Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Sadly, the author has passed away :( #53

Open
svenove opened this issue Aug 10, 2018 · 9 comments
Open

Sadly, the author has passed away :( #53

svenove opened this issue Aug 10, 2018 · 9 comments

Comments

@svenove
Copy link
Contributor

svenove commented Aug 10, 2018

Sadly, the author of this project has passed away in April. :(

He's done a great job with this project and many people are using it!
It would be great to continue this project in a fork, but with 10 forks already (and probably more will come), it's difficult for people to know which one is "active" and in continued development.

Are there any "collaborators" added to this project, that has access to modifying the ReadMe without a PR? Based on the commits, @hlovdal might? If so, it would be great to make an "official" fork of this project and point to it in the ReadMe. :)

Here's also an active (Norwegian) forum thread about this project, started by @roarfred himself: https://www.hjemmeautomasjon.no/forums/topic/1982-lesing-av-ams-data-amshan-iot/

@DIYglenn
Copy link

My fork is focusing on the 'HAN_ESP_TSS721' board, which seems to be the most documented and tested board. I'm currently reorganizing it to make it easier for "end-users" to follow the project.

@UPC-PaalDriveklepp
Copy link

@DIYglenn: Have you made any changes in you fork? I only see some very minor changes... Do you want your fork to be THE official continuation of @roarfred's project? I'd like to contribute with some patches and updates to this project, but I'm not sure where to push it, and I'm hesitant to create the 21th fork.

@DIYglenn
Copy link

DIYglenn commented Dec 7, 2018

Correct, it’s still minor changes, but I’ve reorganized the whole project to focus on that one board, made it easier for non-devs to get what they need.
I think it would be beneficial to keep it in one fork, for the sake of further development.
I’ll notify you when I’ve pulled the changes from my side. Hopefully I’ll be able to look more into this when it’s closer to Christmas. Not had any time to continue since summer.

My thoughts:
Step 1: Organize the folders to archive old development and documentation, and focus on one single board (at least for the moment)

Step 2: Document how to solder and flash the board for newbies (it’s in the works)

Step 3: Clean up the code, the hotspot isn’t always working, and doesn’t really need to be “fancy” looking (first time setup only).

Step 4: Add OTA updates functionality etc for easy administration, and implement support for more meters than just Kaifa (Nuri).

I’ll hopefully be able to do my part soon, and then we could start merging changes from the community.

@UPC-PaalDriveklepp
Copy link

[My fork is focusing on the 'HAN_ESP_TSS721' board]

Are there any other boards? Are the other forks for other boards?

@xibriz
Copy link
Contributor

xibriz commented Jan 3, 2019

I have a much simpler board design (only ~10 parts). I can update my repo with the Fritzing files tonight if I remember.

@ohjohnsen
Copy link

@UPC-PaalDriveklepp I just found this project, and was sad to read that the original designer had passed away. Currently there are almost 50 forks. You wrote back in 2018 that you had some patches for the board. Have you committed these anywhere?

@ArnieO
Copy link

ArnieO commented Nov 18, 2024

@UPC-PaalDriveklepp I just found this project, and was sad to read that the original designer had passed away. Currently there are almost 50 forks. You wrote back in 2018 that you had some patches for the board. Have you committed these anywhere?

The maintenance of the project was continued by @gskjold when @roarfred passed away. Since then, @gskjold has done massive improvements and the project lives on today as the amsreader firmware: https://github.com/UtilitechAS/amsreader-firmware
used in AMS readers sold by Utilitech AS: https://amsleser.no

@ohjohnsen
Copy link

ohjohnsen commented Nov 18, 2024

The maintenance of the project was continued by @gskjold when @roarfred passed away. Since then, @gskjold has done massive improvements and the project lives on today as the amsreader firmware: https://github.com/UtilitechAS/amsreader-firmware used in AMS readers sold by Utilitech AS: https://amsleser.no

Awesome that the firmware is still being improved! It seems the hardware itself has become closed source though, as amsleser.no only sell the prebuilt device.

@ArnieO
Copy link

ArnieO commented Nov 19, 2024

The maintenance of the project was continued by @gskjold when @roarfred passed away. Since then, @gskjold has done massive improvements and the project lives on today as the amsreader firmware: https://github.com/UtilitechAS/amsreader-firmware used in AMS readers sold by Utilitech AS: https://amsleser.no

Awesome that the firmware is still being improved! It seems the hardware itself has become closed source though, as amsleser.no only sell the prebuilt device.

It was me that founded amsleser.no, and later formally teamed up with @gskjold to establish Utilitech AS which now owns and runs the project.

Development and maintenance of both hardware and software is a significant task - and our business model is to sell devices at an affordable price. DIYers are free to use the firmware on personal projects, under a "Fair use" license. That license is as close as you can get to "Open source" while still protecting us from other companies that could use it on hardware they sell.

A Swiss company did exactly that; sold "copy" hardware with our firmware. They even downloaded the STL file of one of our 3D printed enclosures, changed the logo and sold it for use on their own copycat boards. And they claimed they were perfectly entitled to do so.

So: Correct, we need to be a bit cautious to protect the value of all the work laid down. We do not publish the design files for the hardware, and we only sell prebuilt devices.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants