IIIF Presentation V3 manifests are returning errors on validation

[eliotjordan]

Using the presentation api validator with a staging manifest returns 8 different errors:

• Error 1 of 8. Message: Additional properties are not allowed ('logo', 'posterCanvas' were unexpected)

Detail:
Path: /[Additional properties are not allowed ('logo', 'posterCanvas' were unexpected)]
Description:
{"@context":"[ ... ]","type":"Manifest","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest","label":"{ ... }","metadata":"[ ... ]","rendering":"[ ... ]","items":"[ ... ]","behavior":"[ ... ]","posterCanvas":"{ ... }","structures":"[ ... ]","seeAlso":"[ ... ]","rights":"http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/CNE/1.0/","logo":"[ ... ]","thumbnail":"[ ... ]"}

• Error 2 of 8. Message: 'Download as PDF' is not of type 'object'

Detail: Language string, must have a language and value must be an array.
Path: /rendering[0]/label/['Download as PDF' is not of type 'object']
Description:
"Download as PDF"

• Error 3 of 8. Message: 'type' is a required property

Detail: Classes MUST have an id and type property and MAY have a label.
Path: /rendering[0]/['type' is a required property]
Description:
{"label":"Download as PDF","format":"application/pdf","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/catalog/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/pdf"}

• Error 4 of 8. Message: 'id' is a required property

Detail: Classes MUST have an id and type property and MAY have a label.
Path: /items[0]/items[0]/items[0]/['id' is a required property]
Description:
{"type":"Annotation","motivation":"painting","body":"{ ... }","target":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/42791640-9681-41f0-961a-b391d3781f0f"}

• Error 5 of 8. Message: 'items' is a required property

Detail: AnnotationPage id, type and items required
Path: /items[1]/items[0]/['items' is a required property]
Description:
{"type":"AnnotationPage","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660/annotation_page/a54ecdec-5dce-413a-8e46-f7fcdb1eb090"}

• Error 6 of 8.

Message: {'type': 'Canvas', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660', 'label': {'eng': ['32101047382484_1.wav']}, 'items': [{'type': 'AnnotationPage', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660/annotation_page/a54ecdec-5dce-413a-8e46-f7fcdb1eb090'}], 'rendering': [{'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/downloads/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660/file/25233bdc-7885-4240-99be-a45f4bbf107d', 'format': 'audio/x-wav', 'type': 'Dataset', 'label': {'en': ['Download the original file']}}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas
Detail:
Path: /items[1]/[{'type': 'Canvas', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660', 'label': {'eng': ['32101047382484_1.wav']}, 'items': [{'type': 'AnnotationPage', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660/annotation_page/a54ecdec-5dce-413a-8e46-f7fcdb1eb090'}], 'rendering': [{'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/downloads/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660/file/25233bdc-7885-4240-99be-a45f4bbf107d', 'format': 'audio/x-wav', 'type': 'Dataset', 'label': {'en': ['Download the original file']}}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas]
Description:
{"type":"Canvas","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/8f3594bd-2d6d-4c38-8a9e-453de6f77660","label":"{ ... }","items":"[ ... ]","rendering":"[ ... ]"}

• Error 7 of 8. Message: 'items' is a required property

Detail: AnnotationPage id, type and items required
Path: /items[2]/items[0]/['items' is a required property]
Description:
{"type":"AnnotationPage","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86/annotation_page/53c72802-2bef-4e4d-8e9c-ca934bdf13ee"}

• Error 8 of 8.

Message: {'type': 'Canvas', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86', 'label': {'eng': ['32101047382484_2.wav']}, 'items': [{'type': 'AnnotationPage', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86/annotation_page/53c72802-2bef-4e4d-8e9c-ca934bdf13ee'}], 'rendering': [{'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/downloads/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86/file/88e0160d-b447-477c-ac98-70ef3071ebf1', 'format': 'audio/x-wav', 'type': 'Dataset', 'label': {'en': ['Download the original file']}}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas
Detail:
Path: /items[2]/[{'type': 'Canvas', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86', 'label': {'eng': ['32101047382484_2.wav']}, 'items': [{'type': 'AnnotationPage', 'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86/annotation_page/53c72802-2bef-4e4d-8e9c-ca934bdf13ee'}], 'rendering': [{'id': 'https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/downloads/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86/file/88e0160d-b447-477c-ac98-70ef3071ebf1', 'format': 'audio/x-wav', 'type': 'Dataset', 'label': {'en': ['Download the original file']}}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas]
Description:
{"type":"Canvas","id":"https://figgy-staging.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/2325ed52-bb0b-42a9-9fa5-42c7beb106a4/manifest/canvas/1ac9e2dd-3088-45d8-a2f7-bf7766692b86","label":"{ ... }","items":"[ ... ]","rendering":"[ ... ]"}

[sdellis]

@eliotjordan I think it's important that we also validate v3 manifests that contain Range data. I have not been able to find a public example of this, but here is one that is private:

https://figgy.princeton.edu/concern/scanned_resources/ab32bcd8-8586-4c38-8da2-0aaf33d17f57/manifest