You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Possible Bug: The PR introduces new tests for seccomp profiles, but it's unclear if the tests handle exceptions or edge cases related to seccomp profile failures or misconfigurations. It would be beneficial to include negative test cases or error handling scenarios.
Code Organization: The PR adds new classes and methods which are well-organized, but the separation of concerns could be improved. For instance, the SeccompProfileTests class in seccomp_tests.py could be split into more granular classes or modules based on functionality to enhance maintainability.
Dependency Management: The PR includes changes in systest-cli.py and other scripts that import new modules. It's important to ensure that these dependencies are properly managed and compatible with the existing system to avoid runtime issues.
Apply more restrictive actions to critical syscalls in the Seccomp profile
To enhance the security posture, consider specifying more granular actions for certain syscalls instead of a blanket SCMP_ACT_ALLOW. For example, critical syscalls like execve, clone, and mount could be set to SCMP_ACT_ERRNO to prevent their usage unless explicitly needed.
Why: Specifying more granular actions for critical syscalls like execve, clone, and mount significantly enhances security by preventing their usage unless explicitly needed.
10
Change the default action for unspecified syscalls to log instead of error
To ensure better security and maintainability, consider specifying a defaultAction of SCMP_ACT_LOG for syscalls not explicitly allowed or denied. This will log all non-specified syscalls without stopping them, which can be useful for debugging and understanding application behavior without compromising security.
Why: Changing the default action to log can help in debugging and understanding application behavior without stopping the application. However, it may not be suitable for all environments, especially where security is a higher priority than logging.
7
Maintainability
Remove duplicate syscalls from the Seccomp profile
Remove duplicate syscall entries to clean up the Seccomp profile and avoid potential confusion. For instance, mmap, futex, setsockopt, epoll_wait, and getsockname are listed more than once.
Why: Removing duplicate syscalls improves the maintainability and readability of the Seccomp profile, reducing potential confusion and errors.
9
Replace hard-coded JSON file path with a constant for better maintainability
Instead of using a hard-coded string for the JSON file path in the validate_test function, consider using a constant or a configuration setting. This will make the code more maintainable and flexible if the path needs to change in the future.
-Logger.logger.info(f"Test '{test_name}' is defined in ['{json_file_path}'] JSON.")+JSON_FILE_PATH = 'system_test_mapping.json'+Logger.logger.info(f"Test '{test_name}' is defined in ['{JSON_FILE_PATH}'] JSON.")
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8
Why: Using a constant for the JSON file path improves maintainability and flexibility, making it easier to update the path in the future if needed. This is a good practice for configuration settings.
8
Group syscalls in the Seccomp profile for better readability and maintainability
Consider grouping syscalls by categories or functionalities to improve the readability and maintainability of the Seccomp profile. This can also help in managing large lists and making it easier to update or audit.
Why: Grouping syscalls by categories or functionalities enhances readability and maintainability, making it easier to manage and audit the profile.
8
Consolidate error handling in the main function to reduce code duplication
Refactor the error handling in the main function to consolidate the exit conditions into a single block to avoid code duplication and improve readability.
-if args.test_name not in ALL_TESTS:+if args.test_name not in ALL_TESTS or args.customer != CREDENTIALS.customer:
Logger.logger.error(
- f"Test '{args.test_name}' is not defined in the system tests. Please add the test and try again.")+ f"Test '{args.test_name}' is not defined in the system tests or customer '{args.customer}' is different from '{CREDENTIALS.customer}'.")
print_configurations()
exit(1)
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: Consolidating the error handling reduces code duplication and improves readability. However, it slightly reduces the granularity of error messages, which might be useful in some debugging scenarios.
7
Specify conditions under which tests should be skipped
For better control and understanding of when tests should be skipped, provide explicit conditions or environments in the 'skip_on_environment' field instead of leaving it empty.
Why: Specifying conditions for skipping tests enhances maintainability and clarity, but it is not as critical as ensuring ownership or meaningful descriptions. It is a good practice for better control over test execution.
7
Possible bug
Add a check to prevent IndexError when accessing elements in an empty list
Add a check to ensure that the applicationProfiles list is not empty before accessing its elements to avoid potential IndexError.
Why: Adding a check to ensure the list is not empty before accessing its elements prevents potential IndexError, which is crucial for avoiding runtime errors and improving code reliability.
9
Best practice
Ensure all test configurations have an owner specified
To avoid potential configuration errors, ensure that the 'owner' field is populated for all test configurations. This field is crucial for accountability and contact purposes in case of issues or required updates.
Why: Ensuring the 'owner' field is populated is crucial for accountability and maintenance. This is a best practice that helps in identifying responsible parties for each test configuration, which is important for operational efficiency.
9
Enhancement
Add meaningful descriptions to the test configurations
It is recommended to provide meaningful descriptions for each test configuration to help understand the purpose and scope of the tests. This will aid in maintenance and clarity for new developers or for audit purposes.
-"description": ""+"description": "Provide a meaningful description here."
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8
Why: Adding meaningful descriptions improves code maintainability and clarity, which is beneficial for new developers and for auditing purposes. This is a significant enhancement for documentation and understanding.
8
Possible issue
Verify and populate the target repositories for each test configuration
To ensure that the test configurations are targeting the correct repositories, verify and populate the 'target_repositories' field where it is currently empty. This prevents the tests from being inadvertently skipped or misconfigured.
Why: Populating the 'target_repositories' field is important to ensure tests are correctly configured and not inadvertently skipped. This is a significant improvement for preventing potential configuration issues.
8
Robustness
Add error handling for dictionary update to ensure robustness
Consider adding error handling for the update method call on helm_kwargs to handle potential exceptions when updating the dictionary, ensuring robustness.
-self.helm_kwargs.update(test_helm_kwargs)+try:+ self.helm_kwargs.update(test_helm_kwargs)+except Exception as e:+ Logger.logger.error(f"Failed to update helm_kwargs: {str(e)}")+ raise
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6
Why: Adding error handling for the dictionary update improves robustness by catching potential exceptions. However, the likelihood of an exception occurring in this context is relatively low.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
SeccompProfileTests
to the system tests, including pod and container level tests.systest-cli.py
.base_k8s.py
.Changes walkthrough 📝
5 files
tests.py
Add SeccompProfileTests to system tests.
configurations/system/tests.py
SeccompProfileTests
.SeccompProfileTests
inall_tests_names
andget_test
.kubectl_wrapper.py
Include SeccompProfile in kubectl wrapper resources.
infrastructure/kubectl_wrapper.py
SeccompProfile
to the list of known resources.systest-cli.py
Enhance error logging and formatting in systest-cli.
systest-cli.py
statics.py
Add seccomp path and application profile constants.
systest_utils/statics.py
DEFAULT_SECCOMP_PATH
for seccomp tests.APPLICATION_PROFILE_PLURAL
in known server constants.base_k8s.py
Implement method to get application profiles from storage.
tests_scripts/kubernetes/base_k8s.py
6 files
seccomp_tests.py
Implement SeccompProfileTests with pod and container level tests.
configurations/system/tests_cases/seccomp_tests.py
SeccompProfileTests
class.tests.
seccomp.py
Add SeccompProfile class for Helm and Kubescape integration.
tests_scripts/helm/seccomp.py
SeccompProfile
class for Helm and Kubescape integration.application.
nginx-seccomp-container.yaml
Add nginx deployment with container level seccomp profile.
configurations/k8s_workloads/seccomp/nginx-seccomp-container.yaml
level seccomp profile.
nginx-seccomp-pod.yaml
Add nginx deployment with pod level seccomp profile.
configurations/k8s_workloads/seccomp/nginx-seccomp-pod.yaml
seccomp profile.
seccomp-nginx.yaml
Add seccomp profile configuration for nginx.
configurations/k8s_workloads/seccomp/seccomp-nginx.yaml
system_test_mapping.json
Update system test mapping with seccomp profile tests.
system_test_mapping.json
seccomp_profile_pod
andseccomp_profile_container
tests.