Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

No bonds beween atoms...? #41

Open
spyda90 opened this issue May 29, 2024 · 8 comments
Open

No bonds beween atoms...? #41

spyda90 opened this issue May 29, 2024 · 8 comments

Comments

@spyda90
Copy link

spyda90 commented May 29, 2024

Hi,

Thank you for developing NeuralPlexer. We ran our first attempts on a very challenging protein and we obtained promising results, most of all very different from the (useless) ones obtained with our tools.

However, the ligand protein complexes we obtained have a "normal" protein for some amino acids streches while in other ones many bonds are missing (for example, a Leucine residue is represented with all the atoms (putatively at the right distances) but no bonds are there).
The longest stretch where this happens is about 50aa.

In order to proceed with other studies (e.g. MDs) we'd like to solve this issue. What can be the reason why is this happening?

Thank you in advance.

Francesco

@Luke-ebbis
Copy link

Hey @spyda90 is this issue related to #40 ? Can you share more information, I'd like to reproduce it

@spyda90
Copy link
Author

spyda90 commented May 29, 2024

Hi,

It may be similar to #40 but it happens in many other atoms.
Here you are the command line:

neuralplexer-inference --task=batched_structure_sampling --input-receptor 'SHMELTPDQQTLLHFIMDSYNKQRMPQEITNKILKEEFSAEENFLILTEMATNHVQVLVEFTKKLPGFQTLDHEDQIALLKGSAVEAMFLRSAEIFNKKLPSGHSDLLEERIRNSGISDEYITPMFSFYKSIGELKMTQEEYALLTAIVILSPDRQYIKDREAVEKLQEPLLDVLQKLCKIHQPENPQHFACLLGRLTELRTFNHHHAEMLMSWRVNDHKFTPLLCEIWDVQ|KENALLRYLLDKD' --input-ligand FXR/ZGUG.sdf --out-path FXR/ --model-checkpoint neuralplexermodels_downstream_datasets_predictions/models/complex_structure_prediction.ckpt --n-samples 16 --chunk-size 4 --num-steps=40 --cuda --sampler=langevin_simulated_annealing

This is how it appears:
complex1_focus_GUG

Carbons and some nitrogens are there. No oxygens, no bonds. Where ribbons are present, amino acids are fine.

Please let me know if you need something more.

@spyda90
Copy link
Author

spyda90 commented Jun 18, 2024

Hi, any news about this issue?

@Luke-ebbis
Copy link

Hey Spyda, I have no news on the issue, I've been waiting too. If you send me your SDF file, I can try to run it on my system. Then we can see whether the problem persists on different platforms.

@spyda90
Copy link
Author

spyda90 commented Jul 15, 2024

Hi, how can I send you a SDF file? The system do not let me send SDF here. Thank you

@Luke-ebbis
Copy link

Hey @spyda90, you could deposit it on zenodo, or specify a download link (like I did in #49). Looking forward to seeing what my installation does.

@Luke-ebbis
Copy link

@spyda90 I found this structure

image

See the attachment

issue.zip

Call was

apptainer run --nv results/dependencies/neuralplexer/neuralplexer.sif neuralplexer-inference --task=batched_structure_sampling --model-checkpoint results/dependencies/neuralplexer/data/neuralplexermodels_downstream_datasets_predictions/models/complex_structure_prediction.ckpt --out-path results/data/issue-41/issue-41/ --input-receptor 'SHMELTPDQQTLLHFIMDSYNKQRMPQEITNKILKEEFSAEENFLILTEMATNHVQVLVEFTKKLPGFQTLDHEDQIALLKGSAVEAMFLRSAEIFNKKLPSGHSDLLEERIRNSGISDEYITPMFSFYKSIGELKMTQEEYALLTAIVILSPDRQYIKDREAVEKLQEPLLDVLQKLCKIHQPENPQHFACLLGRLTELRTFNHHHAEMLMSWRVNDHKFTPLLCEIWDVQ|KENALLRYLLDKD' --input-ligand 'data/ZGUG.sdf' --sampler langevin_simulated_annealing --n-samples 1 --chunk-size 1 --num-steps=5 --cuda

@spyda90
Copy link
Author

spyda90 commented Jul 22, 2024

Hi,
In Pymol everything seems fine, but loading up in Maestro you can see how there are no connections between several atoms (still).

So, unfortunately, the issue is still there...

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants