diff --git a/app/orchestrators/EngagementOrchestrator.scala b/app/orchestrators/EngagementOrchestrator.scala
index f38ca552..7869ded0 100644
--- a/app/orchestrators/EngagementOrchestrator.scala
+++ b/app/orchestrators/EngagementOrchestrator.scala
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
 package orchestrators
 
 import cats.implicits.catsSyntaxOption
+import cats.implicits.catsSyntaxOptionId
 import controllers.error.AppError.CannotReviewReportResponse
 import controllers.error.AppError.EngagementNotFound
 import controllers.error.AppError.ReportNotFound
-import controllers.error.AppError.ServerError
 import models.User
 import models.engagement.EngagementApi
 import models.engagement.EngagementId
@@ -122,7 +122,13 @@ class EngagementOrchestrator(
         logger.info(s"No engagement review found for report $reportId")
         None
       case review :: Nil => Some(review)
-      case _             => throw ServerError(s"More than one engagement review for report id $reportId")
+      case engagementReviews =>
+        io.sentry.Sentry.captureException(
+          new Exception(
+            s"More than one engagement review for report id $reportId, this is not and expected behavior it should be investigated"
+          )
+        )
+        engagementReviews.maxBy(_.creationDate).some
     }
 
   def findEngagementReviews(reportIds: Seq[UUID]): Future[Map[UUID, Option[EngagementReview]]] =
diff --git a/conf/db/migration/default/V54__unique_review_constraint.sql b/conf/db/migration/default/V54__unique_review_constraint.sql
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b8a9cd42
--- /dev/null
+++ b/conf/db/migration/default/V54__unique_review_constraint.sql
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
+-- Removing duplicates before applying constraint
+DELETE
+FROM report_consumer_review r
+    USING (SELECT rr.report_id, MAX(rr.creation_date) AS max_creation
+           FROM report_consumer_review rr
+           GROUP BY rr.report_id
+           HAVING COUNT(1) > 1) agg
+WHERE agg.report_id = r.report_id
+  AND agg.max_creation <> r.creation_date;
+
+ALTER TABLE report_consumer_review
+    ADD CONSTRAINT unique_report_id UNIQUE (report_id);
\ No newline at end of file