Procedure for Jakarta Platform, Enterprise Edition 11 Web Profile Certification needs review

[starksm64]

user_guides/platform/src/main/jbake/content/rules-wp.adoc needs review

https://github.com/jakartaee/platform-tck/blob/main/user_guides/platform/src/main/asciidoc/rules-wp.adoc

[edburns]

Thanks, I'll consult with Ed Bratt on these.

[edburns]

Subject: TCK-1773 review user_guides/platform/src/main/asciidoc/rules-wp.adoc

This issues calls for a close review of user_guides/platform/src/main/asciidoc/rules-wp.adoc. As the assignee and release-co-coordinator, I'm using this thread to seek help to do the best job.

My first question: How do I derive the correct, current content of this list, currently around line 357:

EE-WP21 Compliance testing for Jakarta EE {tck_version} Web Profile consists of running
the Jakarta EE {tck_version} Web Profile TCK tests and the following Technology
Compatibility Kits (TCKs). Version details are defined in the Platform EE Specification document (https://jakarta.ee/specifications/webprofile/11/), see heading 'Web Profile Definition', sub-heading 'Required Components':

* Jakarta Authentication
* Jakarta Bean Validation
* Jakarta Concurrency
* Jakarta Contexts and Dependency Injection
* Jakarta Debugging Support for Other Languages
* Jakarta Dependency Injection
* Jakarta Faces
* Jakarta JSON Binding
* Jakarta JSON Processing 
* Jakarta RESTful Web Services
* Jakarta Security

This list does seem shorter than I think it should be.

Thanks,

Ed

[edburns]

Consider adding glassfish-runner/README.md

* Directories containing the keyword `extra` are runners for tests that must be run in addition to that component tck.

* Directories containing the keyword `subst` are runners for tests where the component TCK completely replaces the component tck. In other words, the component TCK can be completely ignored.

* Directories that do not contain either of the preceding keywords contain runners for tests where component TCK is the necessary and sufficient set of tests. These tests are produced and published by the respective component specification project.

[starksm64]

EE-WP21 Compliance testing for Jakarta EE {tck_version} Web Profile consists of running
the Jakarta EE {tck_version} Web Profile TCK tests and the following Technology
Compatibility Kits (TCKs). Version details are defined in the Platform EE Specification document (https://jakarta.ee/specifications/webprofile/11/), see heading 'Web Profile Definition', sub-heading 'Required Components':

* Jakarta Authentication
* Jakarta Bean Validation
* Jakarta Concurrency
* Jakarta Contexts and Dependency Injection
* Jakarta Debugging Support for Other Languages
* Jakarta Dependency Injection
* Jakarta Faces
* Jakarta JSON Binding
* Jakarta JSON Processing 
* Jakarta RESTful Web Services
* Jakarta Security

This list does seem shorter than I think it should be.

Thanks,

Ed

This list are the standalone TCKs, so this is different than the components in the spec.

[starksm64]

Jakarta Data was missing from the list, I have added it

[edburns]

@starksm64 wrote:

This should be matching the "Web Profile Definition" from: specification/src/main/asciidoc/webprofile/WebProfileDefinition.adoc

In the TCK guide we should augment this to indicate which test artifacts/standalone TCKs apply to each component spec.