Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Setting up a new Github Action Application for AI Support #2

Closed
wants to merge 89 commits into from

Conversation

DarrellRichards
Copy link
Collaborator

@DarrellRichards DarrellRichards commented Jun 3, 2024

Pull Request Body

Summary of Changes

This pull request includes several significant updates and improvements to streamline the development workflow and incorporate AI-enhanced code reviews. Below is a summary of the changes:

Node Setup and Dependency Management

  • Node Version Update: Updated the Node setup to use actions/setup-node@v4 and specified node-version: 18.
  • Dependency Installation and Build Steps: Added steps to install dependencies using npm install and to build the code using npm run build.
  • Package Updates:
    • Updated package-lock.json to reflect dependency changes.
    • Replaced the @tandil/diffparse dependency with @octokit/types.
    • Added parse-diff as a new dependency (version 0.11.1).

GitHub Action Enhancements

  • Action Tokens:
    • Updated the token key from github-token to github_token.
    • Updated the openai_api_key parameter name.
  • New Inputs:
    • Introduced excluded_files parameter to exclude specific files from the process.
    • Added generate_summary input to generate Pull Request summaries based on git diffs and code changes (optional, defaults to false).
    • Added overall_code_review input for providing an overall code review as a comment (optional, defaults to false).
  • Input Section Updates:
    • Updated the inputs section of action.yml to include excluded_files instead of pr_number.
    • Set a default value for excluded_files.

Code and Script Updates

  • Code Import Modernization: Transitioned from using require statements to import statements for various modules (parse-diff, fs, @actions/core, etc.).
  • Input Constants Definition: Defined constants for inputs like excluded_files, generate_summary, review_code, and overall_code_review using core.getInput.
  • New Interfaces and Functions:
    • Added a new Details interface to structure the pull request's title and description.
    • Extracted logic for validating pull requests, code, and providing overall reviews into distinct asynchronous functions: validatePullRequest, validateCode, and validateOverallCodeReview.
    • Introduced the compareCommits function for obtaining and comparing commit data, ensuring operations only target files not in the excludedFiles list.
  • Main Function Refinement:
    • Refined the main function to trigger validations based on GitHub Actions events (opened or synchronize).
    • Delegated tasks such as updating the pull request body and commenting with feedback based on diff data.
    • Integrated comprehensive logging for better debugging and flow tracking.

AI Integration

  • New AI Service Functions: Implemented a set of functions in src/services/ai.ts to interact with the OpenAI API for generating AI-based responses and summaries.
    • createMessage: Generates a message for AI review requests.
    • prSummaryCreation: Creates a pull request summary.
    • obtainFeedback: Creates detailed feedback for pull requests.
    • summaryOfAllFeedback: Merges multiple feedbacks into one aggregate feedback.
    • summaryAllMessages: Merges multiple summaries into one comprehensive summary.
    • validateCodeViaAI: Validates code changes via AI and returns review comments.

GitHub Service Integration

  • New GitHub Service Functions: Added a file src/services/github.ts to interface with GitHub's API using the @octokit/rest package, implementing functions such as:
    • PRDetails
    • commentOnPullRequest
    • updateBody
    • gitDiff
    • createReviewComment
    • compareCommits

Overall, these updates enhance the efficiency of the development and review process, leveraging modern tools and AI capabilities to provide detailed, automated code reviews and summaries.

Copy link

github-actions bot commented Jun 3, 2024

Summary of Changes

Logging Improvements

  • Console Log Addition:
    • A console.log statement has been introduced to output the summary of all messages in the validatePullRequest function.
    • This addition is helpful for debugging, ensuring the function generates the expected summary of all messages.
    • Recommendation: Transitioning to a more sophisticated logging mechanism or a logger library would be beneficial for production environments to manage log levels and avoid performance issues.

Code Refactoring

  • Conditional Structure Refactoring:
    • The conditional structure responsible for generating and incorporating detailed code review feedback into pull requests has been refactored.
    • The new implementation replicates the functionality outside the commented section, improving code clarity and logically separating feedback generation and application.
    • Suggestions:
      • Remove the commented-out code entirely to avoid confusion and maintain code cleanliness.
      • Add error handling for asynchronous calls such as validateOverallCodeReview, summaryOfAllFeedback, and commentOnPullRequest to enhance reliability and debuggability.
      • Document the steps and purposes within the new structure for future maintainability.

Code Cleanup

  • Trailing Whitespace Removal:

    • An unnecessary trailing whitespace at line 94 in the obtainFeedback function in src/services/ai.ts has been removed.
    • This minor cleanup improves code quality and adheres to coding standards.
    • Recommendation: Consider using a linter or an automated code formatter as part of the build process to ensure a uniform code style across the codebase.
  • Unnecessary Console Log Removal:

    • The statement console.log('feedbacks', feedbacks); has been removed to prevent console clutter in production code.
    • The instruction text has been updated from 'written as a Github Comment format' to 'as a Github Pull Request Body' for clarity on the context of the output.

Enhancements and Recommendations

  • Function Improvement:
    • The summaryOfAllFeedback function can be made more robust and maintainable with type annotations for parameters and return values.
    • Adding error handling to manage potential issues during feedback merging is recommended.

Overall Assessment

  • The changes made improve code readability, maintainability, and quality. They align the process with what is required for a Github Action application, ensuring clarity and ease of use.
  • By further incorporating error handling, type safety, and documentation, the overall reliability and maintainability of the code can be significantly enhanced.
  • This refactoring delivers the same functional outcome while presenting a cleaner and more logical flow of the feedback processing system.

}
}
}

Copy link

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Consider removing or disabling this console.log statement once you have verified that the summary generation is working correctly, to keep the code clean and avoid unnecessary logging in production.

const diff = parser.parseDiffString(dif);
const filteredDiff = diff.filter((file: { to: any; }) => {
const diff = parseDiff(dif);
const filteredDiff = diff.filter((file) => {
return !excludedFiles.some((pattern) =>
minimatch(file.to ?? "", pattern)
);
});
Copy link

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

The commented-out code block beginning at line 179 appears to be redundant as the functionality has been reintroduced immediately after the commented section. Consider removing the commented-out block for improved code readability and maintainability.

- Provide a detailed feedback of the pull request based on the diff below.
- Please write the result in Github Markdown Format.
- Provide the written feedback in the following JSON format: {"feedback": [{"changesOverview": "<changesOverview>", "feedback": "<feedback", "improvements", "<improvements>", "conclusion": "<conclusion>"}]}.

Copy link

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

There seems to be an unused empty line here. It would be more concise to remove it for cleaner code.

}

export async function summaryOfAllFeedback(feedbacks: any[]) {
const systemMessage = `
Copy link

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Unnecessary logging statement console.log('feedbacks', feedbacks); has been removed, this change helps to clean the code by eliminating potentially verbose debugging output.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant