content: linux coredumps

_drafts/linux_coredump.md

@@ -0,0 +1,312 @@
+---
+title: Coredumps at Memfault Part 1 - Introduction to Linux Coredumps
+description: Post Description (~140 words, used for discoverability and SEO)
+author: blake
+---
+
+One of the core features of the Memfault Linux SDK is the ability to capture and
+analyze crashes. Since the inception of the SDK we've been slowly expanding our
+crash capture and analysis capabilities. Starting from the standard ELF
+coredump, we've added support for capturing only the stack memory, and even
+capturing just the stack trace with no registers and locals present. This
+article series will give you a high level overview of that journey, and give you
+a deeper understanding of how coredumps work on Linux.
+
+<!-- excerpt start -->
+
+In this article we'll start by taking a look at how a Linux coredump is
+formatted, how you capture them, and how we use them at Memfault.
+
+<!-- excerpt end -->
+
+{% include newsletter.html %}
+
+{% include toc.html %}
+
+## What is a Linux Coredump
+
+A linux coredump represents a snapshot of the crashing process' memory. It is
+written as an ELF[^elf_format] file. The entirety of the ELF format is outside
+the scope of this article, but we will touch on a few of the more important bits
+when looking at an ELF core file.
+
+## What triggers a cordump
+
+Coredumps are triggered by certain signals generated by or sent to a program.
+The full list of signals can be found in the signal man page[^man_signal]. Here
+are the signals that cause a coredump:
+
+- SIGABRT: Abnormal termination of the program, such as a call to abort.
+- SIGBUS: Bus error (bad memory access).
+- SIGFPE: Floating-point exception.
+- SIGILL: Illegal instruction.
+- SIGQUIT: Quit from keyboard.
+- SIGSEGV: Invalid memory reference.
+- SIGSYS: Bad system call.
+- SIGTRAP: Trace/breakpoint trap.
+
+Of these the most common culprits you'll likely see are `SIGSEGV`, `SIGBUS`, and
+`SIGABRT`. These are signals that will be generated when a program tries to
+access memory that it doesn't have access to, tries to dereference a null
+pointer, or when the program calls `abort`. These typically indicate a fairly
+serious bug in either your program, or the libraries that it uses.
+
+Coredumps are very useful in these situations, as generally you're going to want
+to inspect the running state of the process a the time of crash. From the
+coredump you can get a backtrace of the crashing thread, the values of the
+registers at the time of crash, and the values of the local variables at each
+frame of the backtrace.
+
+## How are coredumps enabled/collected
+
+Enabling coredumps on your Linux device requires a few configuration options. To
+start with you'll need the following options enabled on your kernel at a
+minimum:
+
+```c
+CONFIG_COREDUMP=y
+CONFIG_CORE_DUMP_DEFAULT_ELF_HEADERS=y
+```
+
+These settings will enable the kernel to generate coredumps, as well as set the
+default mappings that are present in the coredump. `man core`[^man_core]
+provides a good overview of the options available to you when configuring
+coredumps.
+
+### core_pattern
+
+The kernel provides an interface for controlling where and how coredumps are
+written. The `/proc/sys/kernel/core_pattern`[^man_core] file provides two
+methods for capturing coredumps from crashed processes. A coredump can be
+written directly to a file by providing a path directly to it. For example if we
+wanted to write the core file to our `/tmp` directory with both the process name
+and the pid we would write the following to `/proc/sys/kernel/core_pattern`.
+
+```bash
+/tmp/core.%e.%p
+```
+
+In this example `%e` expands to the name of the crashing process, and `%p`
+expands to the PID of the crashing process. More information on the available
+expansions can be found in the `man core`[^man_core] page.
+
+We can also write pipe a coredump directly to a program. This is useful when we
+want to modify the coredump in flight. The coredump is streamed to the provided
+program via `stdin`. The configuration is similar to saving directly to a file
+except the first character must be a `|`. This is how we capture coredumps in
+the Memfault SDK, and will be covered more in depth later in the article.
+
+## Elf Core File Layout
+
+Linux coredumps use a subset of the ELF format. The coredump itself is a
+snapshot of the crashing process' memory, as well as some metadata to help
+debuggers understand the state of the process at the time of crash. We will
+touch on the most important aspects of the core file in this article. We will
+not be doing an exhaustive dive into the ELF format, however, if you are
+interested in learning more about the ELF format, the ELF File
+Format[^elf_format] is a great resource.
+
+![]({% img_url linux-coredump/elf-core-layout.png %})
+
+The above image gives us a very high level view of the layout of a coredump. The
+ELF header outlines the layout of the file and source of the file. We can see if
+the producing system was 32-bit or 64-bit, little or big endian, and the
+architecture of the system. Additionally it shows the offset to the program
+headers. Here is the layout of the ELF header[^elf_format]:
+
+```c
+typedef struct {
+  unsigned char e_ident[EI_NIDENT];
+  Elf32_Half e_type;
+  Elf32_Half e_machine;
+  Elf32_Word e_version;
+  Elf32_Addr e_entry;
+  Elf32_Off e_phoff;
+  Elf32_Off e_shoff;
+  Elf32_Word e_flags;
+  Elf32_Half e_ehsize;
+  Elf32_Half e_phentsize;
+  Elf32_Half e_phnum;
+  Elf32_Half e_shentsize;
+  Elf32_Half e_shnum;
+  Elf32_Half e_shstrndx;
+} Elf32_Ehdr;
+```
+
+There is a lot going on here, but the fields that are most important to our
+discussion are broken down below:
+
+- `e_ident`: This field is an array of bytes that identify the file as an ELF
+  file.
+- `e_type`: This field tells us what type of file we are looking at. For our
+  purposes this will always be `ET_CORE`.
+- `e_machine`: This field tells us the architecture of the system that produced
+  the file. Common values here are
+  [`EM_ARM`](https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/c45323b7560ec87c37c729b703c86ee65f136d75/include/uapi/linux/elf-em.h#L26)
+  for 32 bit ARM, and
+  [`EM_AARCH64`](https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/c45323b7560ec87c37c729b703c86ee65f136d75/include/uapi/linux/elf-em.h#L46)
+  for aarch64.
+- `e_phoff`: This field tells us the offset to the program headers.
+- `e_phentsize`: This field tells us the size of each program header.
+
+### Program Headers and Segments
+
+The meat of our coredump exists in the program headers. There are a wide variety
+of program header types defined in the Elf File Format[^elf_format]. From the
+perspective of the coredump, however, we are primarily interested in the
+`PT_NOTE` and `PT_LOAD` program headers.
+
+Program headers have the following layout[^elf_format]:
+
+```c
+typedef struct {
+  Elf32_Word p_type;
+  Elf32_Off p_offset;
+  Elf32_Addr p_vaddr;
+  Elf32_Addr p_paddr;
+  Elf32_Word p_filesz;
+  Elf32_Word p_memsz;
+  Elf32_Word p_flags;
+  Elf32_Word p_align;
+} Elf32_Phdr;
+```
+
+Here is a brief breakdown of the fields in the program header:
+
+- `p_type`: This field tells us what type of segment we are looking at. For our
+  purposes this will be either `PT_NOTE` or `PT_LOAD`.
+- `p_offset`: This field tells us the offset from the beginning of the file
+  where the segment starts.
+- `p_vaddr`: This field tells us the virtual address where the segment is
+  loaded.
+- `p_paddr`: This field tells us the physical address where the segment is
+  loaded.
+- `p_filesz`: This field tells us the size of the segment in the file.
+- `p_memsz`: This field tells us the size of the segment in memory.
+- `p_align`: This field tells us the alignment of the segment.
+
+We'll start by taking a look at the format of the `PT_NOTE` segments. Below is
+the layout of a `PT_NOTE` segment.
+
+![]({% img_url linux-coredump/elf-note-layout.png %})
+
+The first two fields of the segment are fairly self explanatory, they represent
+the size of both the name and the descriptor. The `name` field is a string that
+represents the type of note. The `desc` field is a structure that contains the
+actual data of the note. The type field tells us what type of note we are
+looking at. It is an unsigned integer that represents the type of note. It's
+worth noting that the `name` field works as a kind of namespace for the type
+field. Two notes with the same type field can be differentiated by their name
+field.
+
+The `PT_LOAD` segment is a bit more straightforward. This represents a segment
+of memory that was loaded into the process at the time of crash. These can
+represent either the stack, heap, or any other segment of memory that was loaded
+into the process.
+
+## `procfs` Shallow Dive
+
+An additional benefit to the `core_pattern` pipe interface is that until the
+program that is being piped to exits, we have access to the `procfs` of the
+crashing process. But what is `procfs`, and how does it help us with a coredump?
+
+`procfs` gives us direct, usually read-only, access to some of the kernel's data
+structures[^man_proc]. This can be system wide information, or information about
+individual processes. For our purposes we are interested mostly in the
+information about the process that is currently crashing. We can get direct read
+only access to all mapped memory by address through
+`/proc/<pid>/mem`[^man_proc_pid_mem], or look at the command line arguments of
+the process through `/proc/<pid>/cmdline`[^man_proc_pid_cmdline].
+
+## Coredumps at Memfault: Rev. 1
+
+Our first crack at coredumps at Memfault had one goal: leveraging existing tools
+to capture info about a crashing process. To have feature parity with our
+existing offerings we needed a few basic things:
+
+- A symbolicated backtrace for each running thread in the crashing process
+- The values of registers at the time of crash
+- Symbolicated local variables at each frame
+
+Based on what we've learned about Linux core files so far, they are an obvious
+fit for these requirements. We can use an established system to route
+information about crashed processes, add metadata that helps gives us
+information the device in question, and do all of this without making any source
+modifications to anything running on the system. For this reason our first pass
+at coredumps leave them largely untouched from what the kernel provides. The
+only addition is a note that contains the metadata we use to identify devices
+and the version of software they're running on. This takes advantage of the fact
+that the `PT_NOTE` segment is a free form segment that can be used to add any
+metadata we want to the coredump.
+
+This allows us to gather additional information about the process that crashed,
+and more easily stream memory to avoid unnecessary allocations or memory usage.
+
+Now that we've covered all the background information we can start to dive into
+the innards of the `memfault-core-handler`. First we use the pipe operation that
+was outlined earlier.
+[Here](https://github.com/memfault/memfault-linux-sdk/blob/49adfe0ce0cb6082360012b0f0092a31e8030048/meta-memfault/recipes-memfault/memfaultd/files/memfaultd/src/coredump/mod.rs#L14)
+is the pattern we write to `/proc/sys/kernel/core_pattern` to pipe the coredump
+to our handler:
+
+```bash
+|/usr/sbin/memfault-core-handler -c /path/to/config %P %e %I %s
+```
+
+This tells the kernel to pipe the coredump to our handler, and provides the
+handler with the PID of the crashing process, the name of the crashing process,
+the UID of the crashing process, and the signal that caused the crash.
+
+When a crash occurs the kernel will write the coredump to the `stdin` of the
+handler. The handler will then read all the program headers into memory. This
+sets us up to do two things. First we'll read all of the `PT_NOTE` segments and
+save them in memory. For the first iteration of the handler, we won't do
+anything further with them until we write them to a file. They'll become more
+important in later articles as we get into more of the special sauce of the
+handler.
+
+The next thing the handler does is read all of the memory ranges for each
+`PT_LOAD` segment in the coredump. Instead of storing this in memory we'll
+stream it directly to the output file from `/proc/<pid>/mem`. This is done to
+reduce the memory footprint of the handler, and prevent any issues where we
+would potentially need to seek backwards in the stream. As mentioned before,
+`stdin` is a one way stream, and we can't seek backwards in it.
+
+Now you're probably wondering, why did we go through all of this trouble to end
+up with a file that's largely the same as what the kernel would have produced?
+Well for one it allows us to add metadata to the coredump, but it also sets the
+stage for more advanced coredump handling in the future that we'll cover in the
+the next article.
+
+## Conclusion
+
+We've covered the basics of coredumps on Linux, and how they're used in the
+Memfault SDK. You should now have a pretty good idea of how things look under
+the hood. While the baseline coredumps are useful, and a known commodity, there
+are a few things that aren't great about them. The biggest issue is that they
+can be quite large for processes that have many threads, or do a large amount of
+memory allocation. This can be a large problem for embedded devices that may not
+have a lot of room to store large files. In the next article we'll take a look
+at the steps we've taken to reduce the size of coredumps.
+
+<!-- Interrupt Keep START -->
+
+{% include newsletter.html %}
+
+{% include submit-pr.html %}
+
+<!-- Interrupt Keep END -->
+
+{:.no_toc}
+
+## References
+
+<!-- prettier-ignore-start -->
+[^elf_format]: [ELF File Format](https://refspecs.linuxfoundation.org/elf/elf.pdf)
+[^man_core]: [`man core`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man5/core.5.html)
+[^man_proc]: [`man proc`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man5/procfs.5.html)
+[^man_proc_pid_mem]: [`man proc_pid_mem`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man5/proc_pid_mem.5.html)
+[^man_proc_pid_cmdline]: [`man proc_pid_cmdline`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man5/proc_pid_cmdline.5.html)
+[^man_ulimit]: [`man ulimit`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man3/ulimit.3.html)
+[^man_signal]: [`man signal`](https://www.man7.org/linux/man-pages/man7/signal.7.html)
+<!-- prettier-ignore-end -->

example/linux-coredump/boom.c

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+//! Compile. Run. Boom.
+
+void make_the_boom(void)
+{
+    int *p = 0;
+    *p = 0;
+}
+
+int main(void)
+{
+    make_the_boom();
+
+    return 0;
+}