Table of Contents

• Overview
  • Start Using
• How Does it Work?
  • Beekeeper Architecture
  • Unreferenced Paths
  • Time To Live, TTL
  • Hive Table Configuration
• Running Beekeeper
  • Using Docker
  • Endpoints
  • Application Configuration
  • Beekeeper-API
• External Links
• Legal

Overview

Beekeeper is a service that schedules orphaned paths and expired metadata for deletion.

The original inspiration for a data deletion tool came from another of our open source projects called Circus Train. At a high level, Circus Train replicates Hive datasets. The datasets are copied as immutable snapshots to ensure strong consistency and snapshot isolation, only pointing the replicated Hive Metastore to the new snapshot on successful completion. This process leaves behind snapshots of data which are now unreferenced by the Hive Metastore, so Circus Train includes a Housekeeping module to delete these files later.

Beekeeper is based on Circus Train's Housekeeping module, however it is decoupled from Circus Train so it can be used by other applications as well.

Start using

To deploy Beekeeper in AWS, see the terraform repo.

Docker images can be found in Expedia Group's dockerhub.

How does it work?

Beekeeper makes use of Apiary - an open source federated cloud data lake - to detect changes in the Hive Metastore. One of Apiary’s components, the Apiary Metastore Listener, captures Hive events and publishes these as messages to an SNS topic. Beekeeper uses these messages to detect changes to the Hive Metastore, and perform appropriate deletions.

Beekeeper is comprised of separate Spring-based Java applications:

1. Scheduler Apiary - An application that schedules paths and metadata for deletion in a shared database, with one table for unreferenced paths and another for expired metadata.
2. Path Cleanup - An application that perform deletions of unreferenced paths.
3. Metadata Cleanup - An application that perform deletions of expired metadata.
4. Beekeeper API - A REST API that allows to see what metadata and paths are in the database.

Beekeeper Architecture

Unreferenced paths

The "unreferenced" property can be added to tables to detect when paths become unreferenced. It will currently only be triggered by these events:

• alter_partition
• alter_table
• drop_partition
• drop_table

By default, alter_partition and alter_table events require no further configuration. However, in order to avoid unexpected data loss, other event types require whitelisting on a per table basis. See Hive table configuration for more details.

To check whether a table has been configured with the "unreferenced" property, the beekeeper-api can be used to look for the table and its current unreferenced paths (see Unreferenced paths).

End-to-end lifecycle example

1. A Hive table is configured with the parameter beekeeper.remove.unreferenced.data=true (see Hive table configuration for more details.)
2. An operation is executed on the table that orphans some data (alter partition, drop partition, etc.)
3. Hive Metastore events are emitted by the Hive Metastore Listener as a result of the operation.
4. Hive events are picked up from the queue by Beekeeper using the Apiary Receiver.
5. Beekeeper processes these messages and schedules orphaned paths for deletion by adding them to a database.
6. The scheduled paths are deleted by Beekeeper after a configurable delay, the default is 3 days (see Hive table configuration for more details.)

Time To Live, TTL

The "expired" TTL property will delete tables, partitions, and their locations after a configurable delay. If no delay is specified the default is 30 days.

If the table is partitioned the cleanup delay will also apply to each partition that is added to the table. The table will only be dropped when there are no remaining partitions.

To see whether a table has been configured to use the TTL feature, the beekeeper-api metadata endpoint can be used to check if a table has been successfully registered in the Beekeeper database and see when it is going to be deleted. More information in the Beekeeper API section.

End-to-end lifecycle example

1. A Hive table is configured with the TTL parameter beekeeper.remove.expired.data=true (see Hive table configuration for more details).
2. This Hive event is picked up from the queue by Beekeeper using the Apiary Receiver, and the table is scheduled for cleanup with a configurable delay.
3. An operation is executed on the table which alters it in some way, (alter table, add partition, alter partition)
4. These Hive events are once again picked up from the queue by Beekeeper using the Apiary receiver. Depending on the event, Beekeeper will do the following:
   • Alter table - Creates a new entry in the database with the updated table info
   • Add partition - The partition is scheduled to be deleted using the cleanup delay of the table
   • Alter partition - Creates a new entry in the database with the updated partition info
5. The scheduled partitions, tables, and associated paths will be deleted by Beekeeper after the delay has passed.

