Hydration #145
Hydration #145
Conversation
WalkthroughThe pull request introduces extensive modifications across multiple packages, enhancing the functionality and structure of the codebase. Key updates include the re-exporting of public entities from the Changes
Assessment against linked issues
Possibly related PRs
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 29
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (16)
packages/ciphernode/sortition/Cargo.toml (1)
13-20: Changes align well with PR objectives.The addition of new dependencies and the modular structure with the local 'data' crate align well with the PR objectives of implementing hydration for data persistence. These changes should facilitate better state management and testability.
Consider updating the package description to reflect the new data persistence capabilities, if applicable. For example:
- description = ": coordinates the encryption and decryption of enclave computations" + description = ": coordinates the encryption, decryption, and data persistence of enclave computations"packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (2)
Line range hint
35-42: Potential unbounded memory growth inself.logwhencaptureis trueWhen
captureis enabled, everyInsertoperation is logged intoself.log. If there are a large number of inserts, this could lead to unbounded memory usage.Consider implementing a mechanism to manage the size of
self.log, such as:
- Limiting the maximum size of
self.logand removing the oldest entries when the limit is exceeded.- Providing a method to clear or persist the log after processing.
Line range hint
55-59: Inefficient cloning ofself.loginGetLoghandlerCloning the entire
self.login theGetLoghandler can be inefficient, especially if the log is large.Consider returning a reference to
self.logor using an iterator to avoid cloning:impl Handler<GetLog> for InMemDataStore { - type Result = Vec<DataOp>; - fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Vec<DataOp> { - self.log.clone() + type Result = Vec<DataOp>; + fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Vec<DataOp> { + self.log.iter().cloned().collect() } }Alternatively, if the
Handlerresult allows for references with appropriate lifetimes:impl Handler<GetLog> for InMemDataStore { - type Result = Vec<DataOp>; - fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Vec<DataOp> { - self.log.clone() + type Result = &[DataOp]; + fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> &[DataOp] { + &self.log } }Ensure that lifetime annotations are correctly specified to prevent borrowing issues.
packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (1)
60-60: Reminder: Address the TODO to switch to the Sled actorThe comment indicates an intention to replace the in-memory data store with the Sled actor for persistence:
// TODO: switch to Sled actorImplementing this will enhance data persistence and reliability.
Would you like assistance in implementing the Sled actor integration or opening a GitHub issue to track this task?
packages/ciphernode/keyshare/src/keyshare.rs (1)
143-152: Enhance Error Logging with Additional ContextWhen an error occurs during decryption, the error message logs
error decrypting ciphertext. Including thee3_idor additional context in the error message can aid in debugging and quickly identifying the affected transaction.packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (1)
Line range hint
27-46: Handle potential parsing errors when converting node addressesIn the
SortitionModule::containsmethod, the code usesunwrap()when parsing node addresses:.map(|b| b.parse().unwrap())Using
unwrap()may cause the program to panic if parsing fails. It's safer to handle this error explicitly to prevent potential runtime crashes.Consider handling the parsing error as follows:
.map(|b| b.parse()) .collect::<Result<Vec<Address>, _>>()?;This way, any parsing errors will be propagated as
Resulterrors, allowing for graceful error handling.packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (4)
202-204: Avoid usingstras a parameter name to prevent shadowingThe parameter
strin theensure_root_idmethod shadows Rust's primitivestrtype. This can lead to confusion and potential errors. It is advisable to rename the parameter.Apply this diff to rename the parameter:
- pub fn ensure_root_id(str: &str) -> Result<()> { - if !str.starts_with("/") { + pub fn ensure_root_id(input: &str) -> Result<()> { + if !input.starts_with("/") {
204-204: Correct grammatical error in error messageThe error message in
ensure_root_idhas a grammatical mistake.Apply this diff to fix the error message:
- return Err(anyhow!("string doesnt start with slash.")); + return Err(anyhow!("String doesn't start with a slash."));
155-158: AddSendbound to typeTin asyncreadmethodThe
readmethod is async and may be sent across threads. To ensure thread safety, the typeTshould implement theSendtrait.Apply this diff to add the
Sendbound:pub async fn read<K, T>(&self, key: K) -> Result<Option<T>> where K: IntoKey, - T: for<'de> Deserialize<'de>, + T: for<'de> Deserialize<'de> + Send, {
171-173: Avoid cloning messages unnecessarilyIn the
setmethod, the messagemsgis cloned when applying the prefix. This clone may be unnecessary and can be avoided to improve performance.Apply this diff to avoid cloning:
- let msg = self.prefix.as_ref().map_or(msg.clone(), |p| msg.prefix(p)); + let msg = self.prefix.as_ref().map_or(msg, |p| msg.prefix(p));packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/publickey_aggregator.rs (1)
29-37: Consider renaming theinitmethod for idiomatic clarityThe
initmethod initializesPublicKeyAggregatorStateto theCollectingvariant. For better clarity and adherence to Rust conventions, consider renaming the method to reflect the variant it creates, such ascollecting, or providing associated functions for each variant.You might apply the following change:
impl PublicKeyAggregatorState { - pub fn init(threshold_m: usize, seed: Seed) -> Self { + pub fn collecting(threshold_m: usize, seed: Seed) -> Self { PublicKeyAggregatorState::Collecting { threshold_m, keyshares: OrderedSet::new(), seed, } } }packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (2)
93-96: Ensurefheinstance is available before proceedingGood job checking if the
fheinstance is available. However, consider providing more context in the error message to help with debugging.You might include additional information in the error message, such as the
e3_idor other relevant data.
171-179: Correct inconsistent indentation and formattingThere is inconsistent indentation and unnecessary blank lines which may affect code readability.
Ensure consistent use of indentation and remove unnecessary blank lines.
-let Some(fhe) = ctx.get_fhe() else { - self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::PlaintextAggregation, anyhow!("Could not create PlaintextAggregator because the fhe instance it depends on was not set on the context.")); - - return; -}; +let Some(fhe) = ctx.get_fhe() else { + self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::PlaintextAggregation, anyhow!("Could not create PlaintextAggregator because the FHE instance it depends on was not set on the context.")); + return; +};packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (1)
39-39: Reminder: Address the TODO commentThe TODO comment suggests replacing
InMemDataStorewith a sled-backed Data Actor for data persistence. Consider implementing this change to move from in-memory to persistent storage.Do you want me to help implement the sled-backed Data Actor or open a GitHub issue to track this task?
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (2)
113-142: Correct the method documentation to match the parametersThe documentation comments for
set_keyshare,set_plaintext,set_publickey,set_fhe, andset_metamention accepting a DataStore ID and an address or object, but the methods actually only accept a single parameter. Please update the documentation to accurately reflect the method parameters.
232-232: Address the TODO: Implement typestate pattern for feature dependenciesThere is a TODO comment indicating the need to set up a typestate pattern to enforce the correct order of feature dependencies. This would improve the modularity and robustness of the code by ensuring features are initialized in the correct sequence.
Would you like assistance in implementing this pattern or opening a GitHub issue to track this task?
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
packages/ciphernode/Cargo.lockis excluded by!**/*.lock
📒 Files selected for processing (20)
- packages/ciphernode/aggregator/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/plaintext_aggregator.rs (6 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/publickey_aggregator.rs (7 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/lib.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/aggregator.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/fhe/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/fhe/src/fhe.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/keyshare/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/keyshare/src/keyshare.rs (2 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/sortition/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (4 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (49)
packages/ciphernode/keyshare/Cargo.toml (1)
12-13: LGTM! The new dependencies align well with the PR objectives.The addition of
serdeandasync-traitdependencies is appropriate for implementing hydration and supporting asynchronous operations in the actor model. These changes are consistent with the PR objectives and the requirements outlined in issue #123.
serdewill facilitate serialization and deserialization, which is crucial for data persistence.async-traitwill enable the use of async methods in traits, supporting the asynchronous nature of the actor model.Both dependencies are configured to use the workspace version, maintaining consistency across the project.
packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml (1)
10-13: Excellent additions to support hydration and data persistence!The new dependencies (anyhow, serde, bincode, and async-trait) are well-chosen to support the PR's objective of implementing hydration for data persistence:
anyhowwill improve error handling, crucial for robust data operations.serdeenables serialization and deserialization, essential for data persistence.bincodeprovides efficient binary encoding, useful for compact data storage.async-traitallows for asynchronous trait methods, supporting non-blocking operations in the actor model.Using the workspace configuration for these dependencies ensures consistency across the project.
packages/ciphernode/aggregator/Cargo.toml (1)
9-15: LGTM! New dependencies align with PR objectives.The addition of
serde,async-trait, anddatadependencies is appropriate for implementing hydration and data persistence as outlined in the PR objectives. These changes will enhance the aggregator's capabilities for serialization, asynchronous operations, and data management.To ensure consistency in workspace usage, let's verify all dependencies:
packages/ciphernode/fhe/Cargo.toml (4)
8-8: LGTM: Addition ofasync-traitdependency.The addition of
async-traitas a workspace dependency is appropriate. It will enable the use of async functions in traits, which aligns with the PR objectives of implementing hydration and improving the actor model.
10-10: LGTM: Addition of localdatadependency.The addition of the local
datapackage as a dependency is appropriate. This aligns well with the PR objectives of implementing hydration and data persistence. Using a local path ensures that the package is part of the same repository, promoting modularity and easier maintenance.
11-11: LGTM: Reordering ofenclave-coreandfhe_rsdependencies.The reordering of the
enclave-coreandfhe_rsdependencies improves the organization and readability of the Cargo.toml file. This change doesn't affect functionality and is a good practice for maintaining clean dependency lists.Also applies to: 14-14
8-14: Summary: Dependencies updated to support hydration and data persistence.The changes to the dependencies in this Cargo.toml file align well with the PR objectives of implementing hydration and improving data persistence. The additions of
async-trait,bincode, and the localdatapackage provide the necessary tools for these improvements. The reordering of dependencies enhances readability.Note: There's an inconsistency in the AI-generated summary regarding the
bincodedependency. The summary stated it was removed, but it has actually been added.Overall, these changes support the goals of the PR and should contribute to the implementation of the desired features.
packages/ciphernode/router/Cargo.toml (1)
15-17: LGTM: New dependencies align with PR objectives.The addition of
serde,bincode, andasync-traitas dependencies is appropriate and aligns well with the PR objectives:
serde: Enables serialization and deserialization of Rust data structures, which is crucial for implementing hydration and data persistence.bincode: Complementsserdeby providing an efficient binary serialization format, further supporting the hydration process.async-trait: Allows for async functions in traits, which is beneficial for asynchronous operations in the actor-based system using Actix.These dependencies provide the necessary tools for effective state management and data handling, supporting the implementation of hydration for various components as outlined in the PR objectives.
packages/ciphernode/sortition/Cargo.toml (2)
13-20: Good job on improving dependency organization!The alphabetical reordering of dependencies and the explicit feature specification for 'alloy' enhance the readability and maintainability of the Cargo.toml file.
13-20: LGTM! New dependencies added appropriately.The addition of
anyhow,async-trait,data, andserdedependencies is well-structured and consistent with the project's workspace setup. This suggests improvements in error handling, asynchronous operations, data management, and serialization capabilities.To ensure these new dependencies are being utilized effectively, please run the following script:
✅ Verification successful
Dependencies Verified Successfully
All newly added dependencies (
anyhow,async-trait,data, andserde) are appropriately utilized within thesortitionpackage:
anyhowis used insortition.rsanddistance.rs.async_traitis applied insortition.rs.datais employed insortition.rs.serdeis utilized for serialization and deserialization insortition.rs.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the usage of newly added dependencies in the sortition package # Test: Search for the usage of new dependencies echo "Searching for 'anyhow' usage:" rg --type rust 'use anyhow' packages/ciphernode/sortition/src echo "Searching for 'async_trait' usage:" rg --type rust '#\[async_trait\]' packages/ciphernode/sortition/src echo "Searching for 'data' crate usage:" rg --type rust 'use data::' packages/ciphernode/sortition/src echo "Searching for 'serde' usage:" rg --type rust 'use serde' packages/ciphernode/sortition/srcLength of output: 897
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Further verify the usage of 'serde' in the sortition package # Test: Search for 'serde' in macros and other contexts echo "Searching for 'serde' derive macros:" rg --type rust '#\s*derive\s*\(\s*Serialize\s*,\s*Deserialize\s*\)' packages/ciphernode/sortition/src echo "Searching for 'serde' attribute usages:" rg --type rust 'serde::' packages/ciphernode/sortition/src echo "Searching for 'serde' in Cargo.toml dependencies comments or configurations:" rg --type toml 'serde' packages/ciphernode/sortition/Cargo.tomlLength of output: 710
packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (2)
15-15: Verify all references toDataare updated toInMemDataStoreSince
Datahas been renamed toInMemDataStore, it's important to ensure that all references toDataelsewhere in the codebase have been updated to prevent compile-time errors.Run the following script to find any remaining references to
Data:✅ Verification successful
All references to
Datahave been successfully updated toInMemDataStore. The only remaining occurrence is within a comment, which does not affect the codebase.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Find references to the old `Data` struct. # Test: Search for `Data` in Rust files. Expect: No occurrences related to the old struct. rg --type rust -w 'Data'Length of output: 188
15-18:⚠️ Potential issueUpdate the outdated comment to reflect
BTreeMapusageThe comment in the
handlemethod mentions inserting data intosled, but the code now usesBTreeMap. This may cause confusion for future maintainers.Apply this diff to correct the comment:
fn handle(&mut self, event: Insert, _: &mut Self::Context) { - // insert data into sled + // insert data into the BTreeMap self.db.insert(event.key(), event.value());Likely invalid or redundant comment.
packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (4)
Line range hint
24-35: Verify the impact of changingdatafromAddr<Data>toDataStoreChanging the type of
datafromAddr<Data>toDataStorein theMainCiphernodestruct and its constructor may affect how data is shared and accessed across actors. Ensure that:
- The
DataStoreprovides the necessary concurrency and sharing capabilities required by the actors.- All interactions that previously relied on
Addr<Data>are updated accordingly to work withDataStore.- There are no unintended side effects on data accessibility or message passing between actors.
61-61: Ensure correct initialization ofDataStoreThe data store is initialized with:
let data = DataStore::from_in_mem(InMemDataStore::new(true).start());Verify that:
- The
start()method returns the expected type compatible withDataStore::from_in_mem().- The in-memory data store initialization aligns with the rest of the application's data management strategy.
- Any asynchronous operations are correctly handled and awaited where necessary.
62-62: Confirm the updatedSortition::attachmethod signatureThe
attachmethod forSortitionnow includesdata.clone()as an argument:let sortition = Sortition::attach(bus.clone(), data.clone());Ensure that:
- The
Sortitionactor'sattachmethod is updated to accept theDataStoreparameter.- All other calls to
Sortition::attachare updated to match the new signature.- The
datais utilized appropriately within theSortitionactor without introducing any side effects.
82-86: Verify transition fromadd_hooktoadd_featureThe builder pattern now uses
add_featureinstead ofadd_hook:.add_feature(FheFeature::create(rng)) .add_feature(KeyshareFeature::create(bus.clone(), &address.to_string()))Ensure that:
- The
E3RequestRouteris correctly updated to use features instead of hooks.- All features conform to the expected interfaces and integrate seamlessly.
- The change does not break existing functionality dependent on the previous hook system.
packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/aggregator.rs (4)
3-3: Added imports for data storage functionalityThe addition of
DataStoreandInMemDataStoreimports is appropriate for implementing data persistence.
12-12: Imported features for the router's feature-based architectureThe import of
FheFeature,PlaintextAggregatorFeature, andPublicKeyAggregatorFeaturealigns with the shift from a hook-based to a feature-based architecture in the router.
55-56: Initialized in-memory data store and attached to SortitionThe
DataStoreis correctly initialized with an in-memory store and started. Cloning thestorewhen passing it toSortition::attachis appropriate to ensure that both components have access.
86-97: UpdatedE3RequestRouterto utilize data store and featuresThe
E3RequestRouterbuilder now accepts thestore, and features are added using theadd_featuremethod. The featuresFheFeature,PublicKeyAggregatorFeature, andPlaintextAggregatorFeatureare properly created with the necessary cloned resources. The asynchronous build and await pattern is correctly implemented.packages/ciphernode/keyshare/src/keyshare.rs (1)
69-76: Ensure Secure Management of Secret During DeserializationWhen reconstructing the
Keysharefrom a snapshot infrom_snapshot, thesecretis assigned directly from the deserialized state. Validate that the deserialization process securely handles thesecretto prevent potential security risks such as unauthorized access or tampering.packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (9)
5-6: Necessary imports for new traits and functionalityThe added imports are appropriate and required for implementing
async_traitand the traitsSnapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpoint.
27-30: Definition ofSortitionModulewith serialization capabilitiesThe
SortitionModulestruct is correctly defined withClone,Serialize, andDeserializederived traits, enabling cloning and serialization which are essential for state management and persistence.
87-87: Addition ofstore: DataStorefield toSortitionstructIncluding the
storefield allowsSortitionto interact with theDataStorefor state persistence. This aligns with the goal of enhancing data persistence capabilities.
90-93: Introduction ofSortitionParamsstruct for cleaner initializationThe
SortitionParamsstruct encapsulates initialization parameters, promoting cleaner code and easier extensibility for future parameters.
96-100: Refactorednewmethod to acceptSortitionParamsUpdating the
newmethod to acceptSortitionParamsenhances constructor clarity and parameter management. The initialization ofbusandstorefromparamsis correctly implemented.
104-109: Updatedattachmethod to includeDataStoreThe
attachmethod now accepts aDataStore, which is essential for state persistence. Ensure that all calls toattachacross the codebase are updated to pass theDataStoreinstance.
123-128: ImplementedSnapshottrait forSortitionThe implementation of the
Snapshottrait correctly returns a clone of thelist, allowing the current state to be captured for persistence.
130-140: ImplementedFromSnapshotWithParamstrait forSortitionThe
from_snapshotmethod appropriately reconstructs aSortitioninstance from a snapshot and parameters. This facilitates restoring state, which is crucial for hydration.
142-146: ImplementedCheckpointtrait forSortitionThe
get_storemethod provides access to theDataStore, enabling checkpointing functionality. Verify that cloning theDataStoredoes not introduce unnecessary overhead or performance issues.packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/plaintext_aggregator.rs (6)
14-14: ImplementedSerializeandDeserializefor state enumDeriving
serde::Serializeandserde::DeserializeforPlaintextAggregatorStateenables serialization of the aggregator's state, which is essential for snapshotting and state restoration.
32-41: Addedinitmethod toPlaintextAggregatorStateThe
initmethod provides a clear and concise way to initialize theCollectingstate with the necessary parameters.
53-53: Introducedstorefield toPlaintextAggregatorAdding
store: DataStoreallows the aggregator to persist its state, aligning with the implementation of theCheckpointtrait.
60-68: CreatedPlaintextAggregatorParamsstructEncapsulating constructor parameters into
PlaintextAggregatorParamsenhances code readability and makes parameter management more efficient.
70-78: Refactorednewmethod to accept params structUpdating the constructor to accept
PlaintextAggregatorParamsandPlaintextAggregatorStatesimplifies the instantiation process and improves maintainability.
221-242: Implemented snapshot and restoration traitsThe implementations of
Snapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointenable state saving and restoration, which are crucial for the hydration process described in the PR objectives.packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/publickey_aggregator.rs (6)
3-4: Adding necessary imports for trait implementationsThe added imports
async_trait::async_traitand traits fromdatamodule are required for implementingSnapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointtraits, enabling state serialization and deserialization.
13-13: DerivingSerializeandDeserializeforPublicKeyAggregatorStateBy deriving
serde::Serializeandserde::Deserialize, thePublicKeyAggregatorStateenum can be serialized and deserialized, facilitating state persistence and recovery.
56-56: AddingDataStoreto support checkpointingThe addition of the
store: DataStorefield toPublicKeyAggregatorenables state persistence through checkpointing, enhancing data reliability and recovery mechanisms.
63-70: IntroducingPublicKeyAggregatorParamsfor cleaner initializationThe new
PublicKeyAggregatorParamsstruct encapsulates initialization parameters, promoting cleaner code and better separation of concerns by grouping related configuration data.
79-87: Refactoringnewmethod to utilizeParamsandStateThe
newmethod now acceptsPublicKeyAggregatorParamsandPublicKeyAggregatorState, streamlining the initialization process and improving code maintainability by reducing parameter clutter.
245-267: Implementing state persistence traits forPublicKeyAggregatorThe implementations of
Snapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointenable thePublicKeyAggregatorto persist and restore its state, facilitating data hydration and enhancing fault tolerance.packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (2)
117-150: Handle missing dependencies inhydratemethodIn the
hydratemethod, if dependencies likefheormetaare missing, the method silently returnsOk(()). This could lead to issues if the caller expects the context to be fully hydrated.Consider logging a warning or error when essential dependencies are missing during hydration.
-let Some(fhe) = ctx.fhe.clone() else { - return Ok(()); +if let Some(fhe) = ctx.fhe.clone() { + // proceed with hydration +} else { + self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::Hydration, anyhow!("Missing FHE instance during hydration")); + return Ok(()); }
247-249: Ensure proper error handling in async methodsIn the
hydratemethods, ensure that all asynchronous operations are properly awaited and potential errors are handled.Run the following script to check for unhandled
awaiterrors:✅ Verification successful
All asynchronous operations are properly awaited with error handling.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Find instances where `await` may not be properly handling errors. # Test: Search for `await` without accompanying error handling. rg --type rust 'await\?\s*;' -A 2Length of output: 9877
packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (5)
1-1: LGTM!The import statement appears correct and necessary for the updated data storage mechanism.
11-12: LGTM!The added imports from the
routermodule are appropriate for integrating the new features.
46-58: LGTM: Feature additions to E3RequestRouter are properly structuredThe
E3RequestRouteris correctly configured using the builder pattern with the necessary features. This enhances modularity and maintainability.
85-87: Calls tosetup_local_ciphernodecorrectly handle the new return typeThe calls to
setup_local_ciphernodehave been updated to handle theResult<()>return type usingawait?, ensuring errors are properly propagated.
32-37: Verify function calls to reflect the updated return typeThe
setup_local_ciphernodefunction signature now returnsResult<()>. Please ensure that all calls to this function have been updated to handle theResult, usingawait?or appropriate error handling.Run the following script to verify the function usage:
✅ Verification successful
Further Verification Needed
The current script is capturing function definitions. Please run the following script to exclude function declarations and accurately identify calls to
setup_local_ciphernodethat do not handle theResultproperly:
Further Verification Required
To ensure all calls to
setup_local_ciphernodeproperly handle theResult, please run the following script which accounts for various formatting scenarios of.await?:
All calls to
setup_local_ciphernodeproperly handle theResult🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all calls to `setup_local_ciphernode` handle the `Result` properly. # Test: Search for calls to `setup_local_ciphernode` not followed by `.await?`, indicating missing error handling. rg --type rust 'setup_local_ciphernode\(' -A1 | rg -v '\.await\?'Length of output: 330
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all calls to `setup_local_ciphernode` handle the `Result` properly. # Exclude function declarations and search for calls without `.await?` rg --type rust 'setup_local_ciphernode\(' \ | rg -v 'fn setup_local_ciphernode' \ | rg -v '\.await\?'Length of output: 99
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Comprehensive verification of `setup_local_ciphernode` calls handling `Result`. # Search for calls to `setup_local_ciphernode` excluding its definition # Then, check if `.await?` follows, accounting for different formatting rg --type rust 'setup_local_ciphernode\(' \ | rg -v 'fn setup_local_ciphernode' \ | grep -P '(?!\.await\?).*setup_local_ciphernode\('Length of output: 578
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (5)
packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (3)
86-108: LGTM:Sortitionstruct updated for hydration support.The changes to the
Sortitionstruct and its initialization are well-implemented:
- Addition of
list: SortitionModuleandstore: DataStorefields supports hydration.- The new
SortitionParamsstruct allows for flexible initialization.- The
new()andattach()methods are correctly updated to useSortitionParams.These changes align well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence.
Consider adding documentation comments for the
SortitionParamsstruct to explain its purpose and usage.
130-140: LGTM: Correct implementation ofFromSnapshotWithParamstrait.The
FromSnapshotWithParamstrait implementation forSortitionis well-done:
- It correctly uses the provided snapshot and
SortitionParamsfor reconstruction.- The async implementation allows for potential future extensions with async operations.
- This implementation supports the hydration feature as required by the PR objectives.
Consider adding error handling for potential failure scenarios during reconstruction, such as invalid snapshot data.
193-195: Remove extra empty lines at the end of the file.There are three unnecessary empty lines at the end of the file. It's a best practice to have only one newline at the end of a file.
Remove the extra empty lines at the end of the file, leaving only one newline.
packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (2)
65-66: Update documentation forsnapshotmethodThe documentation for the
snapshotmethod mentions returning a tuple, but the method actually returnsSelf::Snapshot. Please update the comment to accurately reflect the method's behavior.Suggested correction:
- /// Return a tuple with the first element being the id string of the object and the second - /// being a representation of the object's state that is easily serialized by the data store + /// Returns a snapshot representing the object's state that is easily serialized by the data store
220-220: Fix typo in error messageThe error message in the
ensure_root_idmethod has a typo: "string doesnt start with slash." Please correct "doesnt" to "doesn't".Apply this diff to fix the typo:
- return Err(anyhow!("string doesnt start with slash.")); + return Err(anyhow!("string doesn't start with slash."));
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (5 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (7)
packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (6)
5-6: LGTM: New imports added for enhanced functionality.The new imports for
async_traitanddatamodule components are correctly added to support the new features implemented in this file.
Line range hint
27-40: LGTM: Well-designedSortitionModulestruct.The new
SortitionModulestruct is well-designed:
- It encapsulates the node list using a
HashSet<String>.- Correctly implements
Clone,Serialize, andDeserializefor data persistence.- Includes appropriate
new()anddefault()implementations.This addition enhances the modularity and maintainability of the code.
123-128: LGTM: Correct implementation ofSnapshottrait.The
Snapshottrait implementation forSortitionis correct and efficient:
- It returns a clone of
self.listas the snapshot.- This approach ensures that the snapshot is independent of the original data.
- The implementation supports the hydration feature as required by the PR objectives.
142-146: LGTM: Correct implementation ofCheckpointtrait.The
Checkpointtrait implementation forSortitionis correct:
- It returns a clone of
self.storeas required.- This approach ensures that the returned
DataStoreis independent of the original.- The implementation supports the data persistence feature as required by the PR objectives.
Line range hint
148-192: LGTM: Existing handler implementations remain correct.The existing handler implementations for
EnclaveEvent,CiphernodeAdded,CiphernodeRemoved,GetHasNode, andGetNodesremain unchanged. This is correct as they don't directly interact with the new hydration features. The handlers continue to provide the necessary functionality for managing the sortition list.
Line range hint
1-195: Overall: Well-implemented hydration and data persistence features.The changes in this file successfully implement hydration and data persistence for the
Sortitionmodule, aligning well with the PR objectives. Key improvements include:
- Addition of
SortitionModulefor better encapsulation of the node list.- Updates to the
Sortitionstruct to includeDataStoreand useSortitionParamsfor initialization.- Implementation of
Snapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointtraits to support hydration and data persistence.The code follows Rust best practices and maintains the existing functionality while adding new features. Minor suggestions for improvement include adding documentation for
SortitionParams, considering error handling inFromSnapshotWithParams, and removing extra empty lines at the end of the file.Great job on implementing these new features!
packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1)
1-250: Overall, the code changes look goodThe implementation provides flexible key management and supports serialization and snapshot capabilities effectively.
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 5
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (4)
packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (4)
Line range hint
27-31: LGTM:SortitionModuleenhances modularity.The new
SortitionModulestruct effectively encapsulates node storage and supports serialization, which is crucial for the snapshot functionality. This change improves modularity and separation of concerns.Consider adding a brief documentation comment explaining the purpose of this struct.
90-93: LGTM:SortitionParamsimproves constructor interface.The new
SortitionParamsstruct effectively encapsulates the dependencies required for creating aSortitioninstance. This change improves the constructor's interface and makes it more flexible for future extensions.Consider adding a brief documentation comment explaining the purpose of this struct and its fields.
130-140: LGTM:FromSnapshotWithParamstrait implementation added.The new
FromSnapshotWithParamstrait implementation forSortitionis well-structured and correctly usesSortitionParamsto provide the necessary dependencies. This implementation enables the reconstruction of aSortitioninstance from a snapshot, supporting the hydration functionality.Consider adding error handling for potential issues during reconstruction, such as invalid snapshot data.
142-146: LGTM:Checkpointtrait implementation added.The new
Checkpointtrait implementation forSortitioncorrectly provides access to theDataStoreinstance, supporting the hydration functionality. This allows other components to interact with the persistent storage associated with theSortitioninstance.Consider adding a brief documentation comment explaining the purpose of this trait implementation.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (4)
- packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/lib.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (4 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs (1)
Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs:43-43 Timestamp: 2024-10-16T09:51:10.038Z Learning: In `packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs`, avoid suggesting making the `on_event` method in `CommitteMetaFeature` asynchronous or adding error handling for the `write` operation to the data store.
🔇 Additional comments (12)
packages/ciphernode/aggregator/src/lib.rs (1)
3-8: Excellent improvement to module exports!The change from wildcard exports to explicit re-exports is a positive modification that aligns with Rust best practices. This approach offers several benefits:
- Improved clarity: It's now immediately clear which items are available for external use.
- Better control over the public API: You can easily manage which items are exposed.
- Enhanced maintainability: Changes to the public interface are more visible in version control.
This modification will make the codebase more maintainable and easier to understand for other developers working on the project.
packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (5)
5-6: LGTM: New imports support hydration implementation.The added imports from
async_traitanddatamodules are appropriate for implementing the hydration functionality, aligning with the PR objectives for data persistence.
86-88: LGTM:Sortitionstruct updated for data persistence.The addition of the
store: DataStorefield to theSortitionstruct is in line with the PR objectives for implementing hydration. This change enables theSortitioninstance to manage its own data persistence.
96-102: LGTM: Constructor and attach method updated correctly.The changes to
Sortition::newandSortition::attachmethods are consistent with the newSortitionstruct andSortitionParams. Theattachmethod now correctly initializes theSortitioninstance with bothEventBusandDataStore, aligning with the PR objectives for hydration implementation.Also applies to: 104-109
123-128: LGTM:Snapshottrait implementation added.The new
Snapshottrait implementation forSortitionis a crucial addition for supporting hydration functionality. It correctly uses theSortitionModuleas the snapshot representation, enabling efficient state serialization.
Line range hint
1-193: Overall: Excellent implementation of hydration for Sortition module.The changes in this file effectively implement hydration and data persistence for the Sortition module, aligning well with the PR objectives. Key improvements include:
- Introduction of
SortitionModulefor better encapsulation of node storage.- Addition of
DataStoreto theSortitionstruct for managing persistence.- Implementation of
Snapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointtraits to support state serialization and reconstruction.- Updated constructor and attach methods to accommodate the new persistence-related components.
These changes enhance the module's ability to manage and persist its state, improving overall system reliability and data management capabilities.
packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (2)
7-45: LGTM:IntoKeytrait and implementationsThe
IntoKeytrait and its implementations for various types (Vec<String>,Vec<&str>,String,&String, and&str) are well-defined and cover common use cases for keys in a key-value store. The use ofjoin("/")for vector types is a good choice for representing hierarchical keys.
1-248: Overall: Well-designed key-value store implementation with room for minor improvementsThe
data_store.rsfile implements a comprehensive and flexible key-value store with good abstractions and trait definitions. The code is well-structured and follows Rust best practices. Here's a summary of the strengths and areas for improvement:Strengths:
- Flexible key types with the
IntoKeytrait.- Good use of traits for defining behavior (
WithPrefix,Snapshot,Checkpoint).- Async traits for potential I/O operations (
FromSnapshotWithParams,FromSnapshot).- Clear separation of concerns between different components.
Areas for improvement:
- Error handling: Some methods could benefit from better error propagation and handling.
- Performance optimizations: Unnecessary cloning and inefficient string concatenations could be optimized.
- UTF-8 handling: Improve the handling of non-UTF-8 data in the
WithPrefiximplementation forVec<u8>.Consider addressing these minor issues to further improve the overall quality and robustness of the implementation.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/committee_meta.rs (4)
7-7: Serialization Traits Added toCommitteeMetaThe implementation correctly derives
serde::Serializeandserde::DeserializeforCommitteeMeta, enabling serialization which is essential for data persistence.
14-20: Implementation ofCommitteeMetaFeatureis CorrectThe
CommitteeMetaFeaturestruct and itscreatemethod are properly defined, facilitating the integration of the feature within the system.
23-45: Event Handling inon_eventMethod is AppropriateThe
on_eventmethod correctly handles theEnclaveEvent::E3Requestedevent. It extracts the necessary data and stores theCommitteeMetainformation as expected.
47-64: Hydration Logic inhydrateMethod is SoundThe asynchronous
hydratemethod appropriately restores theCommitteeMetafrom the snapshot if available, ensuring the state is maintained correctly across sessions.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 8
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (4)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/repository.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/repositories.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (2 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/repository.rs
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (1)
Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs:82-83 Timestamp: 2024-10-22T02:10:34.864Z Learning: In the file `packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs`, when reviewing test functions like `generate_pk_share`, minor performance optimizations (e.g., minimizing mutex locks) are not a priority.
🔇 Additional comments (4)
packages/ciphernode/router/src/repositories.rs (4)
1-11: LGTM: Imports and struct definition are appropriate.The imports cover all necessary modules and types for the implementation. The
Repositoriesstruct definition encapsulating aDataStorealigns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence.
26-30: LGTM:newmethod implementation is idiomatic.The
newmethod provides a clear and idiomatic way to create aRepositoriesinstance, consistent with Rust conventions and the PR objectives.
73-75: LGTM:RepositoriesFactorytrait is well-defined.The
RepositoriesFactorytrait provides a clear and standard interface for types that can produceRepositoriesinstances. This design allows for flexibility and potential future extensions, aligning with good software design practices.
77-81: LGTM:RepositoriesFactoryimplementation forDataStoreis efficient.The implementation leverages the
Fromtrait to provide a concise and efficient way to createRepositoriesfrom aDataStore. This approach is both idiomatic and consistent with the overall design.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 10
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (5)
packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (3)
Line range hint
4-14: LGTM! Consider future-proofing theDataOpenum.The new
GetLogmessage andDataOpenum are well-structured additions that support the logging feature. The import changes also improve modularity.Consider adding a
Getvariant to theDataOpenum to account for potential future logging of read operations:pub enum DataOp { Insert(Insert), Get(Get), }This change would make the logging more comprehensive and flexible for future requirements.
35-45: LGTM! Consider adding error handling for insertions.The
Handler<Insert>implementation correctly handles data insertion and conditional logging. The use ofto_vec()ensures proper data isolation.Consider adding error handling for potential failed insertions. For example:
impl Handler<Insert> for InMemStore { type Result = Result<(), std::io::Error>; fn handle(&mut self, event: Insert, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { match self.db.insert(event.key().to_vec(), event.value().to_vec()) { Some(_) | None => { if self.capture { self.log.push(DataOp::Insert(event)); } Ok(()) }, Err(e) => Err(std::io::Error::new(std::io::ErrorKind::Other, e.to_string())), } } }This change would provide more robust error handling and allow callers to react to insertion failures.
Line range hint
47-60: LGTM! Consider optimizingGetLogand adding error handling.Both
Handler<Get>andHandler<GetLog>implementations are functionally correct. TheGethandler efficiently retrieves and clones the value from the store.
- For
Handler<GetLog>, consider implementing pagination or returning a reference to avoid cloning the entire log, which could be inefficient for large logs:impl Handler<GetLog> for InMemStore { type Result = &[DataOp]; fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { &self.log } }
- Add error handling to both implementations:
impl Handler<Get> for InMemStore { type Result = Result<Option<Vec<u8>>, std::io::Error>; fn handle(&mut self, event: Get, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { Ok(self.db.get(event.key()).cloned()) } } impl Handler<GetLog> for InMemStore { type Result = Result<&[DataOp], std::io::Error>; fn handle(&mut self, _: GetLog, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { Ok(&self.log) } }These changes would improve efficiency and provide more robust error handling.
packages/ciphernode/data/src/sled_store.rs (2)
7-10: Add Documentation Comments toSledStoreStructConsider adding Rust documentation comments (
///) to theSledStorestruct to explain its purpose, usage, and any important details. This will improve code readability and help other developers understand its role within the system.
52-58: Remove UnnecessaryreturnStatementIn Rust, the last expression in a function is automatically returned. The explicit
returnstatement at line 52 is unnecessary and can be omitted for cleaner code.Apply this diff to simplify the code:
- return match res { + match res { Ok(value) => value.map(|v| v.to_vec()), Err(err) => { self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::Data, err); None } };
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
packages/ciphernode/Cargo.lockis excluded by!**/*.lock
📒 Files selected for processing (5)
- packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (3 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/sled_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml (1)
Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml:0-0 Timestamp: 2024-10-22T02:36:01.448Z Learning: In `packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml`, `actix-rt` is only used in tests and should remain in `[dev-dependencies]`.
🔇 Additional comments (8)
packages/ciphernode/data/Cargo.toml (2)
10-16: LGTM! The added dependencies align well with the PR objectives.The new dependencies (enclave-core, anyhow, serde, sled, bincode, tracing, async-trait) are well-suited for implementing hydration and data persistence as outlined in the PR objectives. They provide the necessary tools for error handling, serialization, database operations, tracing, and asynchronous programming. The use of workspace-level version management (
workspace = true) is a good practice for maintaining consistency across the project.
18-19: LGTM! The placement ofactix-rtin[dev-dependencies]is correct.The addition of
actix-rtas a development dependency is appropriate. As per the previous discussion and the learning from @ryardley,actix-rtis only used in tests and should remain in[dev-dependencies]. This placement ensures that it's available for testing purposes without unnecessarily including it in production builds.packages/ciphernode/data/src/in_mem.rs (3)
15-19: LGTM! Improved struct naming and added logging support.The renaming of
DatatoInMemStoreis more descriptive and the addition oflogandcapturefields effectively supports the new logging feature. The use ofBTreeMapfordbis appropriate for an ordered key-value store.
21-23: LGTM! CorrectActorimplementation.The
Actortrait implementation forInMemStoreis correct and allows it to be used within the Actix actor system.
Line range hint
25-33: LGTM! Well-implemented constructor.The
newmethod forInMemStoreis well-implemented. It correctly initializes all fields and provides flexibility for logging behavior through thecaptureparameter.packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (3)
1-35: LGTM: Imports and message structs are well-definedThe imports are appropriate, and the
InsertandGetstructs are correctly implemented as message types. The methods returning references instead of cloned values are an efficient design choice.
37-43: LGTM: DataStore struct is well-definedThe
DataStorestruct is correctly defined with appropriate fields for scope and message recipients, following Actix patterns for actor communication.
47-56: LGTM: DataStore::read method is well-implementedThe
readmethod is correctly implemented as an asynchronous function. It properly handles the retrieval and deserialization of data, with appropriate error handling.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 5
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (19)
packages/ciphernode/router/src/ciphernode_selector.rs (3)
19-22: LGTM: Method signature updated correctly.The
newmethod has been appropriately updated to accept references and perform cloning within the method. This change improves flexibility and is consistent with updates in other files.Consider using the
to_owned()method foraddressin line 23 for consistency:- address: address.to_owned(), + address: address.to_string(),
38-46: LGTM: Event handling simplified and expanded.The
Handler<EnclaveEvent>implementation has been updated to handle bothE3RequestedandShutdownmessages, simplifying the event handling process. This change aligns well with the overall shift towards more straightforward event handling in the PR.Consider using a more specific pattern match to avoid the catch-all case:
match msg { EnclaveEvent::E3Requested { data, .. } => ctx.notify(data), EnclaveEvent::Shutdown { data, .. } => ctx.notify(data), - _ => (), }This change would make the code more robust against future additions to the
EnclaveEventenum.
Line range hint
48-80: LGTM: E3Requested handling simplified.The
Handler<E3Requested>implementation has been updated to directly handle theE3Requestedtype, simplifying the logic and improving efficiency. This change aligns well with the overall improvements in event handling across the PR.Consider using
tracing::info!instead ofinfo!for consistency with the shutdown handler:- info!(node = address, "Ciphernode was not selected"); + tracing::info!(node = address, "Ciphernode was not selected");packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (2)
57-58: LGTM: Updated method signature with improved flexibilityThe changes to the
attachmethod signature are appropriate:
- The new
data_locationparameter allows for flexible data store initialization.- Returning
Addr<EventBus>instead ofAddr<Self>seems more suitable for the current architecture.These changes align well with the new data management approach and overall architectural changes.
Consider adding a comment explaining the significance of the
data_locationparameter and its impact on the data store initialization.
64-70: LGTM: Flexible data store initializationThe new data store initialization logic is well-implemented:
- It allows for either
SledStoreorInMemStorebased on thedata_location.- The
repositoriesabstraction provides a clean interface for data access.Consider adding error handling for the case where
SledStore::new()fails. You might want to provide a fallback toInMemStoreor propagate a more informative error message.packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/aggregator.rs (4)
35-35: LGTM: Improved memory management forEventBus.The change to pass
busas a reference and clone it inside the struct improves memory management by allowing the caller to retain ownership of theEventBus. This is consistent with the PR objectives of enhancing the overall architecture.Consider using
bus.clone()directly in the struct initialization to avoid an extra variable:Self { e3_manager, bus: bus.clone(), sortition, p2p, }Also applies to: 42-42
52-53: LGTM: Signature changes enhance flexibility and align with architecture.The addition of the
data_locationparameter and the change in return type toAddr<EventBus>align well with the PR objectives of implementing hydration and centralizing communication through theEventBus.Consider adding documentation for the
data_locationparameter to clarify its purpose and expected values.
59-65: LGTM: Data store implementation aligns with hydration objectives.The implementation of
DataStorecreation based on thedata_locationparameter directly addresses the PR objectives of implementing hydration for data persistence. The use ofSledStorefor persistent storage andInMemStorefor in-memory storage provides flexibility, and creating repositories from the store aligns with the goal of simplifying the API and enhancing type safety.Consider adding error handling for the case where
SledStore::new()fails:let store: DataStore = match data_location { Some(loc) => match SledStore::new(&bus, loc) { Ok(sled_store) => (&sled_store.start()).into(), Err(e) => return Err(anyhow::anyhow!("Failed to create SledStore: {}", e)), }, None => (&InMemStore::new(true).start()).into(), };
80-85: LGTM: Feature-based architecture and consistent bus handling.The shift to a feature-based architecture in
E3RequestRouteraligns well with the PR objectives and improves modularity. The consistent use of passing a reference tobusinMainAggregator::new()improves memory management.For consistency, consider updating the
E3RequestRouter::buildercall to use a reference tobus:let e3_manager = E3RequestRouter::builder(&bus, store) .add_feature(FheFeature::create(&bus, &rng)) .add_feature(PublicKeyAggregatorFeature::create(&bus, &sortition)) .add_feature(PlaintextAggregatorFeature::create(&bus, &sortition)) .build() .await?;Also applies to: 100-101
packages/ciphernode/evm/src/ciphernode_registry_sol.rs (2)
Line range hint
65-93: LGTM:extractorfunction improvementsThe changes to the
extractorfunction are good:
- Making it public allows for better modularity.
- Returning
Noneon errors instead of panicking is a more graceful approach.Consider using
tracing::warn!instead oferror!for parsing issues, as they might not always indicate a critical problem.
98-105: LGTM: UpdatedCiphernodeRegistrySolReader::attachmethodThe changes to the
attachmethod are well-aligned with the new event handling approach:
- Taking a reference to
Addr<EventBus>is more flexible.- Returning
Addr<EvmEventReader>is consistent with the new implementation.- Using
EvmEventReader::attachsimplifies the code.Consider adding a brief comment explaining the purpose of this method, as it now acts more like a factory for
EvmEventReader.packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol_writer.rs (1)
35-43: LGTM: Improved memory efficiency and added RPC URL validation.The changes to the
newmethod are good:
- Using references for
busandsignerimproves memory efficiency.- Adding
ensure_http_rpcenhances input validation.- Cloning
busallows for multiple ownership, which is often necessary in the actor model.Minor suggestion: Consider using
bus: bus.clone()instead ofbus: bus.clone(),to be consistent with the no-trailing-comma style used elsewhere in the struct initialization.packages/ciphernode/evm/src/helpers.rs (3)
122-122: Improved thread safety with ArcThe change to use
&Arc<PrivateKeySigner>for thesignerparameter is a good improvement for thread safety and memory management. This aligns well with best practices for shared ownership in concurrent scenarios.Consider adding a brief comment explaining the rationale behind using
Archere, as it might not be immediately obvious to all developers why this change was made.Also applies to: 130-130
141-148: Approved: ensure_http_rpc functionThe
ensure_http_rpcfunction effectively converts WebSocket URLs to HTTP URLs, which aligns with the PR objectives. It correctly handles both "ws://" and "wss://" protocols.Consider using a match statement for slightly more concise and idiomatic Rust code:
pub fn ensure_http_rpc(rpc_url: &str) -> String { match rpc_url { url if url.starts_with("ws://") => url.replacen("ws://", "http://", 1), url if url.starts_with("wss://") => url.replacen("wss://", "https://", 1), _ => rpc_url.to_string(), } }This suggestion maintains the same functionality while potentially improving readability.
159-177: Approved: Comprehensive test coverage for URL conversion functionsThe new test module provides excellent coverage for both
ensure_http_rpcandensure_ws_rpcfunctions. All possible scenarios are tested, which is crucial for ensuring the reliability of these utility functions.To further enhance the tests, consider adding a negative test case for each function. For example:
#[test] fn test_ensure_http_rpc_with_invalid_input() { assert_eq!(ensure_http_rpc("invalid://foo.com"), "invalid://foo.com"); } #[test] fn test_ensure_ws_rpc_with_invalid_input() { assert_eq!(ensure_ws_rpc("invalid://foo.com"), "invalid://foo.com"); }These additional tests would confirm that the functions handle unexpected inputs gracefully.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (1)
176-199: Good implementation of snapshot and checkpoint functionalityThe addition of
E3RequestRouterSnapshotand the implementations ofSnapshotandCheckpointtraits forE3RequestRouterare well-done. These changes enable state persistence and recovery, which are crucial for system reliability.Consider using
iter().cloned().collect()instead ofkeys().cloned().collect()for slightly better performance:-let contexts = self.contexts.keys().cloned().collect(); +let contexts = self.contexts.iter().map(|(k, _)| k.clone()).collect();packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (2)
17-17: Consider using a more specific import for AddressInstead of importing the entire
alloy::primitivesmodule, consider importingAddressdirectly for better clarity.-use alloy::{primitives::Address, signers::k256::sha2::digest::Reset}; +use alloy::primitives::Address; +use alloy::signers::k256::sha2::digest::Reset;
180-185: Consider adding a check for total < lenThe
pad_endfunction could potentially panic iftotalis less thaninput.len(). Consider adding a check to handle this case.fn pad_end(input: &[u64], pad: u64, total: usize) -> Vec<u64> { let len = input.len(); + if total < len { + return input[..total].to_vec(); + } let mut cop = input.to_vec(); cop.extend(std::iter::repeat(pad).take(total - len)); cop }packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (1)
17-17: Reminder to address the TODO commentThere's a TODO comment on line 17 indicating:
/// TODO: move these to each package with access on MyStruct::launcher()Consider implementing this change to improve code organization and maintainability by placing each feature in its respective package.
Would you like assistance in creating a plan to refactor these features or opening a GitHub issue to track this task?
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (15)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/aggregator.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/ciphernode_registry_sol.rs (3 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol_reader.rs (3 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol_writer.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/event_reader.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/helpers.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/registry_filter_sol.rs (6 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/ciphernode_selector.rs (3 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (5 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (4 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (2 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/registry_filter_sol.rs
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (3)
Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs:82-83 Timestamp: 2024-10-22T02:10:34.864Z Learning: In the file `packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs`, when reviewing test functions like `generate_pk_share`, minor performance optimizations (e.g., minimizing mutex locks) are not a priority.Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#133 File: packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs:137-139 Timestamp: 2024-10-08T19:45:18.209Z Learning: In `packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs`, using the same RNG instance `rng_test` for generating multiple key shares without advancing its state is acceptable.Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#133 File: packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs:137-139 Timestamp: 2024-10-03T23:02:41.732Z Learning: In `packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs`, using the same RNG instance `rng_test` for generating multiple key shares without advancing its state is acceptable.
🔇 Additional comments (71)
packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol.rs (1)
12-19: Approve changes toattachmethod signature and implementation.The updates to the
attachmethod, including the use of references forbusandsignerparameters, are improvements that can lead to better memory management and reduced cloning. These changes align with the broader updates mentioned in the PR objectives and AI summary.To ensure consistency across the codebase, let's verify similar changes in related files:
This script will help verify that similar changes have been made consistently across related files and identify any remaining instances that might need updating.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/ciphernode_selector.rs (3)
4-4: LGTM: Import statement updated correctly.The import statement has been appropriately updated to include
E3RequestedandShutdown, which aligns with the new event types introduced in this PR.
27-31: LGTM: Method updated correctly with new subscription.The
attachmethod has been appropriately updated to accept references, maintaining consistency with thenewmethod. The addition of the "Shutdown" subscription aligns well with the new shutdown handling capability introduced in this PR.
82-88: LGTM: Shutdown handling added.The new
Handler<Shutdown>implementation adds proper shutdown handling to theCiphernodeSelectoractor. This addition improves the actor's lifecycle management and aligns with the introduction of theShutdownevent across various components in the PR.packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol_reader.rs (3)
1-7: LGTM: Import changes reflect architectural shiftThe changes in imports, particularly the addition of
EvmEventReaderand removal ofReadonlyProvider, indicate a shift in the event reading mechanism. This aligns with the broader changes in the module's architecture.
52-52: LGTM:extractorfunction made publicThe
extractorfunction has been made public, allowing for external access. This change aligns with the new architecture and maintains the existing logic for event extraction.
80-80: Consider further simplification ofEnclaveSolReaderThe
EnclaveSolReaderstruct is now empty, suggesting it's used as a namespace for associated functions. This aligns with the removal of the actor implementation.As previously suggested, re-evaluate the necessity of the
EnclaveSolReaderstruct. Consider whether it can be replaced with a module or removed entirely if it's no longer providing value beyond grouping functions.packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/ciphernode.rs (5)
4-4: LGTM: Import changes align with new architectureThe new imports for
DataStore,InMemStore,SledStore,FheFeature,KeyshareFeature, andRepositoriesFactoryare consistent with the transition to a feature-based architecture and the introduction ofDataStorefor data management.Also applies to: 11-13
26-26: LGTM: Updated data field typeThe change from
Addr<Data>toDataStorefor thedatafield is consistent with the new data management approach usingDataStore.
37-37: LGTM: Updated constructor parameter typeThe change of the
dataparameter type fromAddr<Data>toDataStorein thenewmethod is consistent with the struct field change and supports the new data management approach.
97-107: LGTM: Updated MainCiphernode initializationThe changes in the
MainCiphernode::newcall are consistent with the updates to the method signature and the overall architectural changes:
- The order and number of parameters have been adjusted correctly.
- The use of
storeinstead ofdataaligns with the transition toDataStore.These changes ensure that the
MainCiphernodeis initialized correctly with the new data management approach.
86-90: LGTM: Improved E3RequestRouter initialization with feature-based architectureThe new initialization of
E3RequestRouterusing a builder pattern with feature additions is a significant improvement:
- It allows for more flexible and modular configuration.
- The use of
FheFeatureandKeyshareFeaturealigns well with the new feature-based architecture.Ensure that any errors arising from the asynchronous
.build().await?are properly propagated and handled. Consider adding specific error handling for this asynchronous operation.packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/aggregator.rs (1)
3-3: LGTM: Import changes align with PR objectives.The new imports for
DataStore,InMemStore, andSledStore, as well as the updated imports from theroutermodule, align well with the PR objectives of implementing hydration for data persistence and shifting towards a feature-based architecture.Also applies to: 12-15
packages/ciphernode/evm/src/ciphernode_registry_sol.rs (2)
1-1: LGTM: Import ofEvmEventReaderaddedThe addition of the
EvmEventReaderimport aligns with the changes in theattachmethod, which now returnsAddr<EvmEventReader>.
95-96: LGTM: SimplifiedCiphernodeRegistrySolReaderstructThe simplification of
CiphernodeRegistrySolReaderto a unit struct is appropriate given the removal of its fields andnewmethod. This change addresses the previous suggestion to refactor this struct since it no longer contains any fields.packages/ciphernode/data/src/data_store.rs (4)
1-7: LGTM: Imports are appropriate and concise.The imports cover all necessary dependencies for the implemented functionality, including error handling, serialization, and actor-based communication.
9-24: LGTM:Insertstruct is well-implemented.The
Insertstruct is correctly implemented with appropriate trait derivations. Thenew()method uses theIntoKeytrait for flexible key types, and thekey()andvalue()methods efficiently return references to avoid unnecessary cloning.
26-37: LGTM:Getstruct is well-implemented.The
Getstruct is correctly implemented with appropriate trait derivations. Thenew()method uses theIntoKeytrait for flexible key types, and thekey()method efficiently returns a reference to avoid unnecessary cloning.
1-137: Overall, the implementation is well-structured and efficient, with some room for improvement.The
data_store.rsfile implements a robust key-value data store using Actix for message handling. The code makes good use of Rust's type system and the actor model. Here are the main points:
- The
InsertandGetmessage types are well-implemented with appropriate trait derivations and efficient methods.- The
DataStorestruct provides a comprehensive interface for interacting with the data store.- There are a few areas where performance could be improved, particularly in the
scopeandget_scopemethods.- Error handling in the
writemethod could be more explicit to allow callers to handle errors.- There's some code duplication in the
Fromimplementations that could be reduced using a macro.Addressing these points would further enhance the quality and maintainability of the code.
packages/ciphernode/evm/src/enclave_sol_writer.rs (5)
4-4: LGTM: Import for RPC URL validation added.The addition of
ensure_http_rpcimport is a good practice for validating the RPC URL before use.
15-15: LGTM: Import for Shutdown message added.The addition of the
Shutdownimport aligns with the PR objective of implementing graceful termination.
48-60: LGTM: Improved method signature and added Shutdown event subscription.The changes to the
attachmethod are good:
- Using references in the method signature is consistent with the
newmethod changes.- Adding a subscription to the "Shutdown" event aligns with the PR objectives for implementing graceful termination.
80-80: Consider simplifying the Shutdown event handling.The addition of the
EnclaveEvent::Shutdownmatch arm is good for implementing graceful termination. However, as suggested in a previous review comment, consider simplifying this to directly callctx.stop()instead of notifying self with the data.
111-116: LGTM: Shutdown handler implemented.The addition of the
Handler<Shutdown>implementation forEnclaveSolWriteris good:
- It properly implements the shutdown logic by stopping the actor's context.
- This is consistent with the PR objectives for implementing graceful termination.
- The implementation is simple and straightforward.
packages/ciphernode/sortition/src/sortition.rs (9)
5-6: LGTM: New imports for async traits and data management.The added imports for
async_traitanddataare appropriate for implementing hydration and data persistence features as outlined in the PR objectives.
Line range hint
27-88: LGTM: NewSortitionModulestruct and updatedSortitionstruct.The introduction of
SortitionModuleand the updates toSortitionimprove modularity and align with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence. TheSortitionList<String>implementation ensures that core node management functionality is maintained.
89-92: LGTM: NewSortitionParamsstruct.The
SortitionParamsstruct effectively encapsulates the parameters needed for creating aSortitioninstance, including theRepository<SortitionModule>for data persistence. This aligns well with the PR objectives.
96-100: LGTM: UpdatedSortition::newmethod.The
newmethod now acceptsSortitionParams, allowing for proper dependency injection of both the event bus and the data store. This change aligns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence.
104-109: LGTM: UpdatedSortition::attachmethod.The
attachmethod now properly initializes aSortitioninstance with both the event bus and data store. This change aligns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence.
123-128: LGTM: NewSnapshottrait implementation forSortition.The
Snapshottrait implementation forSortitionallows for creating a snapshot of theSortitionstate. This aligns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence.
130-140: LGTM: NewFromSnapshotWithParamstrait implementation forSortition.The
FromSnapshotWithParamstrait implementation forSortitionenables the reconstruction ofSortitionstate from a snapshot and parameters. This aligns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence. The use ofasync_traitis appropriate for handling potential asynchronous operations during reconstruction.
142-146: LGTM: NewCheckpointtrait implementation forSortition.The
Checkpointtrait implementation forSortitionallows for retrieving theRepository<SortitionModule>fromSortition. This aligns well with the PR objectives for implementing hydration and data persistence, providing a way to access the underlying data store.
Line range hint
1-147: Overall: Excellent implementation of hydration and data persistence forSortition.The changes in this file successfully implement hydration and data persistence for the
Sortitionmodule, aligning well with the PR objectives. The introduction ofSortitionModule,SortitionParams, and the implementations ofSnapshot,FromSnapshotWithParams, andCheckpointtraits provide a robust framework for state management and serialization.These changes are consistent with the broader restructuring effort across multiple files in the PR, as mentioned in the AI-generated summary. The new structure enhances the module's ability to manage and retain its state, supporting the goals of improved data persistence capabilities.
Great job on implementing these features while maintaining the core functionality of the
Sortitionmodule!packages/ciphernode/evm/src/helpers.rs (3)
18-18: Excellent implementation of graceful shutdown mechanismThe changes to the
stream_from_evmfunction effectively implement a graceful shutdown mechanism. The use of theselect!macro allows for concurrent handling of incoming logs and the shutdown signal, which aligns well with the PR objective of cleaning up on SIGTERM (issue #149). This improvement enhances the robustness of the streaming process.Also applies to: 26-26, 36-57, 63-64
150-157: Approved: ensure_ws_rpc functionThe
ensure_ws_rpcfunction effectively converts HTTP URLs to WebSocket URLs, complementing theensure_http_rpcfunction. It correctly handles both "http://" and "https://" protocols.As suggested for the
ensure_http_rpcfunction, consider using a match statement here as well for consistency and potentially improved readability.
Line range hint
1-177: Overall: Excellent improvements to EVM helpersThe changes in this file significantly enhance the functionality and robustness of the EVM helpers. Key improvements include:
- Implementation of a graceful shutdown mechanism in
stream_from_evm.- Enhanced thread safety in
create_provider_with_signer.- Addition of URL protocol conversion functions
ensure_http_rpcandensure_ws_rpc.- Comprehensive test coverage for the new functions.
These changes align well with the PR objectives, particularly addressing the cleanup on SIGTERM (issue #149) and improving overall code quality. The minor suggestions provided in the review comments could further refine the implementation.
Great work on these improvements!
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (6)
Line range hint
1-53: Excellent architectural improvements!The transition to a feature-based architecture with the introduction of the
E3Featuretrait is a significant improvement. This design choice enhances modularity, extensibility, and maintainability of the codebase. The use of the#[async_trait]attribute for thehydratemethod is correct and allows for asynchronous operations in trait methods.
Line range hint
110-163: Improved event handling with feature-based systemThe new implementation of
Handler<EnclaveEvent>forE3RequestRouterprovides better separation of concerns by delegating event handling to features. The early check for the shutdown event is a good practice for graceful termination.However, there's a potential performance issue:
[performance]
Consider optimizing the feature iteration to avoid cloningself.featuresin each event handling:-for feature in self.features.clone().iter() { +for feature in self.features.iter() { feature.on_event(context, &msg); }
166-174: Improve error handling in shutdown processThe
Handler<Shutdown>implementation ensures that all contexts are notified of the shutdown event, which is good for graceful termination. However, there's room for improvement in error handling.
[error_handling]
Consider adding error handling for theforward_message_nowcalls:for (_, ctx) in self.contexts.iter() { - ctx.forward_message_now(&shutdown_evt) + if let Err(e) = ctx.forward_message_now(&shutdown_evt) { + log::error!("Failed to forward shutdown event: {:?}", e); + // Consider additional error handling or recovery steps + } }
201-235: Enhance error handling infrom_snapshotmethodThe
FromSnapshotWithParamsimplementation forE3RequestRouteris a crucial addition for state recovery. However, the current implementation silently ignores errors during context restoration, which could lead to incomplete state recovery without proper notification.
[error_handling]
Consider collecting and logging errors during context restoration:+let mut restoration_errors = Vec::new(); for e3_id in snapshot.contexts { let Some(ctx_snapshot) = repositories.context(&e3_id).read().await? else { + restoration_errors.push(format!("Missing snapshot for context {}", e3_id)); continue; }; - contexts.insert( - e3_id.clone(), - E3RequestContext::from_snapshot( - E3RequestContextParams { - store: repositories.context(&e3_id), - e3_id: e3_id.clone(), - features: params.features.clone(), - }, - ctx_snapshot, - ) - .await?, - ); + match E3RequestContext::from_snapshot( + E3RequestContextParams { + store: repositories.context(&e3_id), + e3_id: e3_id.clone(), + features: params.features.clone(), + }, + ctx_snapshot, + ).await { + Ok(context) => { contexts.insert(e3_id.clone(), context); } + Err(e) => restoration_errors.push(format!("Failed to restore context {}: {:?}", e3_id, e)), + } } +if !restoration_errors.is_empty() { + log::warn!("Errors during context restoration: {:?}", restoration_errors); +}
237-272: ImprovedE3RequestRouterBuilderwith snapshot supportThe updates to
E3RequestRouterBuilderalign well with the new feature-based and snapshot-aware architecture. The default addition ofCommitteeMetaFeatureensures that all routers have this essential feature.[error_handling]
Consider adding error handling for feature addition:-pub fn add_feature(mut self, listener: Box<dyn E3Feature>) -> Self { - self.features.push(listener); - self +pub fn add_feature(mut self, listener: Box<dyn E3Feature>) -> Result<Self> { + // Perform any necessary validation on the feature + if /* feature is valid */ { + self.features.push(listener); + Ok(self) + } else { + Err(anyhow!("Invalid feature")) + } }This change would allow for validation of features before they're added and provide better error handling.
60-100: Great improvements toE3RequestRouterstructure and initialization!The updated
E3RequestRouterstruct and the introduction ofE3RequestRouterParamsenhance flexibility and separation of concerns. The use ofArc<Vec<Box<dyn E3Feature>>>is an efficient way to share features across contexts.Consider adding error handling in the
from_paramsmethod:packages/ciphernode/tests/tests/test_aggregation_and_decryption.rs (22)
1-12: LGTM: Updated imports and type definitionsThe new imports and type definitions align well with the changes in the test file. They reflect the addition of new features and components, such as
DataStore,InMemStore, and various router features.
20-21: LGTM: Updated FHE importsThe imports for FHE-related types and traits have been updated to include necessary components for the tests.
32-38: LGTM: New LocalCiphernodeTuple type definitionThe
LocalCiphernodeTupletype definition provides a clear structure for the return value of thesetup_local_ciphernodefunction.
40-65: LGTM: Updated setup_local_ciphernode functionThe
setup_local_ciphernodefunction has been updated to include the newDataStoreand router features. The changes align well with the new architecture and provide a good setup for the tests.
69-73: LGTM: Updated generate_pk_share functionThe
generate_pk_sharefunction has been updated to include theaddrparameter and return aResult<PkSkShareTuple>. This change aligns with the new requirements and improves error handling.Also applies to: 76-76
79-90: LGTM: New generate_pk_shares functionThe
generate_pk_sharesfunction is a helpful addition that generates multiple public key shares. It's well-implemented and uses thegenerate_pk_sharefunction effectively.
92-96: LGTM: New create_random_eth_addrs functionThe
create_random_eth_addrsfunction is a useful helper for generating random Ethereum addresses for testing purposes.
98-104: LGTM: New RNG and seed creation functionsThe
create_shared_rng_from_u64andcreate_seed_from_u64functions provide consistent ways to create RNGs and seeds for testing, which is good for reproducibility.
106-123: LGTM: New create_crp_bytes_params functionThe
create_crp_bytes_paramsfunction encapsulates the creation of CRP bytes and parameters, which is useful for setting up the test environment.
125-151: LGTM: New AddToCommittee struct and implementationThe
AddToCommitteestruct and its implementation provide a clean way to add addresses to the committee and create corresponding events. This is a good abstraction for the test setup.
153-166: LGTM: New create_local_ciphernodes functionThe
create_local_ciphernodesfunction is a helpful addition for setting up multiple local ciphernodes in the test environment.
168-178: LGTM: New encrypt_ciphertext functionThe
encrypt_ciphertextfunction encapsulates the encryption logic and returns both the ciphertext and the expected serialized output, which is useful for testing.
187-195: LGTM: New add_ciphernodes functionThe
add_ciphernodesfunction is a useful helper for adding multiple ciphernodes to the test environment and generating the corresponding events.
197-200: LGTM: New type aliasesThe
PkSkShareTupleandDecryptionShareTupletype aliases improve code readability.
201-207: LGTM: New aggregate_public_key functionThe
aggregate_public_keyfunction provides a clean way to aggregate public keys from the shares.
209-223: LGTM: New to_decryption_shares functionThe
to_decryption_sharesfunction is well-implemented and provides a way to generate decryption shares from the public key shares.
225-236: LGTM: New to_keyshare_events functionThe
to_keyshare_eventsfunction is a helpful utility for creating keyshare events from the generated shares.
238-251: LGTM: New to_decryptionshare_events functionThe
to_decryptionshare_eventsfunction is well-implemented and provides a way to create decryption share events from the decryption shares.
253-269: LGTM: New get_common_setup functionThe
get_common_setupfunction encapsulates the common setup logic for the tests, which is good for reducing code duplication and improving maintainability.
271-375: LGTM: Updated test_public_key_aggregation_and_decryption testThe
test_public_key_aggregation_and_decryptiontest has been significantly updated to use the new helper functions and test the updated functionality. The test covers the key aspects of public key aggregation and decryption.
377-452: LGTM: New test_stopped_keyshares_retain_state testThe
test_stopped_keyshares_retain_statetest is a valuable addition that verifies the persistence of keyshare state after a shutdown event. This test helps ensure the robustness of the system in handling state persistence.
Line range hint
1-452: Overall: Well-structured and comprehensive test suiteThe updates to this test file are thorough and well-implemented. They cover the new features and components introduced in the system, such as the DataStore, router features, and improved event handling. The new helper functions and type definitions improve code readability and reduce duplication. The tests provide good coverage for the public key aggregation, decryption, and state persistence functionality.
Some minor suggestions for improvement:
- Consider adding more detailed comments for complex test scenarios to improve maintainability.
- Look into adding more edge cases and error scenarios to further improve test coverage.
Overall, great job on updating and expanding the test suite!
packages/ciphernode/evm/src/event_reader.rs (3)
66-69: Stop the actor context ifprovideris already takenWhen
self.providerisNone, the actor cannot proceed correctly. Simply returning might leave the actor running in an invalid state. Consider stopping the actor context withctx.stop()to gracefully shut down the actor.
74-77: Stop the actor context ifshutdownhas already been calledIf
self.shutdown_rxisNone, it indicates that the shutdown channel has already been consumed. Returning without stopping the actor may leave the actor in an inconsistent state. Consider callingctx.stop()to gracefully shut down the actor.
79-82: Handle potential errors in the spawned async taskAdd error handling to the spawned task to ensure that any errors during event streaming are properly logged, preventing silent failures.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/hooks.rs (4)
18-85: Code Review:FheFeatureimplementationThe
FheFeaturestruct and its implementation correctly handle the initialization and hydration of the FHE component. Error handling is properly managed, and dependencies are correctly utilized.
87-177: Code Review:KeyshareFeatureimplementationThe
KeyshareFeaturestruct appropriately handles the creation of the keyshare upon receiving theCiphernodeSelectedevent. The hydration method manages dependencies and error handling correctly, aligning with the system's requirements.
179-294: Code Review:PlaintextAggregatorFeatureimplementationThe implementation of
PlaintextAggregatorFeatureeffectively manages the initialization and hydration of the plaintext aggregator. Dependency checks and error reporting are correctly handled, ensuring robustness in the feature's lifecycle.
296-409: Code Review:PublicKeyAggregatorFeatureimplementationThe
PublicKeyAggregatorFeaturestruct and its methods correctly handle the setup and hydration of the public key aggregator. Dependency management and error handling are appropriately implemented, maintaining consistency with the other features.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
packages/ciphernode/data/src/sled_store.rs (1)
1-61: Overall implementation is solid with room for improvement.The
SledStoreimplementation provides a good foundation for database operations using Sled, aligning with the PR objectives for data persistence. The code structure is clear, and error handling is generally well-implemented.Key strengths:
- Proper integration with the Actix framework.
- Use of
anyhowfor comprehensive error handling.- Implementation of both
InsertandGetoperations.Areas for improvement:
- Consistency in error handling between
InsertandGethandlers.- Better handling of binary keys in error messages.
- Propagation of errors to callers for more flexible error management.
Next steps:
- Implement the suggested improvements for both
InsertandGethandlers.- Consider adding unit tests to ensure the reliability of the
SledStoreoperations.- Ensure that this implementation integrates well with the broader hydration strategy outlined in the PR objectives.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (1)
198-232: Consider enhancing error handling and logging infrom_snapshotThe
from_snapshotimplementation forE3RequestRouteris well-structured and correctly restores the router's state. However, consider enhancing error handling and adding logging for better diagnostics:
- Log when a context snapshot is missing (line 208).
- Consider collecting and reporting any errors encountered during context restoration, rather than silently continuing.
Example:
let mut errors = Vec::new(); for e3_id in snapshot.contexts { match repositories.context(&e3_id).read().await { Ok(Some(ctx_snapshot)) => { // ... (existing code to restore context) }, Ok(None) => { log::warn!("Missing context snapshot for e3_id: {}", e3_id); errors.push(anyhow!("Missing context for e3_id: {}", e3_id)); }, Err(e) => { log::error!("Error reading context snapshot for e3_id: {}: {}", e3_id, e); errors.push(e); } } } if !errors.is_empty() { log::warn!("Encountered {} errors during snapshot restoration", errors.len()); // Decide whether to return an error or continue with partial restoration }This approach provides more visibility into any issues during the snapshot restoration process.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (6)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/into_key.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/sled_store.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/snapshot.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/shutdown.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/event_reader.rs (1 hunks)
- packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (5 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (4)
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/into_key.rs
- packages/ciphernode/data/src/snapshot.rs
- packages/ciphernode/enclave_node/src/shutdown.rs
- packages/ciphernode/evm/src/event_reader.rs
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (2)
Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs:202-235 Timestamp: 2024-10-22T03:47:04.014Z Learning: In `packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs`, within the `E3RequestRouter::from_snapshot` method, errors during context restoration propagate upwards due to the `?` operator, and skipping contexts when `repositories.context(&e3_id).read().await?` returns `Ok(None)` is acceptable, as missing snapshots are expected.Learnt from: ryardley PR: gnosisguild/enclave#145 File: packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs:126-133 Timestamp: 2024-10-22T03:44:33.301Z Learning: In `E3RequestRouter::handle` method in `e3_request_router.rs`, `self.repository()` cannot fail, so it's not necessary to handle errors when accessing repositories via `self.repository().repositories()`.
🔇 Additional comments (10)
packages/ciphernode/data/src/sled_store.rs (4)
1-10: LGTM: Imports and struct definition are appropriate.The imports cover all necessary components, and the
SledStorestruct is well-defined with the required fields for database operations and event bus communication.
12-25: LGTM: Actor implementation and constructor are well-implemented.The
Actortrait implementation is correct, and thenewmethod effectively creates aSledStoreinstance. The error handling has been improved as per the previous suggestion, providing more detailed context when opening the database fails.
27-40: 🛠️ Refactor suggestionConsider improving error handling in the Insert handler.
While the current implementation is functional, it could be enhanced for better error handling and consistency with the
Gethandler. Consider the following improvements:
- Change the result type to
Result<()>to propagate errors to the caller.- Return the error after sending it to the event bus, allowing the caller to handle it if needed.
This change would improve error handling and make the
Inserthandler more consistent with theGethandler.Here's a suggested implementation:
impl Handler<Insert> for SledStore { type Result = Result<()>; fn handle(&mut self, event: Insert, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { self.db .insert(event.key(), event.value().to_vec()) .context("Could not insert data into db") .map_err(|err| { self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::Data, err.clone()); err }) } }
42-61: 🛠️ Refactor suggestionImprove key handling and error propagation in the Get handler.
The current implementation has a few areas for improvement:
- Key conversion: Using
String::from_utf8_lossymay not be appropriate for binary keys. Consider using a hexadecimal representation instead.- Error handling: Return a
Result<Option<Vec<u8>>>to propagate errors to the caller, allowing for better error handling.Here's a suggested implementation:
use hex; impl Handler<Get> for SledStore { type Result = Result<Option<Vec<u8>>>; fn handle(&mut self, event: Get, _: &mut Self::Context) -> Self::Result { let key = event.key(); let hex_key = hex::encode(&key); self.db .get(key) .with_context(|| format!("Failed to fetch key {}", hex_key)) .map_err(|err| { self.bus.err(EnclaveErrorType::Data, err.clone()); err }) .map(|opt| opt.map(|v| v.to_vec())) } }This implementation addresses both the key handling and error propagation issues.
packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs (6)
43-51: LGTM: Well-designedE3FeaturetraitThe new
E3Featuretrait is well-structured and properly uses the#[async_trait]attribute for the asynchydratemethod. This design allows for a more modular and extensible approach to handling events and hydration.
57-71: LGTM: ImprovedE3RequestRouterstructureThe changes to
E3RequestRouterand the introduction ofE3RequestRouterParamsreflect a well-thought-out transition to a feature-based system. The use ofArc<Vec<Box<dyn E3Feature>>>allows for efficient, thread-safe sharing of features, and the addition of thestorefield integrates the newDataStorefunctionality.
Line range hint
107-160: LGTM: Improved event handling with feature-based systemThe updated
Handler<EnclaveEvent>implementation effectively utilizes the new feature-based system. The logic for handling different event types is clear and modular. The addition of a checkpoint call after handling each event ensures data persistence, which is a good practice for maintaining system state.
Line range hint
1-268: Summary: Significant improvements with some minor enhancement opportunitiesThe changes to
E3RequestRouterand related components represent a substantial improvement in the code's architecture. The transition to a feature-based system and integration withDataStorealign well with the PR objectives and should enhance modularity and extensibility.Key improvements:
- Introduction of the
E3Featuretrait for better modularity.- Integration of
DataStorefor improved state management.- Implementation of snapshot functionality for persistence.
Suggestions for further enhancement:
- Reconsider the public visibility of
EventBuffer.- Improve error handling and logging in the
from_snapshotmethod.- Implement more granular event subscriptions.
Overall, these changes significantly improve the codebase, with only minor adjustments recommended for optimal performance and maintainability.
25-25: Consider the implications of makingEventBufferpublicThe
EventBufferstruct is now public. While this change may be intentional to allow external access, consider whether this level of visibility is necessary. If possible, keep internal structures private to maintain encapsulation and prevent unintended usage.✅ Verification successful
EventBufferis used inpackages/ciphernode/router/src/context.rs.Making it public allows necessary external access. Ensure this visibility is intended and aligns with encapsulation principles.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if EventBuffer is used outside this file rg "EventBuffer" --type rust --glob '!**/e3_request_router.rs'Length of output: 135
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if EventBuffer is used outside this file rg "EventBuffer" --type rust --glob "!packages/ciphernode/router/src/e3_request_router.rs"Length of output: 343
84-85: Consider error handling forCommitteeMetaFeaturecreationThe
CommitteeMetaFeatureis added by default, which is good for ensuring consistent base functionality. However, consider handling potential errors that might occur during its creation.If
create()can fail, consider updating the code to handle potential errors:-builder.add_feature(CommitteeMetaFeature::create()) +builder.add_feature(CommitteeMetaFeature::create().map_err(|e| anyhow!("Failed to create CommitteeMetaFeature: {}", e))?)
Closes: #123
Closes: #149
Sets up hydration for data persistence
Actors save and hydrate themselves to the db by implementing a set of traits:
Also I have tidied up the feature section:
This adds a few patterns to our codebase for creating checkpoints of state for our actors as outlined in #123
Summary by CodeRabbit
Release Notes
New Features
Shutdownevent type for graceful termination of the actor system.E3RequestContextfor better event handling and dependency management.EvmEventReaderfor better event processing from the Ethereum Virtual Machine.IntoKeytrait for flexible key handling and conversion.Repositoriesstruct for managing various repository types.Bug Fixes
Chores