Major rebase and updates to the original proposal

This change rebases the original extension on main. It also
brings many modifications from discussions within the Khronos SI
group and this MR:
- Add a proposal document
- Rely on VK_KHR_present_id to identify presents
- Split out VK_PRESENT_MODE_FIFO_LATEST_READY_EXT
- Add physical device and surface capabilities
- Define "presentation" as a set of well-defined multiple steps
- Explicitly describe the internal results queue interactions
- Add many per-present parameters, allowing to remove swapchain state
- Refine VRR support
- Cleanup appendix and update contributors
- Replace present slop with a flag to round to nearest refresh cycle
- Refine mechanisms for feedback about time domains and timing properties updates
- Allow timing results to be returned incomplete and out of order

appendices/VK_EXT_present_timing.adoc

@@ -1,11 +1,13 @@
-// Copyright (c) 2017-2022 Khronos Group.
+// Copyright (c) 2017-2024 Khronos Group.
 //
 // SPDX-License-Identifier: CC-BY-4.0
 
 include::{generated}/meta/{refprefix}VK_EXT_present_timing.adoc[]
 
+=== Other Extension Metadata
+
 *Last Modified Date*::
-    2020-07-06
+    2024-05-30
 *IP Status*::
     No known IP claims.
 *Contributors*::
@@ -21,9 +23,15 @@ include::{generated}/meta/{refprefix}VK_EXT_present_timing.adoc[]
   - Alon Or-Bach, Samsung
   - Niklas Smedberg, Unity Technologies
   - Tobias Hector, AMD
+  - Lionel Duc, NVIDIA
+  - Lina Versace, Google
+  - Sebastian Wick, Red Hat
+  - Jakob Bornecrantz, Collabora
+
+=== Description
 
 This device extension allows an application that uses the
-`<<VK_KHR_swapchain>>` extension to obtain information about the
+`apiext:VK_KHR_swapchain` extension to obtain information about the
 presentation engine's display, to obtain timing information about each
 present, and to schedule a present to happen no earlier than a desired time.
 An application can use this to minimize various visual anomalies (e.g.
@@ -41,7 +49,6 @@ no sooner than a given time.
 This allows the application to avoid stuttering, so the animation looks
 smooth to the user.
 
-
 include::{generated}/interfaces/VK_EXT_present_timing.adoc[]
 
 === Issues
@@ -61,7 +68,7 @@ pname:refreshDuration is non-zero, at which point the FRR vs. VRR
 indication will also be valid.
 
 If the presentation engine's pname:refreshDuration is a fixed value,
-the application's image present duration (IPD) must be a multiple of
+the application's image present duration (IPD) should be a multiple of
 pname:refreshDuration.
 That is, the quanta for changing the IPD is pname:refreshDuration.
 For example, if pname:refreshDuration is 16.67ms, the IPD can be
@@ -85,8 +92,6 @@ fixed; but can change over time.
 For example, if a full-screen video player application is visible, the display
 may operate at a 24Hz refresh cycle; and then later switch to 60Hz when
 multiple windows are visible.
-The special value of zero for pname:refreshDuration is used to
-indicate the condition where the platform cannot yet answer the query.
 
 VRR displays on some platforms can also be seen as having different
 characteristics over time.
@@ -96,11 +101,11 @@ display (however that is defined).
 If the application's window is not full-screen-exclusive (e.g. a normal
 multi-window case), the display can look like an FRR display (i.e. because the
 compositor is trying to treat all windows in a consistent manner).
-A different issue will deal with these how the timing characteristics
-can change over time.
+A different issue will deal with how the timing characteristics can change
+over time.
 
 
-2) Do we return min/max Values for Refresh Duration for VRR?
+2) Do we return min/max values for refresh duration for VRR?
 
 *PROPOSED*: return only the minimum value of refreshDuration for a VRR.
 
@@ -119,8 +124,8 @@ artifacts.
 3) How to deal with changes in timing properties?
 
 *RESOLVED*: The slink:VkPastPresentationTimingEXT structure that is
-returned by flink:vkGetPastPresentationTimingEXT will contain
-pname:timeDomainChanged, which will be ename:VK_TRUE if the time
+returned by flink:vkGetPastPresentationTimingEXT contains
+pname:timeDomainChanged, which is ename:VK_TRUE if the time
 domain enabled for the swapchain is not currently available.
 
 An example of why display timing properties can change is if a surface
@@ -140,34 +145,33 @@ visible and VRR otherwise.
 4) One Query for all Timing info vs. an initial query to determine FRR vs. VRR,
 and then FRR-specific vs VRR-specific queries?
 
-*PROPOSED*: Have one query, as described in issue 1, that can be
+*RESOLVED*: Have one query, as described in issue 1, that can be
 called whenever the application needs to obtain the timing properties
 of the surface.
 
 
-5) Query to Determine Time Domain?
+5) Query to determine time domain?
 
