    • --all-folders : operate on all folders (default)
    • --folder NAME : mail folders to include; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-folder NAME : mail folders to exclude; can be specified multiple times

  • message IMAP SEEN flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-seen : operate on both SEEN and not SEEN messages (default)
    • --seen : operate on messages marked as SEEN
    • --unseen : operate on messages not marked as SEEN

  • message IMAP FLAGGED flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-flagged : operate on both FLAGGED and not FLAGGED messages (default)
    • --flagged : operate on messages marked as FLAGGED
    • --unflagged : operate on messages not marked as FLAGGED

hoardy-mail mark

Login, perform IMAP SEARCH command with specified filters for each folder, mark resulting messages in specified way by issuing IMAP STORE commands.

  • folder search filters (required):

    • --all-folders : operate on all folders
    • --folder NAME : mail folders to include; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-folder NAME : mail folders to exclude; can be specified multiple times

  • message IMAP SEEN flag filters (mutually exclusive, default: depends on other arguments):

    • --any-seen : operate on both SEEN and not SEEN messages
    • --seen : operate on messages marked as SEEN
    • --unseen : operate on messages not marked as SEEN

  • message IMAP FLAGGED flag filters (mutually exclusive, default: depends on other arguments):

    • --any-flagged : operate on both FLAGGED and not FLAGGED messages
    • --flagged : operate on messages marked as FLAGGED
    • --unflagged : operate on messages not marked as FLAGGED

  • marking:

    • {seen,unseen,flagged,unflagged} : mark how (required):
      • seen: add SEEN flag, sets --unseen if no message flag filter is specified
      • unseen: remove SEEN flag, sets --seen if no message flag filter is specified
      • flag: add FLAGGED flag, sets --unflagged if no message flag filter is specified
      • unflag: remove FLAGGED flag, sets --flagged if no message flag filter is specified

hoardy-mail fetch

Login, perform IMAP SEARCH command with specified filters for each folder, fetch resulting messages in (configurable) batches, put each batch of message into the specified Maildir and fsync them to disk or feed them to the specified MDA/LDA, and, if and only if all of the above succeeds, mark each message in the batch on the server in a specified way by issuing IMAP STORE commands.

  • folder search filters:

    • --all-folders : operate on all folders (default)
    • --folder NAME : mail folders to include; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-folder NAME : mail folders to exclude; can be specified multiple times

  • delivery target (required, mutually exclusive):

    • --maildir DIRECTORY : Maildir to deliver the messages to; with this specified hoardy-mail will simply drop raw RFC822 messages, one message per file, into DIRECTORY/new (creating it, DIRECTORY/cur, and DIRECTORY/tmp if any of those do not exists)
    • --mda COMMAND : shell command to use as an MDA to deliver the messages to; with this specified hoardy-mail will spawn COMMAND via the shell and then feed raw RFC822 message into its stdin, the resulting process is then responsible for delivering the message to Maildir, mbox, etc; maildrop from Courier Mail Server project is a good KISS default

  • delivery mode (mutually exclusive):

    • --yolo : messages that fail to be delivered into the --maildir or by the --mda are left un--marked on the server but no other messages get affected and currently running hoardy-mail fetch continues as if nothing is amiss
    • --careful : messages that fail to be delivered into the --maildir or by the --mda are left un--marked on the server, no other messages get affected, but hoardy-mail aborts currently running fetch and all the following commands of the for-each (if any) if zero messages from the current batch got successfully delivered --- as that usually means that the target file system is out of space, read-only, or generates IO errors (default)
    • --paranoid : hoardy-mail aborts the process immediately if any of the messages in the current batch fail to be delivered into the --maildir or by the --mda, the whole batch gets left un--marked on the server

  • hooks:

    • --new-mail-cmd CMD : shell command to run at the end of each program cycle that had new messages successfully delivered into the --maildir or by the --mda of this fetch subcommand; can be specified multiple times

  • message IMAP SEEN flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-seen : operate on both SEEN and not SEEN messages
    • --seen : operate on messages marked as SEEN
    • --unseen : operate on messages not marked as SEEN (default)

  • message IMAP FLAGGED flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-flagged : operate on both FLAGGED and not FLAGGED messages (default)
    • --flagged : operate on messages marked as FLAGGED
    • --unflagged : operate on messages not marked as FLAGGED

  • marking:

    • --mark {auto,noop,seen,unseen,flagged,unflagged} : after the message was fetched:
      • auto: seen when only --unseen is set (which it is by default), flagged when only --unflagged is set, noop otherwise (default)
      • noop: do nothing
      • seen: add SEEN flag
      • unseen: remove SEEN flag
      • flagged: add FLAGGED flag
      • unflagged: remove FLAGGED flag

hoardy-mail delete

Login, perform IMAP SEARCH command with specified filters for each folder, delete them from the server using a specified method.

  • folder search filters (required):

    • --all-folders : operate on all folders
    • --folder NAME : mail folders to include; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-folder NAME : mail folders to exclude; can be specified multiple times

  • message IMAP SEEN flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-seen : operate on both SEEN and not SEEN messages
    • --seen : operate on messages marked as SEEN (default)
    • --unseen : operate on messages not marked as SEEN

  • message IMAP FLAGGED flag filters (mutually exclusive):

    • --any-flagged : operate on both FLAGGED and not FLAGGED messages (default)
    • --flagged : operate on messages marked as FLAGGED
    • --unflagged : operate on messages not marked as FLAGGED

  • deletion method:

    • --method {auto,delete,delete-noexpunge,gmail-trash} : delete messages how:
      • auto: gmail-trash when --host imap.gmail.com and the current folder is not [Gmail]/Trash, delete otherwise (default)
      • delete: mark messages as deleted and then use IMAP EXPUNGE command, i.e. this does what you would expect a "delete" command to do, works for most IMAP servers
      • delete-noexpunge: mark messages as deleted but skip issuing IMAP EXPUNGE command hoping the server does as RFC2060 says and auto-EXPUNGEs messages on IMAP CLOSE; this is much faster than delete but some servers (like GMail) fail to implement this properly
      • gmail-trash: move messages to [Gmail]/Trash in GMail-specific way instead of trying to delete them immediately (GMail ignores IMAP Deleted flag and EXPUNGE command outside of [Gmail]/Trash); you can then hoardy-mail delete --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" them after (which will default to --method delete), or you could just leave them there and GMail will delete them in 30 days

hoardy-mail for-each

For each account: login, perform other subcommands given in ARGs, logout.

This is most useful for performing complex changes --every once in while in daemon mode. Or if you want to set different --folders for different subcommands but run them all at once.

Except for the simplest of cases, you must use -- before ARGs so that any options specified in ARGs won't be picked up by for-each. Run with --very-dry-run to see the interpretation of the given command line.

All generated hooks are deduplicated and run after all other subcommands are done. E.g., if you have several fetch --new-mail-cmd filter-my-mail as subcommands of for-each, then filter-my-mail will be run once after all other subcommands finish.

  • positional arguments:

    • ARG : arguments, these will be split by ; and parsed into other subcommands

  • folder search filters (will be used as default for subcommands):

    • --all-folders : operate on all folders
    • --folder NAME : mail folders to include; can be specified multiple times
    • --not-folder NAME : mail folders to exclude; can be specified multiple times

Notes on usage

  • When specifying account-related settings --user and --pass* options should be always specified last.

    Internally, new account definition gets emitted when a new --pass* option finishes processing.

    All server connection and authentication options except --user and --pass* get reused between successively defined accounts, unless overwritten with a new value before the next --pass* option.

  • Message search filters are connected by logical "AND"s so, e.g., --from "github.com" --not-from "[email protected]" will act on messages which have a From: header with github.com but without [email protected] as substrings.

  • fetch subcommand acts on --unseen messages by default.

  • delete subcommand acts on --seen messages by default.

  • Under for-each, after any command that produced errors (e.g. a fetch that failed to deliver at least one message because --maildir or --mda failed to do their job), any successive delete commands will be automatically skipped.

    In theory, in the case of --maildir or --mda failing to deliver some messages hoardy-mail need not do this as those messages will be left unmarked on the server, but in combination with the default --careful delivery option (which see) this behaviour could still be helpful in preventing data loss in the event where the target filesystem starts generating random IO errors (e.g. if you HDD/SSD just failed).

    In general, this behaviour exists to prevent delete from accidentally deleting something important when folder hierarchy on the IMAP server changes to be incompatible with in-use hoardy-mail options. For instance, say you are trying to fetch from a folder that was recently renamed and then try to delete from --all-folders. The behaviour described above will prevent this from happening.

Examples

  • List all available IMAP folders and count how many messages they contain:

Now, assuming the following are set:

common=(--host imap.example.com --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]")
common_mda=("${{common[@]}}" --mda maildrop)
gmail_common=(--host imap.gmail.com --user [email protected] --passcmd "pass show mail/[email protected]")
gmail_common_mda=("${{gmail_common[@]}}" --mda maildrop)

  • Count how many messages older than 7 days are in [Gmail]/All Mail folder:

    hoardy-mail count "${gmail_common[@]}" --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --older-than 7

  • Mark all messages in INBOX as not SEEN, fetch all not SEEN messages marking them SEEN as you download them so that if the process gets interrupted you could continue from where you left off:

    # setup: do once
hoardy-mail mark "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX unseen

# repeatable part
hoardy-mail fetch "${common_mda[@]}" --folder INBOX

  • Similarly to the above, but use FLAGGED instead of SEEN. This allows to use this in parallel with another instance of hoardy-mail using the SEEN flag, e.g. if you want to backup to two different machines independently, or if you want to use hoardy-mail simultaneously in parallel with fetchmail or other similar tool:

    # setup: do once
hoardy-mail mark "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX unflagged

# repeatable part
hoardy-mail fetch "${common_mda[@]}" --folder INBOX --any-seen --unflagged

# this will work as if nothing of the above was run
fetchmail

# in this use case you should use both `--seen` and `--flagged` when expiring old messages
# so that it would only delete messages fetched by both hoardy-mail and fetchmail
hoardy-mail delete "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX --older-than 7 --seen --flagged

  • Similarly to the above, but run hoardy-mail fetch as a daemon to download updates every hour:

    # setup: do once
hoardy-mail mark "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX unseen

# repeatable part
hoardy-mail fetch "${common_mda[@]}" --folder INBOX --every 3600

  • Fetch all messages from INBOX folder that were delivered in the last 7 days (the resulting date is rounded down to the start of the day by server time), but don't change any flags:

    hoardy-mail fetch "${common_mda[@]}" --folder INBOX --any-seen --newer-than 7

  • Fetch all messages from INBOX folder that were delivered from the beginning of today (by server time), without changing any flags:

    hoardy-mail fetch "${common_mda[@]}" --folder INBOX --any-seen --newer-than 0

  • Delete all SEEN messages older than 7 days from INBOX folder:

    Assuming you fetched and backed up all your messages already this allows you to keep as little as possible on the server, so that if your account gets cracked/hacked, you won't be as vulnerable.

    hoardy-mail delete "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX --older-than 7

    (--seen is implied by default)

  • DANGEROUS! If you fetched and backed up all your messages already, you can skip --older-than and just delete all SEEN messages instead:

    hoardy-mail delete "${common[@]}" --folder INBOX

    Though, setting at least --older-than 1, to make sure you won't lose any data in case you forgot you are running another instance of hoardy-mail or another IMAP client that changes message flags is highly recommended.

  • Fetch everything GMail considers to be Spam for local filtering:

    # setup: do once
mkdir -p ~/Mail/spam/{new,cur,tmp}

cat > ~/.mailfilter-spam << EOF
DEFAULT="\$HOME/Mail/spam"
EOF

hoardy-mail mark "${gmail_common[@]}" --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" unseen

# repeatable part
hoardy-mail fetch "${gmail_common_mda[@]}" --mda "maildrop ~/.mailfilter-spam" --folder "[Gmail]/Spam"

  • Fetch everything from all folders, except for INBOX, [Gmail]/Starred (because in GMail these two are included in [Gmail]/All Mail), and [Gmail]/Trash (for illustrative purposes):

    hoardy-mail fetch "${gmail_common_mda[@]}" --all-folders \
  --not-folder INBOX --not-folder "[Gmail]/Starred" --not-folder "[Gmail]/Trash"

    Note that, in GMail, all messages except for those in [Gmail]/Trash and [Gmail]/Spam are included in [Gmail]/All Mail. So, if you want to fetch everything, you should probably just fetch from those three folders instead:

    hoardy-mail fetch "${gmail_common_mda[@]}" \
  --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" --folder "[Gmail]/Spam"

  • GMail-specific deletion mode: move (expire) old messages to [Gmail]/Trash and then delete them:

    In GMail, deleting messages from INBOX does not actually delete them, nor moves them to trash, just removes them from INBOX while keeping them available from [Gmail]/All Mail.

    To work around this, this tool provides a GMail-specific --method gmail-trash that moves messages to [Gmail]/Trash in a GMail-specific way (this is not a repetition, it does require issuing special IMAP STORE commands to achieve this):

    hoardy-mail delete "${gmail_common[@]}" --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --older-than 7

    (--method gmail-trash is implied by --host imap.gmail.com and --folder not being [Gmail]/Trash, --seen is still implied by default)

    Messages in [Gmail]/Trash will be automatically removed by GMail in 30 days, but you can also delete them immediately with:

    hoardy-mail delete "${gmail_common[@]}" --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" --any-seen --older-than 7

    (--method delete is implied by --host imap.gmail.com but --folder being [Gmail]/Trash)

  • Every hour, fetch messages from different folders using different MDA settings and then expire messages older than 7 days, all in a single pass (reusing the server connection between subcommands):

    hoardy-mail for-each "${gmail_common[@]}" --every 3600 -- \
  fetch --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --mda maildrop \; \
  fetch --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" --mda "maildrop ~/.mailfilter-spam" \; \
  delete --folder "[Gmail]/All Mail" --folder "[Gmail]/Spam" --folder "[Gmail]/Trash" \
    --older-than 7

    Note the -- and \; tokens, without them the above will fail to parse.

    Also note that delete will use --method gmail-trash for [Gmail]/All Mail and [Gmail]/Spam and then use --method delete for [Gmail]/Trash even though they are specified together.

    Also, when running in parallel with another IMAP client that changes IMAP flags, hoardy-mail for-each will notice the other client doing it while fetching and will skip all following deletes of that --every cycle to prevent data loss.