TTL Caveats

Currently with the first release of Beekeeper TTL there are the following issues:

• If you add the TTL property to a partitioned table any existing partitions will not be scheduled for deletion. They will be deleted along with the table when the TTL delay is met.
• If a table or partition is dropped by a user before the expiration time the related paths will become unreferenced and won’t be cleaned up.
  • This can be avoided by also adding the "unreferenced" property to the table, see the unreferenced paths section. However, this property listens to any drop event on that table and we haven’t yet configured Beekeeper to ignore drop events made by itself. So this will mean that any path for a table/partition dropped by Beekeeper during the TTL cleanup will be scheduled for deletion again in the unreferenced cleanup table.
• If a partitioned table with existing partitions is renamed, these partitions will not be dropped until the table has expired.
  • For example: A table is created with a cleanup delay of 2 days and a partition is added. The delay is changed to 10 days and the table is then renamed. With the current release the existing partition won’t be rescheduled to be deleted under the new table. So it will be deleted along with the table in 10 days instead of 2.

Hive table configuration

Beekeeper only actions on events which are marked with specific parameters. These parameters need to be added to the Hive table that you wish to be monitored by Beekeeper. The configuration parameters for Hive tables are as follows:

Parameter	Required	Possible values	Description
beekeeper.remove.unreferenced.data=true	Yes	true or false	Set this parameter to ensure Beekeeper monitors your table for orphaned data.
beekeeper.unreferenced.data.retention.period=X	No	e.g. P7D or PT3H (based on ISO 8601 format)	Set this parameter to control the delay between schedule and deletion by Beekeeper. If this is either not set, or configured incorrectly, the default will be used. Default is 3 days.
beekeeper.hive.event.whitelist=X	No	Comma separated list of event types to whitelist for orphaned data. Valid event values are: alter_partition, alter_table, drop_table, drop_partition.	Beekeeper will only process whitelisted events. Default value: alter_partition, alter_table.
beekeeper.remove.expired.data=true	Yes	true or false	Set this parameter to enable TTL on your table.
beekeeper.expired.data.retention.period=X	No	e.g. P7D or PT3H (based on ISO 8601 format)	Set this parameter to control the TTL duration for your table. If this is either not set, or configured incorrectly, the default value of P30D (30 days) will be used.

Usage

Unreferenced Paths

This command can be used to add the parameter to a Hive Table:

ALTER TABLE <table-name> SET TBLPROPERTIES("beekeeper.remove.unreferenced.data"="true");

TTL

You can either add the property when the table is created:

CREATE TABLE <table> (<col_name> <type>, ... ) TBLPROPERTIES("beekeeper.remove.expired.data"="true", "beekeeper.expired.data.retention.period"="PT2M");

Or alter an existing table:

ALTER TABLE <table> SET TBLPROPERTIES("beekeeper.remove.expired.data"="true", "beekeeper.expired.data.retention.period"="PT1H");

NOTE - if you add this property to a partitioned table any existing partitions will not be scheduled for deletion. They will be deleted along with the table when the TTL delay is met.

Running Beekeeper

All the Beekeeper modules run independently of each other:

• beekeeper-path-cleanup periodically queries a database for paths to delete and performs deletions.
• beekeeper-metadata-cleanup periodically queries a database for metadata to delete and performs deletions on hive tables, partitions, and s3 paths.
• beekeeper-scheduler-apiary periodically polls an Apiary SQS queue for Hive Metastore events and inserts S3 paths and Hive tables to be deleted into a database, scheduling them for deletion.
• beekeeper-api allows to retrieve information from the database and see what has been scheduled for deletion.

All applications (except the beekeeper-api) require configuration to be provided, see Application configuration for details.

java -jar <spring-boot-application>.jar --config=<config>.yml

<config>.yml takes this format:

spring.datasource:
  url: jdbc:mysql://<database-url>:3306/beekeeper?useSSL=false
  username: <username>
  password: <password>   
  
# other config

This can be provided via a file or Spring can load properties from the environment (see below).

Using Docker

Three Docker images are created during mvn install - two for cleanup of paths and metadata, and one for scheduling.

Configuration can be provided in one of two ways:

1. Using environment variables.

docker run --env-file <config-env>.env <image-id>

<config-env>.env takes this format:

spring_datasource_url=jdbc:mysql://<database-url>:3306/beekeeper?useSSL=false
spring_datasource_username=<user>
spring_datasource_password=<password>

# other config

Any additional configuration can be added in a similar way as the app will load properties from the docker environment.