-*PROPOSED*: Have a query to determine the time domain.
-This extension will define some return values, including some that are
-platform-specific.
-Other extensions can add other time domains.
+*RESOLVED*: Have a query to determine the time domain.
+This extension defines a basic swapchain-local time domain.
+Other extensions can add other platform-specific time domains.
 
 
-6) What Time to use for targetPresentTime for Early Images?
+6) What time to use for targetPresentTime for early images?
 
 *PROPOSED*: Have no query for determining the current time in the PE’s time
-domain; and do allow the special value of zero for targetPresentTime and
-idealPresentTime, meaning that there is no target nor ideal time.
+domain; and do allow the special value of zero for targetPresentTime,
+meaning that there is no target.
 
 On some platforms, there is no way to determine the current time, nor
 to determine surface timing properties until after at least one image
 has been presented.
 
 In such cases, the special value of zero allows the application to
 indicate that timing feedback is desired, but that no
-targetPresentTime nor idealPresentTime is requested.
+targetPresentTime is requested.
 Later, once the application has obtained feedback, it can specify
-targetPresentTime and idealPresentTime.
+targetPresentTime by using the result's actualPresentTime.
 
 
 7) How long before an application’s request for new image duration is honored?
@@ -188,68 +192,48 @@ The first time (from the call till the image is presented) generally doesn’t
 matter, because the application will likely be providing a targetPresentTime
 (i.e. the application may have some indication for how long this will be).
 However, the latency between targetPresentTime until feedback is available may
-be much long.
+be much longer.
 For example, on Android on the 1st-generation Pixel phone (60Hz FRR display),
 the latency was approximately 5 refresh cycles (83.33ms).
 For higher-frequency displays, the latency may have a larger number of refresh
 cycles.
 
-Is there value in having a query for the application to know how long it may
-have to wait for feedback?
-Can such a query be reasonably answered by the driver?
-
-Is there other interesting information in this space that we may wish to
-capture?
+Can such a query be reasonably answered by the driver? Is there other
+interesting information in this space that we may wish to capture?
 
 
 9) Do we have a query(s) about the number of VkPastPresentationTimingEXT
 structs to keep?
 
-*UNRESOLVED*: At the Montreal F2F, there was discussion about how much
-feedback that the driver needs to keep and/or how much feedback that
-the application needs to be able to query.
-
-The way that the LunarG cube demo (official WSI example code) used
-VK_GOOGLE_display_timing, and what is proposed for the new extension is that
-the application query what feedback is available during every render-present
-loop.
-If the application never skips querying for feedback, and always obtains
-whatever feedback is available, there doesn’t seem much need for such a
-query(s).
-What I saw with the cube demo on a Pixel phone was that most of the time, the
-application obtained feedback for 1 previous present.
-Occasionally, it would get 2 VkPastPresentationTimingEXT structs on time and
-then 0 the next (or vice versa).
-
-Perhaps, a video player application might present several images at once, and
-then later get feedback for several images at the same time.
-That would be the most-likely use-case that I can come up with for why a query
-might be useful.
-Is that compelling enough?
-
-What might the model for the query(s) be?
-Potentially the application can tell the driver how many presents it might do
-at a time, and the driver can use that to size its internal buffer.
-Is there value in having a query that would influence the driver’s behavior
-(beyond what’s provided for in the currently-proposed API)?
+*PROPOSED*: Let the application specify at swapchain creation how many
+results the swapchain is allowed to store before querying them with
+vkGetPastPresentationTimingEXT.
+
 
 10) How is the SWAPCHAIN_LOCAL time domain used with the calibrated
 timestamps extension?
 
-PROPOSED: Define a struct to chain into VkCalibratedTimestampInfoEXT::pNext
+*PROPOSED*: Define a struct to chain into VkCalibratedTimestampInfoEXT::pNext
 that specifies a swapchain.
 Is anything additional needed for
 vkGetPhysicalDeviceCalibrateableTimeDomainsEXT, or are swapchain-local
 timestamps always calibrateable or always not calibrateable for a given
 device?
 
+
 11) Should VK_PRESENT_MODE_FIFO_LATEST_READY_EXT be part of this extension,
 or split out into its own extension?
 
-PROPOSED: It is only tangentially related.
+*RESOLVED*: It is only tangentially related.
 Split it out into its own extension and define the interaction here.
 
 === Version History
 
   * Revision 1, 2018-05-11 (Ian Elliott)
-  ** Internal revisions
+  ** Internal revisions.
+
+  * Revision 2, 2022-11-30 (Lionel Duc)
+  ** Rebase for public discussions.
+
+  * Revision 3, 2024-05-29 (Lionel Duc)
+  ** Public revisions.

appendices/glossary.adoc

@@ -836,7 +836,8 @@ Image Present Duration::
 Image Present Rate::
     The number of newly-presented images the application intends to present
     each second (a.k.a. frame rate).
-    This value should: be a multiple of the refresh rate.
+    On fixed refresh rate displays, this value should: be a multiple of
+    the refresh rate.
 endif::VK_EXT_present_timing,VK_GOOGLE_display_timing[]
 
 Image Subresource::