New Fc multi position

[bbday]

Do you have plan to fix it for new fc24?
cause now is possible same player can autoswitch position then a CM player can be also at same time RB and get bonus for chemistry

[Regista6]

Yeah, I've asked the author of the tool I am using to download Squad CSV to include an additional column for Alternate Positions. Once that is available, this can be implemented. Apart from this, I think only the chemistry of Icons has changed; they now add 1 chem to every league!

[bbday]

if you need csv that include alternative position no issue i can generate it, usually each player have 2-3 alternative position (let me know it format that you wanna it, like array [CM,LM,RM] example).
I can generate also more efficient csv format with nation, team, club split in other csv than use ID like dictionary (i use this format for me)
Let me know it

[bbday]

You can use this CSV to make test i use all fifa code then more accurate.
I suggest to use Id cause numbers have more performance than strings (you can use dictionary to retrive name)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/10HFvMCv1-Nw6T7hohPctHO_RbIWaUtWG/view?usp=drive_link

If miss something let me know it

[Regista6]

The tool has been updated. Currently, the dataset looks like this:

Name	Rating	Rarity	Preferred Position	Nation	League	Team	Price Limits	Last Sale Price	Discard Value	Contract	Untradeable	Loans	DefinitionId	IsDuplicate	IsInActive11	Alternate Positions	ExternalPrice
Miedema	86	Rare	ST	Netherlands	Barclays WSL	Arsenal	--NA--	0	0	7	TRUE	TRUE	233746	FALSE	TRUE	CAM,CF,ST	7000

I am thinking of just creating separate entries of a particular player for each position. Also would like to access your dataset as well. Thanks!

[bbday]

my data comming from EA player iteration.
Atm main change is same player have mutiple positions and chemistry bonus for club is valid if club name is name (male/female) cause clubId is different number.

I think to use extra value like ClubMFId use same code id male/female for chemistry calc
For multiple position atm i dont have any idea except your but will increase 4 iterations

[Regista6]

Many thanks for taking an interest in this project. Can you grant access to your drive link above?

In the above example, Miedema has club listed as Arsenal. If for female players, this consistency is maintained, then it will be fine, I think!

Dataset size will definitely increase (x3 approximately if we consider each player can play in 3 positions). But how much it will impact solver performance remains to be seen.

[bbday]

sorry i didnt realize need access to see it

[Regista6]

In your dataset, male and female players have different club IDs for the same club name. One of my intentions was to combine players from club and market. But for that, I would need the entire dataset of players with prices. For now though, the extension to download club csv works well. Also, I've pushed some code to reflect changes made in EA FC 24.

EA FC 24 changes 📈