2. Using a base64 encoded properties file as an environment variable:

export BEEKEEPER_CONFIG=$(base64 -w 0 -i <config>.yml)
docker run -e BEEKEEPER_CONFIG=$BEEKEEPER_CONFIG <image-id>

<config>.yml takes this format:

spring.datasource:
  url: jdbc:mysql://<database-url>:3306/beekeeper?useSSL=false
  username: <username>
  password: <password>   
  
# other config

Database password

To avoid the problem of a plaintext password, AWS Secrets Manager is supported.

To use Secrets Manager, remove the password from the <config>.yml:

spring.datasource:
  url: jdbc:mysql://<database-url>:3306/beekeeper?useSSL=false
  username: <username>
  
# other config

and provide the password strategy and password key when running the container:

docker run -e BEEKEEPER_CONFIG=$BEEKEEPER_CONFIG -e DB_PASSWORD_STRATEGY=aws-secrets-manager -e DB_PASSWORD_KEY <password-key> <image-id>

Local dockerised database

If you would like to connect a dockerised application to a local MySQL database (e.g. initialised from docker-compose up), the two containers need to be on the same network:

docker run --network beekeeper_default <image-id>

where <database-url> is the name of the running MySQL container.

Endpoints

Being a Spring Boot Application, all standard actuator endpoints are supported.

For example, the healthcheck endpoint at: http://<address>:<port>/actuator/health.

Each application listens on a different port:

Application	Port
beekeeper-path-cleanup	8008
beekeeper-metadata-cleanup	9008
beekeeper-scheduler-apiary	8080
beekeeper-api	7008

To access an endpoint when running in a Docker container, the port must be published:

docker run -p <port>:<port> <image-id>

Application configuration

Beekeeper Scheduler Apiary

Property	Required	Description
apiary.queue-url	Yes	URL for SQS queue.
beekeeper.default-cleanup-delay	No	Default Time To Live (TTL) for orphaned paths in ISO 8601 format: only days, hours, minutes and seconds can be specified in the expression. Default value is P3D (3 days).
beekeeper.default-expiration-delay	No	Default Time To Live (TTL) for tables in ISO 8601 format: only days, hours, minutes and seconds can be specified in the expression. Default value is P30D (30 days).

Beekeeper Path Cleanup

Property	Required	Description
cleanup-page-size	No	Number of rows that should be processed in one page. Default value is 500.
dry-run-enabled	No	Enable to simply display the deletions that would be performed, without actually doing so. Default value is false.
scheduler-delay-ms	No	Amount of time (in milliseconds) between consecutive cleanups. Default value is 300000 (5 minutes after the previous cleanup completes).
old-data-cleanup-cron	No	Cron expression which sets the schedule for the cleanup of old rows in the housekeeping_path table. Default is 0 0 13 * * ? (every day at 1pm).
old-data-retention-period-days	No	Number of days to keep old rows in the housekeeping_path table after their corresponding data is deleted. Default is 182 (6 months).

Beekeeper Metadata Cleanup

Property	Required	Description
cleanup-page-size	No	Number of rows that should be processed in one page. Default value is 500.
dry-run-enabled	No	Enable to simply display the deletions that would be performed, without actually doing so. Default value is false.
scheduler-delay-ms	No	Amount of time (in milliseconds) between consecutive cleanups. Default value is 300000 (5 minutes after the previous cleanup completes).
Metastore-uri	Yes	URI of the Hive Metastore where tables to be cleaned-up are located.
old-data-cleanup-cron	No	Cron expression which sets the schedule for the cleanup of old rows in the housekeepin_metadata table. Default is 0 0 13 * * ? (every day at 1pm).
old-data-retention-period-days	No	Number of days to keep old rows in the housekeepin_metadata table after their corresponding data is deleted. Default is 182 (6 months).

Beekeeper-API

Beekeeper also has an API which provides read access to the Beekeeper database and allows seeing what metadata and paths are currently being managed.

It allows to manually enter a database and a table name and check whether this table has been successfully registered in Beekeeper along with things like the current status of the table, the date and time it will be deleted, the current cleanup delay, etc.

It currently supports two endpoints; one for the expired metadata and another one for the unreferenced paths.

As well as supporting all standard actuator endpoints, the Beekeeper-API also supports the swagger endpoint (see the Swagger documentation), which provides a visual documentation of the structure of the API, making it easy to explore its capabilities. This is a good start if it's the first time the user is using the API. It can be accessed at this url:

http://<host>/swagger-ui.html

For the two main endpoints, the base url (will be referred to as <base-url> in the following sections) is

http://<host>/api/v1

and the rest of the url will depend on which endpoint needs to be accessed (see Expired metadata endpoint and Unreferenced paths endpoint).

It also supports different filters (see filtering section).

Expired metadata endpoint (GET /metadata)

This endpoint will return the TTL configuration of all expired partitions that are going to be deleted (or have been deleted) in a specific table. If it is unpartitioned it will just show one object; the table.

<base-url>/database/{databaseName}/table/{tableName}/metadata

where {databaseName} and {tableName} must be replaced by the database and table name that needs to be searched for. So for example, if they wanted to check a table called my_cool_table in the database my_cool_database, they would go to

<base-url>/database/my_cool_database/table/my_cool_table/metadata

The API will display all the partitions in that table unless it is unpartitioned, in that case it will show only one object; the table. To check only the table object without all of its individual partitions, search for the one with the variable "partitionName"=null as such:

{
    "path": "s3://mybucket/mydatabase/mytable",
    "databaseName": "mydatabase",
    "tableName": "mytable",
    "partitionName": null,
    "housekeepingStatus": "DELETED",
    "creationTimestamp": "2020-09-14T17:22:55",
    "modifiedTimestamp": "2020-09-14T18:36:52",
    "cleanupTimestamp": "2020-09-14T17:36:32",
    "cleanupDelay": "PT10M",
    "cleanupAttempts": 1,
    "lifecycleType": "EXPIRED"
}

This is possible using filters. To search for the table object, a filter with the path to the table will be needed, for example

<base-url>/database/{databaseName}/table/{tableName}/metadata?path=s3://mybucket/mydatabase/mytable

Unreferenced paths endpoint (GET /unreferenced-paths)

This endpoint will return the configuration of all unreferenced paths that are going to be deleted (or have been deleted) in a specific table. If it is unpartitioned it will just show one object; the table.

It is available in this url;

<base-url>/database/{databaseName}/table/{tableName}/unreferenced-paths

where {databaseName} and {tableName} must be replaced by the database and table name that needs to be searched for. So for example, if they wanted to check a table called my_cool_table in the database my_cool_database, they would go to

<base-url>/database/my_cool_database/table/my_cool_table/unreferenced-paths

Filtering

Both endpoints are different but they share the same filtering capabilities. The following table gives an overview of the filters available:

Filter name	Description	Example
path	Given a path name, return if there is a path with that name	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata?path= s3://mybucket/mydb/mytable/myfile.part0001
partition_name	Given a partition name, return the partitions with that name	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?partition_name=event_date=2020-01-01/event_hour=0/event_type=B
housekeeping_status	Given a housekeeping status, return all partitions with that status (SCHEDULED, FAILED or DELETED)	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?housekeeping_status=SCHEDULED
lifecycle_type	Given a lifecycle type, return all partitions with that lifecycle (EXPIRED or UNREFERENCED). Note: currently this filter is useless as the first endpoint only returns EXPIRED metadata and the second only returns UNREFERENCED paths	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?lifecycle_type=EXPIRED
registered_before	Given a timestamp, it will return all partitions that were registered in Beekeeper before that time	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?registered_before=2021-02-25T15:33:05
registered_after	Given a timestamp, it will return all partitions that were registered in Beekeeper after that time	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?registered_after=2021-02-25T15:33:05
deleted_before	Given a timestamp, it will return all partitions that were deleted before that time	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?deleted_before=2021-02-25T15:33:05
deleted_after	Given a timestamp, it will return all partitions that were deleted after that time	/database/my_database_name /table/my_table_name/metadata ?deleted_after=2021-02-25T15:33:05

Note: the partition_name filter is only available for the expired metadata endpoint, as this variable is not available in the paths.

Metrics

Beekeeper currently supports Graphite and Prometheus metrics.

Prometheus metrics are exposed at /actuator/prometheus.

Graphite metrics require configuration to enable. If Graphite is enabled, both host and prefix are required. If they are not provided, the application will throw an exception and not start.

The following table shows the configuration that can be provided:

Property	Required	Description
graphite.enabled	No	Enable to produce Graphite metrics. Default value is false.
graphite.host	If enabled	Graphite host.
graphite.prefix	If enabled	Prefix for Graphite metrics.
graphite.port	No	Graphite port. Default is 2003.
prometheus.prefix	No	Prefix for Prometheus metrics. Default value is beekeeper.

External links

Please see the Housekeeping library for more information.

Legal

This project is available under the Apache 2.0 License.

Copyright 2019-2020 Expedia, Inc.